CONSCIENCE AND FEELING AS A GUIDE.
By D. T. Bourdeau
ARE conscience and feeling always a safe and sufficient guide? Any candid, unbiased person who will look at this question in the light of Scripture, reason, and experience, must answer it negatively, notwithstanding a growing tendency on the part of many to go by feeling and conscience, utterly disregarding the plain teachings of Holy Writ, to which their course is often in direct opposition. If conscience and feeling were always a safe and sufficient guide in matters of religious faith and practice, there would be no necessity for a divine revelation, and God would not have given us the Bible. He does not deal in superfluities. He gave us a revelation, because he knew we needed it to enlighten and govern our consciences and mold our feelings. A safe and infallible guide, or rule of conduct, cannot contradict itself; but feeling and conscience do contradict themselves. They lead some heathens to cast themselves under the car of Juggernaut, and others to look upon such an act with abhorrence. They lead some professors of Christianity to attach great importance to certain religious practices, while others discard the same practices as dangerous. Who will say that the poor Hindu who decides to be crushed by the ponderous car of Juggernaut has not deep and pungent feelings, or that he is devoid of conscience? But is he right? Are his feelings and conscience a safe criterion? Freeman, of Pocasset, Mass., was in a certain sense conscientious, and no doubt had deep feeling, when he committed the atrocious crime of murdering his little daughter, under the pretense of following the example of Abraham. But we all say that his conscience was perverted, and he greatly erred in suffering his feelings and impressions3 to usurp the throne of reason, mold his conscience, and lead him to commit a terrible crime. Feeling leads the drunkard to go to the intoxicating cup, till he is bereft of reason, and degrades himself beneath the brute beasts. I hold in my hand a brass medal on which are stamped these words: “O Marie, conçue sans péché, priez pour nous qui avons recours à vous: O Mary, conceived without sin, pray for us who have recourse to thee.” This medal was presented to me twenty-five years ago, by an intelligent Catholic lady, with the urgent request that I should wear it. She believed that it would have virtue to make me a good Roman Catholic. And to inspire in me faith in the virtue of this medal, she related the following anecdote:— “There was once a widow who had an only son, who left home, went to the States, and was persuaded to embrace the Protestant faith. After awhile he returned home. His mother did all she could to have him return to the Catholic Church; but all her efforts were ineffectual, until, with deep emotion, and by the spirit of inspiration, she took a similar medal, and opening her son's mouth, dropped it in. He threw it up; but it had the desired effect upon him; it made him a Roman Catholic, or [to use her own words], led him to do his religion as formerly.” This she told me with deep feeling, tears falling freely. I could not help respecting her honesty, conscientiousness, and good intentions; but all this did not satisfy my mind that she was right. My conscience and feeling did not agree with hers. I wanted Bible evidence. It would always be safe to follow conscience and feeling, had they never been perverted by sin. Now it is safe to follow them only so far as they agree with the Bible, which God has given us to regulate our naturally perverse natures, and bring them into harmony with his righteous will. There is a change in man's feelings and conscience at conversion. This is the first great step toward bringing the feelings into harmony with the will of God; the conscience receives more light, and is quickened and strengthened for the right, so that it reproves for sins upon which it was once silent, and condemns in thunder tones sins against which it once spoke but faintly; and a plainer copy of the law of God is written on the heart and in the conscience. But are we to believe that the Christian should undergo no further changes in his conscience and feelings? Who will dare take this position? No one who has advanced in the Christian life. As greater light shines upon our characters, and we see more of the will of God and more of our defects, we feel deeply over sins that we did not see when we were converted, and our conscience condemns us for those sins as it did for other sins at that time. Although the word feeling is so often used in our times in a manner to make one think that feeling should be the criterion par excellence in matters of religious faith and practice, yet this word occurs but twice in the English Bible (Eph. 4:19; Heb. 4:15); and in neither of these instances are we taught or commanded to go by feeling, or to follow feeling. Nor is conscience set forth in the Bible as a safe guide under all circumstances. We read not only of “a good conscience,” “a pure conscience,” “a conscience void of offense,” but also of “an evil conscience,” a conscience that “is defiled,” of a conscience that is “seared,” or hardened, of a conscience that is “weak,” and of one that needs to be purged from “dead works,” etc. (Acts 23:1; 24:6; 1 Tim. 1:5, 19; 3:9; Heb. 10:22; Titus 1:15; 1 Tim. 4:2; 1 Cor. 8:12; Heb. 9:14.) Now if we were to follow conscience in all these cases, we should certainly pursue a zigzag course in forming character. How evident it is that our belief, education, and lives mold our consciences and feelings. And how easy it is to harden the heart or conscience through “unbelief,” “the deceitfulness of sin,” and by not walking in the light of truth when it shines on our pathway. It is in this way that that state is reached styled by the apostle “past feeling” (Eph. 4:19); i. e., unfeeling as to doing right and shunning wrong, but possessing feeling, intensified, hellish feeling, to commit sin with greediness. The subject is well illustrated by the adaptation of the ear to the rumbling of the cars, or to the loud noise of a saw-mill. At first, the noise distracts, and it is difficult to sleep; but gradually we become accustomed to it, until we can sleep soundly on the cars while they are jostling over rough roads, or by a gang of saws in motion. We would not despise conscience as a faculty that God has implanted in man. Let it be respected, even in the sinner, because of the faint copy of God's holy law that is seen in it. Let its feeble light in the sinner be made use of to turn him into the paths of righteousness. But let the light of divine truth be made to shine in it more and more, and let it be educated and sanctified. Let the law of God be written in it more distinctly, that it may be a more faithful monitor. Nor would we discard sanctified feeling; feeling that agrees with the word of God, that results from obedience to God, and goes with, and is strengthened by, the blessings of the Spirit of God. An increase of this feeling is evidence of advancement in Christian experience. What we protest against is making conscience and feeling an independent and infallible guide, and following them to the neglect of the word of God and in opposition to it. Whenever feeling and conscience are opposed to the Bible, they may be safely pronounced evil, however much men may praise and exalt them. It is very selfish and dangerous to put feeling in the front, and reach out after good feeling, even the blessings of the Spirit, regardless of the relations we sustain to the word of God. It is like a man who hires out to another for a given period, and asks pay before he has complied with the conditions,—done the work. It is despising God's authority that runs through his word, grieving the Spirit of truth, dethroning reason by putting impressions in its stead, and opening a wide door for fanaticism, and for Satan to come in with his deceptions.