ABSURD REASONING

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 24, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 17.

Read the full edition

ABSURD REASONING.

BY ELD. F. D. STARR.
Some years since, a minister of one of the leading churches, in talking with me, argued that the advocates of seventh-day observance were responsible for the increasing Sabbath desecration around us. Said he: “Wherever your tents are pitched, or your doctrines preached, the minds of all the people are unsettled in regard to the Sabbath question; Sunday loses its sacredness in their minds, and so they observe no day at all. Perhaps you do not think yourselves responsible for all this, but we think you are. From utterances of the press and the pulpit, we see that the calamities visited upon our nation are interpreted to be expressions of God’s wrath because of Sunday-breaking, and consequently those who seek to turn the people from the observance of Sunday to that of another day, must be the ones against whom he is chiefly offended.”
Strange reasoning this, that those who teach men to fear God, and keep his commandments are the ones who occasion his displeasure! But this mode of reasoning is not new. The apostles were accused of turning the world up-side down.
A specimen of this same reasoning, as met by the Reformers, exhibits a parallel to the present case. “The eastern counties rose in insurrection; four thousand men were under arms in a moment; and Henry was guarded in his own palace by only a few servants. It was necessary to break down the bridges to stop the insurgents. The courtiers complained to the king; the king threw the blame on the cardinal; the cardinal laid it on the clergy, who had encouraged him to impose this tax by quoting to him the example of Joseph demanding of the Egyptians the fifth part of their goods; and the clergy in their turn ascribed the insurrection to the gospellers, who [said they] were stirring up a peasant war in England, as they had done in Germany. Reformation produces revolution: this is the favorite text of the followers of the pope. Violent hands must be laid upon the heretics.”
“The charge of the priests was absurd; but the people are blind whenever the gospel is concerned, and occasionally the governors are blind also. Serious reasoning was not necessary to confute this invention. ‘Here, by the way, I will tell you a merry toy,’ said Latimer one day in the pulpit. ‘Master More was once sent in commission into Kent to help to try out, if it might be, what was the cause of Goodwin Sands and the shelf that stoppeth up Sandwich haven. He calleth the country afore him, such as were thought to be men of experience, and among others came in an old man with a white head, and one that was thought to be a little less than one hundred years old. So Master More called the old aged man unto him, and said: “Father, tell me, if you can, what is the cause of this great arising of the sands and shelves hereabout, that stop up Sandwich haven.” “Forsoth, sir” [quoth he], “I am an old man, for I am well nigh an hundred, and I think that Tenterden steeple is the cause of the Goodwin Sands. For I am an old man, sir, and I may remember the building of Tenterden steeple, and before that steeple was in building, there was no manner of flats or sands.”’ After relating this anecdote, Latimer slyly added: ‘Even so, to my purpose, is preaching of God’s word the cause of rebellion, as Tenterden steeple was the cause Sandwich haven is decayed.’—Hist. Ref. vol. 5, p. 235.
Even so, we may add, is preaching the commandments of God, the fourth not excepted, the cause of Sabbath profanation, and consequent temporal calamities.