A PRIEST of Lisieux, France, L'Abbé Valin, has addressed the following letter to the pope. It has been published in several French papers, and on this side the water appears in the New York Observer. We doubt if Pope Leo is often treated to such bold and truthful statements as are here presented for his consideration:—
Most Holy Father: It is with deep humility that I venture to implore you to consider how that the proud doctrine of papal domination over the church, governments, and people, has never tended to promote the true prosperity of the Holy See. In truth, it has been the chief cause of the Greek schism, of the Anglican, of Protestantism, and will be the cause of the separation of church and State now threatening France.
Consider if the crises through which the church is now passing be not due to the same cause; if the loss of temporal power, and the strange situation of the pope confined as a penitent to the Vatican, seem not as a chastisement from God.
The pope has assumed the place of God and of Christ on earth; he has taken upon himself the whole authority of the church; he has constituted himself the master of the apostolic and catholic faith. To render account of that faith, believers may consign to oblivion Jesus Christ in the heavens; they have no need to trace the apostolic tradition back to him; the pope is sufficient; he is infallible; he is, so says the council of the Vatican, the perpetual principle and the visible foundation of the faith. Is it surprising that God should chastise such doctrines,—doctrines that shock Christianity, and ravage the soul with doubt and unbelief? God resisteth the proud.
Ah, with what truth did Pope Saint Bernard warn Eugène and all popes: “There is no prison, no sword, that I fear for you, as I fear the passion for domination!”
If the pope maintains these doctrines, peace is impossible; there remains nothing but war, determined war against the clergy. One will have but to wait to see revolution unchained upon the church, the pope abandoned, the bishops humiliated, the clergy beggared and trampled upon in the sanctuary, convents dispersed, and by a kind of official schism in France, the separation of church and State; so manifestly does the ultramontanism excite only indignation, and lead to the overthrow of religion.
But if, on the contrary, his holiness Pope Leo XIII. will but search his own conscience, recognizing in himself the frailty and infirmity that clothes us all, and in a spirit of humility and truth render glory to God in saying to Jesus Christ, “Thou only art holy; thou only art the Lord; thou only art most high; thou alonep. 4 canst neither deceive nor be deceived, for thou alone art God;” if he will but comprehend that this is the apostolic faith, this the Catholic teaching, the Catholic belief, this the testimony determining the true doctrine of Jesus Christ, the true Catholic dogma, and that thus infallibility comes through the church to him, and not through him to the church,—oh, then, as by magic, would peace return to the church, calm to troubled consciences, good will to the clergy, and security to religious establishments. Then would the pope once more win back souls to the holy Catholic, Apostolic Roman Church, and would establish the reign of Jesus Christ on earth. Then might he proudly descend the steps of his palace without the Vatican, blessed of God and man.
It is necessary to feel penetrated by the strongest convictions, and animated by the truest sentiments, to dare, holy father, thus to address you; it is the heart of a devoted priest speaking in humility before you and God; nor do I hesitate to say, “Anathema be this writing if it be not true, if it be not profitable, or if I be only a child of Jemini, vociferating to the injury of the pope and the Vatican.”