ADVANCED THOUGHT ON THE CREDIBILITY OF NEW TESTAMENT HISTORY

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 20, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 8.

Read the full edition

ADVANCED THOUGHT ON THE CREDIBILITY OF NEW TESTAMENT HISTORY.

WHAT is advanced thought now inculcating as to the historic evidences of Christianity, and especially as to the mythical theory of Strauss, which gave scholars a certain amount of trouble a few years ago?
1. It is now admitted by Bauer, Renan, Strauss, and all really learned infidels, that four of Paul's epistles were written before the year 60. These four are the First and Second to the Corinthians, Romans, and Galatians.
2. Paul's four undisputed epistles prove: (1) That within the twenty-five years of the date assigned to the death and resurrection of our Lord, numerous Christian societies had been established throughout the whole extent of the Romish Empire, from Jerusalem to Rome itself. (2) That in these societies there was agreement in the reception of the doctrines of our present Gospels as of divine authority, and of the history recorded in the Gospels as attested by the most irresistible and overwhelming contemporary evidence.
These four epistles alone prove that the creed taught by Paul, and received by the Christian societies throughout the Roman Empire, before the year 60, included substantially all that the Christian creed of to-day embraces.
3. Between 34 and 60 A. D. there is not time enough in any age, and especially not enough in the age of Livy and Tacitus, for myths and legends to grow up and obtain acceptance as histories of actual fact.
4. The mythical theory of Strauss, the legendary theory of Renan, the tendency theory of Bauer, all of them applications of a theory of development to the explanation of the origin of the New Testament literature, are thoroughly confuted and shown to be now utterly untenable by serious and educated men. (See Bampton Lectures for 1877 by Prebendary Row; also, Prof. Stanley Leathes' lecture in the volume entitled, “Modern Skepticisms,” published by the London Christian Evidence Society; and also the Rev. Dr. G. Oswald Dyke's article in Brit. and For. Ed. Rev., No. 111, on “The Witness of St. Paul to Jesus Christ.”)
5. But the application of the development theory to the explanation of the origin of the New Testament literature having thus ignominiously failed, it is to be presumed that we shall not find in that theory a complete explanation of the Old Testament literature.
Go with me to the Colosseum in Rome, and convince yourselves that some things, 1800 years distant from us, can be made perfectly sure to historic conviction. This Colosseum is a huge object. It is difficult to get out of sight of it in the wide plain of the centuries. When was it built? It was begun in the year 72. Who built it? Jews captured at Jerusalem were the chief workmen employed on this structure. When was Jerusalem captured? In the year 70. Who captured it? Titus. How do you know Titus captured Jerusalem? Across the street, yonder, is an arch erected to his memory; and on it, to this day, in beautiful relief, you have representations of the golden candlestick and other utensils employed in the temple. Nobody doubts that Titus, in the year 70, captured Jerusalem, and that the Jews helped to erect the Colosseum? When did Nero die? In the year 68. Solid, unmistakable verities, these stones and those dates. There are very many events, 1800 years gone by, of which we are more sure than we are of what happened in the next street an hour ago. When did Paul die? Under Nero. Everybody admits that Paul died in the reign of this despot, although there is a dispute as to the year; but he certainly died under Nero, and, therefore, before 68. When did Paul write his epistles? Before he died! [Laughter and applause.]—Ex. from 152d Boston Lecture by Joseph Cook.