WHAT TO CALL IT

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 16, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 3.

Read the full edition

WHAT TO CALL IT.

It is astonishing how much there is in a name, notwithstanding the old query on this point. For instance, the whole country is agitated over the Sunday question. All who believe in Sunday sanctity wish to see the day universally observed. They would be glad to see every one compelled to keep it. But how to accomplish this without seeming to countenance religious oppression and a union of Church and State, has been the vexing problem. Believers in the divine appointment of the seventh day, and who religiously observe it, cannot be compelled by the civil law to keep another day because somebody else regards that as the Sabbath, without making it very apparent that religious discrimination is exercised; that the consciences of some are oppressed; and that the State is interfering with the spiritual freedom of its subjects. This would be religious intolerance, persecution for conscience’ sake, and a union of Church and State.
This would never do; it would be oppressive and unjust; and yet the result must in some way be secured. A happy thought strikes them. Make the law, but do not call it a religious law. Enforce the day, but divorce the religious idea. Call it merely a civil law, a police regulation. Then it is no oppression, and nobody can complain. The seventh-day man is made to pay homage to a religious custom which he knows to be false. He is deprived of one-sixth of his time and means of support, if he lives by the labor of his hands, because a stronger religion demands it, and the State confirms that demand. But it is not done in the name of religion, therefore the Sabbath-keeper can take no exception, and no exemption should be made. And this view many papers, which heretofore have professed great indignation at the idea of religious intolerance and persecution, are now arguing.
A case in illustration has just occurred in New York city. Certain Jews made application for an injunction restraining the police from arresting them for pursuing their ordinary business on the first day of the week, on the ground that they were observers of the seventh day. The injunction was temporarily granted, but was finally dissolved, on the plea that the business of the applicants would not come under the head of “works of necessity or mercy.”
In case of the observers of the seventh day, the exemption of the New York penal code makes only this provision: “It is a sufficient defense to a prosecution for servile labor on the first day of the week, that the defendant uniformly keeps another day of the week as holy time, and does not labor on that day; and that the labor complained of was done in such a manner as not to interrupt or disturb other persons in observing the first day of the week as holy time.”
It is now argued that this is no ground for exemption from arrest for Sunday labor as applied to the observer of the seventh day; for it only provides for a successful defense in case of arrest, and when a person is found working upon the first day, he is violating the letter of the law; and the law does not presume that he has any defense till he makes one. Therefore, although a person is well known to be a conscientious observer of the seventh day, he may be arrested every time he is found working on the first day, and put to the annoyance and trouble of making his defense. And this is argued for as all right.
To the question, “Would not this be a hardship to the Jews and Seventh-day Baptists?” the answer is given that this is incidental to their living in a community which makes Sunday the day of rest, and cannot be avoided without destroying the day of rest altogether.
Again it is said that if the Sunday law “is not equally well fitted to the Jews, as it is not, who form but a mere fragment of the people, this is an inconvenience to them which they must bear, and which the law cannot remove without imposing a much greater inconvenience upon a far larger number of persons.”
This is a clear foreshadowing of the kind of toleration that is to be extended to the observers of the seventh day. But we imagine that a kind of legislation which will not provide for the just rights of all the people, to the last individual, even the humblest, is not, to say the least, a very defensible kind; and if the rights of a class may be ignored, because they “form but a mere fraction of the people,” is not the oppression of the church in every age justified? for they have always been only “a mere fraction of the people.”
And all this difference is made by simply changing the name of the legislation, and calling it a law for civil and social ends instead of religious. We quote again: “If it enforced any kind of religious observance upon them, this would be unjust; but there is no injustice in requiring them to observe Sunday as a day of rest in a community in which, for good and sufficient general reasons, the day is so observed.”
Disguise this Sunday movement as we will, we do not correctly read its anatomy, if beneath this woolly exterior it has not a heart of a very different nature.