WHEN DID CHRIST RISE FROM THE DEAD; ON SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 20, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 8.

Read the full edition

WHEN DID CHRIST RISE FROM THE DEAD; ON SATURDAY OR SUNDAY?

BY ELD. W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Continued.)

TESTIMONY OF HISTORY.

It is now time to give a little attention to the historic argument bearing upon the subject. It would not have been proper to do so before we had made out our case from the Scriptures themselves, as history, against revelation, amounts to nothing. The unanimity of the Fathers upon this question, so far as we know, is complete. It will only be possible to give very brief citations from some of the more prominent of them. These will be presented in the order in which they purport to have been written, and without any effort to settle the controverted questions about their authorship or the exact dates at which they were written; the sole purpose being to demonstrate that the general current of opinion during the first three centuries (during which they were written) was in the direction of the opinion that Christ rose on the first day of the week.
APOSTOLIC CONSTITUTIONS.—“But when the first day of the week dawned, he arose from the dead, and fulfilled those things which before his passion he foretold to us, saying, ‘The Son of man must continue in the heart of the earth three days and three nights.’”
BARNABAS.—“Therefore also we keep the eighth day with joyfulness, the day also on which Jesus rose again from the dead; but when he had manifested himself he ascended into the heavens.”
IGNATIUS.—“And after the observance of the Sabbath, let every friend of Christ keep the Lord’s day as a festival, the resurrection day, the queen and chief of all the days” (of the week).
JUSTIN MARTYR.—(About A. D. 140.) “But Sunday is the day on which we all hold our common assembly, because it is the first day on which God, having wrought a change in the darkness and matter, made the world; and Jesus Christ our Saviour on the same day arose from the dead. For he was crucified on the day before that of Saturn” (Saturday).
IRENAEUS.—(From 140 to 188 A. D.) “This [custom] of not bending the knee upon Sunday, is a symbol of the resurrection, through which we have been set free, by the grace of Christ, from sins and from death, which has been put to death under him.”
TERTULLIAN.—(About A. D. 200.) This writer is so diffuse that we cannot appropriate the space necessary to present an intelligent citation from him here. Suffice it to say that he speaks of Sunday as the Lord’s day and a festival day. This, to the well-informed reader, is sufficient, as it is manifest from his writings, that the first day of the week was regarded by him as a festival because of the resurrection of Christ thereupon.
HIPPOLYTUS.—(About A. D. 250.) “Of the night on which our Lord Jesus Christ rose. That no one shall sleep on that night, and wash himself with water.” The foregoing allusion to the night of Christ’s resurrection, is a manifest reference to his coming forth from the grave while it was yet dark on the first day of the week. John 20: 1.
CYPRIAN.—(A. D. 255.) “For because the eighth day, that is, the first day after the Sabbath, was to be that on which the Lord should rise again, and should quicken us, and give us circumcision of the Spirit, the eighth day, that is, the first day after the Sabbath, and the Lord’s day, went before in the figure.”
ANATOLIUS.—(A. D. 270.) “Our regard for the Lord’s resurrection, which took place on the Lord’s day, will lead us to celebrate it on the same principle.” In the days of this author the term “Lord’s day” had come to be applied quite generally to the first day of the week. That he employed it thus, is made evident by his eleventh canon, where he says: “On the Lord’s day was it that light was shown to us in the beginning.”
So much for the views of the men of the early ages of Christianity. Would it not be remarkable indeed, if they were all mistaken in the matter of the day of Christ’s resurrection? Yet they were so, if the opinion of our opponent is sound, since tradition and history, in both the hands of the papists and the anti-papists, unite in speaking of the day of the sun as the one on which Christ rose from the dead. At a very early period in the history of the church, that day began to be specially honored because of its connection with that event. Indeed, it is an indisputable fact that in a very remote antiquity,—one which lay even upon the border of the second century,—a disposition was manifested to treat the first day of the week as a festival day, because of the honor which it was supposed God had conferred upon it by calling his Son from the grave during the hours which belong properly thereunto. This disposition increased until finally it supplanted the Sabbath of the Lord, or the seventh day of the week.
Now while it is easy to dispose of the logic which would make a sabbath of the first day of the week because Christ rose thereupon, it is not a little difficult to understand how it so fell out that all antiquity were united in admitting the fact from which the deduction was made, provided it were not such. All understand the reluctance with which a change of Sabbath would be made, inasmuch as it would involve guilt on the part of those making it without authority, and all see how very hard it would have been to persuade men to change the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week, because of the fact that Christ rose on the latter, so long as men understood that such was not the case, but that he really did rise on the former, i. e., the seventh day.
Do you answer that it would be just as easy to make men believe that the first day of the week was the resurrection day, when such was not the case, as it would be to make them believe that it was the Sabbath when such was not true? I reply, Not so by any means. The one was a matter of fact, the other a matter of deduction. If, indeed, Christ did rise upon the seventh day of the week, the early authorities must all have been unanimous respecting that fact. The apostles would have taught it, and their successors would have received it from them. For two centuries tradition would have established the fact authoritatively among all Christians. This circumstance, we say, would have rendered it very difficult, if not utterly impossible, for the early Fathers to have been deceived upon that subject, since many of them lived within the period of time under consideration.
On the other hand, take the other view of the subject, and the situation is materially changed. Admit that Christ rose on the first day of the week, and it at once becomes evident that a change of the Sabbath, in process of time, was a possibility. The fact that Christ had risen upon the first day of the week being admitted by all, it was natural that they should look upon it with favor, and feel a disposition to honor it above other days. Take, by way of illustration, our own fourth of July. As the day of our national birth, it is joyfully celebrated by Americans the world over. It has not been difficult to bring about this result; for it is in harmony with the feelings of all. So, too, with the Sunday. On it the early Christians were begotten to “a lively hope” through the resurrection of Christ. In process of time it was celebrated as a festival day. Still later its sanctity was increased in the eyes of men by the supposed logical deduction that God designed in resurrecting Christ on that day to teach men that they were to look upon it as one which he especially wished to distinguish. The papacy, seizing hold of this thought, elaborated and emphasized it before the people, and gradually, in the course of centuries, exalted what had once been a festival to the dignity of an actual and only Sabbath.
In this, we say, there is philosophy; i. e., we can conceive how the Sabbath might have been changed in this manner, but it is very much more difficult to understand how the whole religious world could have been first deceived in regard to the day of Christ’s resurrection, and then made to believe that the day thus palmed off upon them was the Sabbath. It is just as hard again to accept this statement, as it is to accept the explanation which we offer; since our hypothesis only involves the task of persuading the public mind that the fact of the resurrection proved the sanctity of the day on which it occurred; whereas, the other makes it necessary that they should first deceive all men in regard to the day on which the resurrection did actually occur, and then convince them that the resurrection on the day which they had substituted in the place of the true one proved that it was holy time. Thus, once more, the candid reader will readily perceive that the historic argument proves that the theory respecting the day of the resurrection which harmonizes the teaching of history with itself, is the one which favors the first day of the week.
(To be continued.)