A CRITIC, OR A FAULT-FINDER—WHICH?

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 16, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 3.

Read the full edition

A CRITIC, OR A FAULT-FINDER—WHICH?

Remembering a solemn injunction of Scripture, I ever seek to be careful to entertain strangers, hoping that I shall exchange greetings with an angel unawares. But notwithstanding this zeal of mine, which I trust will in the future find reward, I am sometimes harassed with the fear that I may, on some occasion, entertain a devil unawares. It therefore happens that occasionally, after the stranger has gone forth from my gates, I am greatly “tumbled about” in my mind, while I vainly wonder what kind of a spirit I have been entertaining.
Possibly the foregoing remarks have no connection with what is to follow. At any rate I shall not trouble myself to suggest any connection.
Some evenings ago a reverend-looking young man graced my sanctum with his presence. We entered into conversation, and from discussing things, we drifted into a discussion of various personages, small and great. I soon found the stranger ready to give his impressions, and that he possessed ideas which were plainly not borrowed. We spoke presently of ministers of the gospel. One was named, whose popularity is wide-spread, and upon whose ministrations many delight to wait. My visitor regarded him as a “puffing fellow, whose preaching had more of sound than of sense in it,” and thought that people were finding it out. It was true that a large congregation loved him, but that was their fault. If they were the right kind of people, they would not appreciate such an empty fellow so highly.
I named another preacher, and inquired for my visitor’s opinion of him. “Oh! he was a pretty good fellow; but he stole some of his sermons from the published works of other men. His congregation, too, was small.” Several others were named, but this man, who was their brother in the Lord, had disparaging remarks to make of every one of whom he spoke half a dozen sentences.
I next named a work published by a great and famous man. The book was one that had won encomiums from thousands; but this grave man, with an air of superiority, instantly pronounced it a poor thing. I looked up at the smile of contempt on his thin features, and then I had many thoughts.
By and by the stranger went away, giving me a cordial grasp of the hand at parting; and I wondered what he would say about me if any one ever happened to mention my name in his presence. Since that visit I have had some thoughts about him. I hope I am not uncharitable, but I cannot but wonder whence he obtained the right to set himself in judgment upon so high a seat. He has not the wisdom of years, for he is a young man; nor of the schools, for he is not learned; nor of genius, for he is only an ordinary, common-place person. How is it, then, that he rushes in where angels might fear to tread? Is it because he is one of that class of persons who are “nothing if not critical?” What a pity they would not learn that often, by being critical, they become worse than nothing!
More than half a century ago Byron sang:—
“A man must serve his time to every trade Save censure—critics all are ready-made.”
But ought these croaking fellows to receive so dignified a name as that of critic? Criticism, true and honest, involves some intelligence, some sound sense, some impartiality; but what often passes for criticism lacks all these qualities. Would-be critics are frequently mere birds of ill-omen,—vultures that are ever looking for that from which more cleanly birds fly. No person should delude himself with the idea that he is a critic when he is a mere fault-finder, a grumbler, a croaker, a crabbed old raven which, by some unaccountable metamorphosis, has a habitation in a human body.
When a minister, and especially a young minister, has fault to find with almost all his brethren, what treatment can he expect from his flock? What thoughts does he suppose they will entertain as he solemnly reads from the pulpit the words of our Saviour, “Judge not, that ye be not judged. For with what judgment ye judge ye shall be judged; and with what measure ye mete it shall be measured to you again. And why beholdest thou the mote that is in thy brother’s eye, but considerest not the beam that is in thine own eye?”—Graeme Grey.