The following communication from a Boston correspondent of the Christian at Work was published in its issue of Nov. 16, under the above heading, with the editor’s reply, as given below, in brackets:—
Will you be so kind as to give a bit of information to one who is dreadfully dull and stupid? This is the case: Joseph Henry Allen, a Professor in Harvard, has just published a little volume, entitled, “Our Liberal Movement in Theology,” being an outline of the Unitarian Episode from first to last in New England. Now on page 139, speaking of the resurrection of Christ, Professor Allen says: “It is probably not too much to say that no educated mind—that is, no mind trained in modern methods—now believes that a body of flesh and blood literally came from the grave, and in plain sight of men rose above the clouds, the view of it which most early believers maintained with great intrepidity. That has passed away, along with the dogma of the resurrection of the body, which it was held to prove.” Again, page 140, “That belief has passed wholly out of the educated mind of the present day, along with the kindred and dependent doctrine of the resurrection of our own body.”
The reason I appeal to you, Mr. Editor, as with tears in my eyes, is that you may tell me, first, am I then so exceedingly ignorant as to have falsely supposed that the resurrection is most sincerely and cordially believed in by many, very many thousands of people in Christendom? or, second, am I stupidly wrong in having imagined that among these there are, at least, a few who can be regarded as educated?
I know very well that Professor Allen is incapable of saying what is not so, if only because he says, page 144, that a man’s duty lies . . . “in keeping mind and heart always open to the whisper of the Spirit of all truth.”
Be so good, Mr. Editor, as to explain to me this matter. So utterly unable am I to understand such an assertion from the pen of any man, much more a Professor in Harvard, that I beg you will make your explanations in words of one syllable, generously remembering that he who applies to you is such . . . A DUNCE.
[We are surprised (1) that there should be a dunce in Boston, which is supposed to be so full of knowledge and intelligence that the people who are regarded as fools there would pass for philosophers elsewhere. And (2) we are astonished that a Boston dunce should apply to a New York Orthodox journal for information, instead of Harvard University, which is the fountain-head of all theological and scientific and other knowledge. (Of course we ignorant and superstitious New York people believe in the Scriptures, and find comfort and edification therein. It may be very superstitious in us, and possibly we should not be regarded as “educated” at Cambridge, which has a standard of its own. And it sometimes seems to us that the Harvard Illuminati look at the rest of the world through an atmosphere which gives a peculiar Harvard tinge to everything.—Ed.]