In a recent number of Harper’s Magazine, the writer of an article entitled the “Isms of Forty Years Ago,” endeavors to give currency to the stories about ascension-robes which have so often appeared in the public prints in connection with the name of William Miller and the Advent movement of 1844, in the use of the following language: “In New York, as Mrs. Child records, at a shop in the Bowery, muslin for ascension robes was offered.”
In these words there is found an oft-repeated scandal which is of but little importance now, so far as Mr. Miller is concerned, as he long since passed beyond the reach of the tongue of slander, but which, though oft-refuted, should not be allowed to go unchallenged on this occasion, lest it should accomplish the purpose designed by the enemy of all truth in its promulgation, by prejudicing honest minds against the important work in which Mr. Miller was engaged. Such was the extent of that work, and such the nature of the soul-stirring themes which were handled by its author in presenting the doctrine of the near coming of Christ, that it would indeed be remarkable if the work itself had not been marred by more or less extravagance on the part of a few of its adherents. He who is best acquainted with the history of great religious movements is well aware that they have ever been characterized by more or less excess on the part of those participating in them.
This was true even of those who were intimately related to Christ in the incipient history of his work. Again and again it was necessary for him to repress with a strong hand the tendency to extreme acts on the part of his followers. Illustrations of this will be found in his rebuke of James and John when they desired to call down fire from Heaven to consume the citizens of the Samaritan town, because they would not receive Christ; also in the act of reproving the disciples for rejecting one who was capable of casting out devils, simply because he did not follow them.
In Martin Luther’s day, also, fanaticism was again and again rebuked by him when developing itself in the persons of those whose weaker intellect and shattered nervous organisms induced them to fancy that they were led by the Spirit to do a thousand things which calmer-minded men perceived to be of a nature to seriously injure the cause of God.
John Wesley, furthermore, found it necessary continually—when preaching his views concerning perfect love—to hold in check numbers of individuals who could never distinctly discern the line between truth and fanaticism.
These things being so, there is left us but one of two alternatives. We must either decide that God has never done any work in the earth, or else we must frankly admit that isolated cases in which individuals connected with his cause have held extreme views, do not prove that he did not give general direction to the movement with which they were connected. So far as William Miller is concerned personally, it is even possible that, like Martin Luther, he might have been seriously defective in certain points of character, and still, on the whole, have been an instrument in the hand of Providence of throwing important light upon certain Scripture doctrines. If he possessed such defects, however, those who knew him best find it the most difficult to point them out. It has never yet been our fortune to meet one who was intimately acquainted with him who did not both love and admire the man. In a very able and impartial article recently written concerning him, we find the following estimate of his qualities of head and heart, as well as a description of his person and style of preaching:—
“As a man, Mr. Miller is described as strictly temperate in all his habits, devoted in his family and social attachments, and proverbial for his integrity. He was naturally very amiable in his temperament, affable and attentive to all, a kind-heartedness, simplicity, and power peculiarly original characterizing his manner. He was of about medium stature, a little corpulent; hair, a light glossy brown; countenance full and round, with a peculiar depth of expression in his blue eye, of shrewdness and love. As a preacher, Mr. Miller was generally spoken of as convincing his hearers of his sincerity and instructing them by his reasoning and information. All acknowledged that his lectures were replete with useful and interesting matter, showing a knowledge of Scripture very extensive and minute—that of the prophecies, especially, being surprisingly familiar; and his application of the prophecies to the great events which have taken place in the moral and natural world, was, to say the least, ingenious and plausible. There was nothing very peculiar in his manner. His gestures were easy and expressive; his style decorous, simple, natural, and forcible. He was always self-possessed and ready; distinct in his utterance, and frequently quaint in his observations; in the management of his subject, exhibiting much tact, holding frequent colloquies with the objector and inquirer, supplying the questions and answers himself in a very apposite manner, and, although grave himself, sometimes producing a smile upon the faces of his auditors.”
The same writer, in alluding to the numerous reports concerning the improprieties committed by those who were engaged in what is known as the ’44 movement, bears the following very pertinent testimony: “That irregularities of one kind and another attended a religious movement so wide-spread, intense, and enthusiastic as this, is not to be wondered at; but it is doubtless true that the majority of the incidents thus circulated were the easy inventions of opponents.” Such a confession from one who was not himself an Adventist, should put us on our guard, lest we unwittingly do injustice to a great and good man, by giving currency to a scandal which may have originated in the malevolence of those who hated Christ, and persecuted his followers by willfully misrepresenting them.
The safest rule by which to judge of the course of any party or sect, will be found in a full acceptance of the testimony of their friends, unless it can be shown that they are so far warped in judgment or dishonest in purpose that their statement cannot be relied upon. Applying this principle to the case in hand, we find that all the friends of Mr. Miller are united in insisting that the story of the ascension robes is utterly devoid of foundation. Again and again it has been repudiated by them in the public prints. Thousands of those who long since decided that Mr. Miller was mistaken in some of his views, still insist that this story is the sheerest fabrication.
Furthermore, this uniform testimony on their part is rendered most credible when we consider the probabilities of the case. Who does not perceive that it is utterly unreasonable to suppose that the thing in question ever took place? No candid mind, when he considers the scope of the ’44 movement, and the extent to which the whole world was stirred by it, can doubt that the men who were behind it were possessed of more than ordinary intelligence. Mr. Miller himself delivered more than three thousand lectures in ten years, during which time he was compelled to meet and combat some of the ablest men of the age. No fool could have been adequate to this task. So cool, calm, and calculating was he, that it is said that in those ten years of free discussion he was never asked a single question which he had not previously anticipated in his own mind. That which was true of him was, to a greater or less extent, true of the influential leaders in the movement. Is it to be presumed that such men could be duped into the ridiculous farce of actually making and putting on robes composed of white cotton cloth, in the expectation that they would ascend in them to meet the Lord in the air? The proposition is too absurd to admit of discussion.
When we stop for a moment to consider the sentiments entertained by these men concerning the manner in which they expected to be translated at the coming of Christ, the most casual observer will perceive the utter untruthfulness of the ascension-robe scandal. Mr. Miller and his co-laborers who expected that Christ would come on the tenth day of the seventh month in 1844 (Jewish time), well knew that there could not a vestige of such a garment ever come into the presence of the Lord. They were perfectly familiar with the whole theory of translation, and often expounded those scriptures which plainly teach that nothing which bears the taint of that corruption which attaches to everything belonging to this world can be translated to Heaven; that even our bodies are vile in his sight; and that when Christ comes, they are, for this reason, to be entirely transformed before they can be caught up to meet the Lord in the air.
Such being the case, we repeat that it is simply absurd to suppose for a moment that such men could have fallen into the ridiculous theory that there could be either wisdom or utility in arraying themselves as it is charged they did.
Do you ask, then, how the stories came to be current? I answer that they had their origin either in that disposition which the grossly wicked always manifest to burlesque every great religious movement, or else in unpardonable ignorance of what the Adventists really taught.
The book of Revelation is filled with highly wrought figures. It often speaks of the redeemed in the world to come as wearing white robes. These garments it also defines to be robes of righteousness; i. e., the white linen in which the heavenly host appear to be clothed is not real, but is simply typical of their spotless characters and purity of heart. How natural that those who expected so soon to join the heavenly throng should encourage one another, as Christians do now at times, by frequent allusions to these typical robes, and palms, and crowns. How natural, too, that opponents, either through ignorance or malice, should pervert these expressions to an unholy use by making them the basis of the scandal which we are endeavoring to refute.
Should it be replied that while it is undoubtedly true that Mr. Miller or his immediate associates were not guilty of the irregularity in question, but that there were a few of the more ignorant who did really put on the white robes, we reply that even were this true, it would be utterly unjust to judge the whole movement by the act of a little handful of hare-brained fanatics.
Furthermore, we express it as our firm conviction, resulting from frequent conversation with individuals who were prominent actors in227the ’44 movement, that there was not a solitary case in which a man, woman, or child ever put on an ascension robe in the expectation of being caught up to meet the Lord in the air.
As additional evidence that we are right in this, we cite the following from the pen of Eld. James White, who was a prominent Adventist for many years, and who was also associated with Mr. Miller in proclaiming the coming of Christ in 1844:—
“In almost every place where our ministers give discourses upon the second coming of Christ and the necessary preparation for that event, they have to labor against the prejudices of the people caused by reports of the inconsistencies of Adventists; one of which is, that at a point of expectation in the past, many of them did prepare robes of white linen and put them on, ready to ascend and meet their coming Lord. . . . But I do not believe that anything of the kind ever occurred. I have been actively engaged in the proclamation of the doctrine of the second advent for more than twenty-five years, and have traveled and preached in Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Rhode Island, New York, Ohio, Michigan, Illinois, Wisconsin, Iowa, and Canada, and have not met a person who has seen an Adventist thus attired, or one who was able to give better proofs that anything of the kind ever did occur than vague reports. I have never found the place where the thing occurred. It was always in the next town, county, or State. Again, reports in relation to this matter, and slanders of a similar nature, have a hundred times been denied in second-advent periodicals, and proofs have been called for of the truthfulness of these statements. No one has been able to produce the proofs; but still the tongue of slander takes delight in repeating the old thread-bare falsehood.”
From among the friends and co-workers of Mr. Miller we shall introduce another witness in the person of Josiah Litch. For years he was the editor of the Advent Herald, published at Boston. He also edited a very able history of the rise and progress of Adventism. From the latter we take the following, as quoted in Life Incidents, p. 314:—
“These periods came and passed with no unusual occurrence. As soon as they had gone by, a flood of scoffing, reviling, and persecution burst forth, not from the infidel world so much, but from the professed friends of the Saviour. The most idle and foolish stories of ascension robes, and going out into the graveyards to watch, going to the tops of houses, etc., etc. These were repeated again and again, both from pulpit and press, until the public were, many of them, at least, almost persuaded to believe them true.
“How or where they originated, except in willful falsehood, we cannot devise. Some of the reports of that character, we happen to know, originated with professed ministers of the gospel, who gave date and place, when there was not a word of truth in the whole story. Others must have originated in a similar way.”
Thus much for the testimony of these individuals. The opportunities which they have had for obtaining all the facts in the case have been such that it would be difficult to bring forward more competent witnesses than they are.
Leaving, therefore, that line of evidence for one equally conclusive, if not more so, we introduce the following item published in the REVIEW AND HERALD of April 14, 1868:—
“Fifty dollars reward is offered to any person who will present unquestionable proofs of the truthfulness of the statement that believers in the second advent of Christ, on the day of expectation, did put on ascension robes. Those who can produce such proofs are requested to forward them immediately to the writer, at Greenville, Montcalm Co., Mich., and receive fifty dollars by return mail.”
The object in publishing the foregoing was that of furnishing a practical test of the untruthfulness of the ascension-robe slander. Up to the present time, but one man has ever endeavored to make out a case entitling him to the reward. The facts proved that his inordinate inquisitiveness had made him the victim of a practical joke, and that the ascension robes in question were nothing more, and nothing less, than certain night-dresses, similar in material and make-up to those found in every lady’s wardrobe.
Who does not perceive that such a result should satisfy every candid person that the charges in question, brought against the followers of Mr. Miller, are purely mythical in their character? Thousands are now living who were eye-witnesses of the events connected with the disappointment of 1844, whose recollection of these events is still so distinct that they are competent to make oath in the premises, provided they have ever seen that which it is claimed they have witnessed. Besides the ordinary motives which would naturally lead them to the divulgence of the facts in the case, there has been presented to them the additional inducement of fifty dollars reward, provided they would prove the things alleged. He who is acquainted with the rancor which has characterized the opposition to Adventism, and who knows also the cupidity of the men of these times, will readily discover that the reason why they have let this opportunity slip of injuring their opponents and gratifying their greed of gain, is only to be found in their inability to make the necessary proofs.
Here, then, we bring this article to a close. We have shown, first, that it is utterly unreasonable to suppose—when we take into consideration the views concerning translation which were held by Mr. Miller and his friends, as well as their general character for intelligence—that they ever did put on ascension robes. Secondly, that taking the testimony of the men themselves who were concerned in the ’44 movement—which is really the best evidence that could be obtained—we find them unanimous in declaring that the stories under consideration were the inventions of unreasonable and bitter opponents. Thirdly, we have introduced the testimony of two witnesses, whose circumstances have been most favorable for obtaining a complete knowledge of the facts, that they have never been able to find a single man by whom any Adventist has at any time been seen attired in an ascension robe. Fourthly, we have introduced an extract published in the ADVENT REVIEW, showing that a reward of fifty dollars was at one time offered to any person who could prove that Adventists have at any time donned ascension robes as claimed, and that no one has ever brought forward the necessary proof.
That these considerations should be regarded as conclusive in the matter, we think will be conceded by any unprejudiced mind. It is not anticipated, however, that they will put an end to the scandal; for the enemy of all truth has used it very successfully heretofore in prejudicing the minds of the unwary against the doctrine of the Second Advent, and it is not to be doubted that he will continue this nefarious course for time to come. All that the writer of this article hopes is that it may be the means, with the blessing of God, of dispelling from the minds of those who are not so prejudiced that they cannot weigh evidence, the delusions under which many have been laboring in this matter. If his desires in this respect shall be gratified, and if those who shall by this effort become convinced that Mr. Miller and his co-laborers have been grossly misrepresented in the charges passing under review, will have the candor and the courage to denounce the scandal, he will be abundantly rewarded for his labor.