Garfield and the Infidel.
By John Wentworth
Many pleasant and complimentary things have been said and written concerning our late lamented President, all showing his quickness and breadth of mind and his adherence to right principles. But probably in none of them does he appear in a role to stir more deeply the heart of the God-fearing American citizen than in the following incident, in which he acts as the champion of the Bible and its humble adherents:— If Garfield did not have his facts when a measure was introduced, he would “read up” during the night, and surprise the whole house with his facts and arguments the next morning. That story of Col. Conwell’s as to how he squelched Prof. Denton, the spiritualist, gives a clear idea of how he used sometimes to surprise his fellow-members in Congress. Prof. Denton gave a series of lectures at Chagrin Falls, and attempted to prove by scientific discoveries that the Bible could not be true. In the course of his discussion he had been able to convince quite a number of people, and it began to be boldly asserted on the streets and in the factories that the Bible was only an ingenious fable. The professor was a critical scholar, and had a very plausible way of stating his theories; and there was no one found to withstand his arguments. Ministers attacked him, but only with invectives, which did more harm than good. Teachers and public speakers often ridiculed him, but such things only avail against a shallow reasoner, or one manifestly unpopular. Prof. Denton was gaining the thinking men and women, and felt sure, as his adherents boasted, “of shutting up the churches and abolishing the Bible from Chagrin Falls.” It was one of those strange, almost unaccountable freaks of public opinion, and men were drawn into it who, all their lives, had been the most orthodox believers in the Holy Bible. The churches of the Disciples viewed the success of Professor Denton with the deepest dismay. The church at Chagrin Falls seemed in danger of annihilation, and the whole denomination viewed its tottering condition with great alarm. It happened that the noted professor had one weak point, illustrating the truth of that book he was endeavoring to overturn, wherein it says that “great men are not always wise.” He had a habit of boasting, and one evening he went so far as to challenge any and every believer of the Bible in Ohio to refute his statements. He offered the use of the hall and ample time to any person who dared to undertake the task. At length the listeners who adhered to the Bible thought of Mr. Garfield. They had heard him preach at Chagrin Falls and in the surrounding country towns, and they felt that, if any man could cope with the learned professor, it would be he. They felt that some one must champion their cause, or all would be lost. In a distress of mind not easily realized by people living in other portions of the religious world, these sincere and sorrowful Christians turned to Mr. Garfield for help. At first, he declined to meet the professor, thinking it unbecoming a Christian man to debate such questions in a public hall. But the continued petition of his friends and the alarm of the churches, caused him at last to consent, and a committee of citizens was appointed to arrange for the public discussion. It was a great day at Chagrin Falls, and one which will not soon be forgotten, when these two champions met in the arena of serious, earnest, religious debate. Mr. Garfield had never heard Prof. Denton, and was consequently supposed to be ignorant of just the position the professor would take. But Mr. Garfield had been too wise to risk a cause which he believed so holy to the impulses and guesses of an impromptu speech; and, as soon as he knew that he was to meet the professor, he had taken steps to find out the arguments which the infidel used. Having ascertained privately that the professor was to lecture on the same topic in a distant part of the State before the date of the discussion, Mr. Garfield had sent a friend to hear these lectures, and write them out for his use. Of course the professor knew nothing of this, and had no doubt of his ability to silence a man who had not made science a special study. When, however, Mr. Garfield had received the copies of the lectures, he had at once sent in various directions and procured the latest scientific books, together with those the professor had quoted as being against the Bible. He had also obtained learned opinions of distinguished scholars, and before the day of discussion, was thoroughly armed with arguments and authorities. When the hour came for the discussion, the hall was crowded to suffocation, by an eager, and, on the part of the Disciples, an almost breathless audience. But they did not lose faith in Mr. Garfield. They thought that, if any one could overcome the learned professor, they had secured the right man. The professor, amid the smiles of his followers, and with a perfect confidence in his ability, opened the debate with his statement of scientific facts, and their bearing on the accounts of creation and the miracles in the Bible. The professor did not try to be precise and accurate in all his statements; for he was sure Mr. Garfield would not attack him on scientific ground; and, when he stated any difficult question, he very kindly explained it in “simple language” for Mr. Garfield’s better understanding. He repeated, however, almost verbatim, the lecture of which Mr. Garfield had a copy. Mr. Garfield said nothing until his turn came, and when he arose, it was apparent to all that the professor had predisposed the audience in favor of infidelity. When, however, Mr. Garfield coolly, and with a readiness and knowledge which really astounded his hearers, took up the professor’s arguments, one by one, and, quoting voluminously from books and history, used the professor’s own authorities against him, and piled up unanswerable names above them, there was such a sudden overturning as an earthquake might make. It seemed miraculous to the people, who very reasonably supposed that Mr. Garfield had not heard the professor’s arguments before. The professor had the closing speech to make, but he saw that he had lost the battle, and that his forces were too thoroughly routed to be rallied again. So, while he claimed that with further research he could yet establish his theories, he manfully admitted that he was surprised and defeated, for the time, by the apparently inexhaustible learning of his opponent. He said it was the first time he had met so gifted and learned an adversary. Of course, the tide of unbelief in the Scriptures was stayed.—John Wentworth, in Boston Herald.