A FRIEND sends us a letter from an individual who takes exception to the statements made in Testimony No. 28 on page 140. To his mind the declarations there made are so diametrically opposed to the facts in the case that he is compelled to reject the visions of Mrs. E. G. White as not having been given by the Lord. The writer has an air of candor, and there is some force in what he says, so we purpose to consider his difficulties briefly.
These difficulties are two in number, and are supported by several facts, so-called. On the page in question Sister White makes four quotations, two of them from first and two of them from second Timothy. She also speaks of these quotations as being contained in the dying charge of the apostle Paul, and states further that Mark committed them to writing. The objector denies the accuracy of what is said in this matter, first, because 1 Timothy was written too early to be called the dying charge of Paul, and secondly, because Mark was not with him at Rome at the time in question. Here are his points and proofs:—
1. The first epistle was written some seven years before the second epistle of Timothy was written.
Ans. The point made here is this: As the first epistle to Timothy was written seven years before Paul's death, it was written too early to be styled his dying charge. I know not where our friend finds his authority for stating that 1 Timothy was written at the date which he fixes. It is certain, however, that some of the ripest scholars which the world has ever produced do not agree with our friend in this matter. Indeed, it has been largely disputed whether the first so-called, was not written subsequently to the second epistle to Timothy. Adam Clarke in speaking of the chronology of the two epistles to Timothy has the following in his preface to epistle number two: “What remains to be done in reference to the present epistle, i. e., number two, is to inquire into the time in which it was most probably written. The disagreement on this question among learned men is very great, some arguing that it was written about the year A. D. 61, others referring it to the year 66, some asserting that it is the first in order of time, of these two epistles, and that it was written on Paul's first imprisonment at Rome. Several of the most eminent critics are of this opinion, and they have supported their sentiments with arguments of no small weight. Hammond, Lightfoot, and Lardner, as well as several critics on the continent, contend for the earlier date.”
Again: If our brother will take the pains to refer to his King James' Bible, he will find in the margin the chronology of 1 Timothy located in A. D. 65, and that of 2 Timothy in A. D. 66. Thus it appears that the separation of the writing of the two epistles by seven years is by no means justifiable when we look upon the matter in the light of scholarship. In fact, the question of dates is so far from being settled that there is room for doubt as to which of the epistles was published first. Admitting, however, as we are inclined to think we should, that the first and second epistles to Timothy were written in the order in which they are given in our Bible, there is nothing to prove that they were separated from each other in the time of their writing even by a single week. The chronology in our Bible is given as only approximately true. Paul was twice imprisoned at Rome; but no good reason can be offered to prove that the two epistles in question were not both of them written during or about the time of his last confinement.
2. 1 Timothy was probably written in Macedonia (1 Tim. 1:3), and at a time when Paul expected soon to go and see Timothy. 1 Tim. 3:14. He therefore did not urge the immediate presence of Timothy. It follows, therefore, that no part of the first epistle contains Paul's dying charge to Timothy.
Ans. To the foregoing points it may be replied, first, the text cited to prove that 1 Timothy was written in Macedonia comes very far short of accomplishing the end desired. Here it is: “As I besought thee to abide still at Ephesus, when I went unto Macedonia, that thou mightest charge some that they teach no other doctrine, neither give heed to fables and endless genealogies, which minister questions, rather than godly edifying which is in faith; so do.” 1 Tim. 1:3, 4. It will be observed that in the preceding the apostle exhorts Timothy to abide still in Ephesus as he (the apostle) counseled him to do “when he went into Macedonia.” Now if the apostle had been writing from Macedonia he would have said “when I came into Macedonia.” The circumstance that265he uses the word “went” instead of “came” proves that he must have been somewhere outside of Macedonia instead of within it when he wrote the epistle. The subscription found in our version represents the epistle to have been written from Laodicea. Other subscriptions speak of it as having been written at Athens, Macedonia, and a number of other places. As it regards the place where it was really written, conjecture is all that can be offered. In the difference of opinion upon this subject, it is by no means impossible or even improbable that Sister White is right in speaking of it as though it were sent from Rome.
Secondly, it is true that when Paul commenced to write his first epistle to Timothy, he hoped to go to Timothy in a brief space of time. 1 Tim. 3:14. It is not impossible, however, that before the completion of the epistle, his affairs might have taken on a more discouraging aspect. It will be observed that the hopeful language of the apostle is found in the third chapter, or about the middle of the epistle; whereas, the language of Sister White was taken from the last chapter of the epistle. It is by no means certain that some little time may not have elapsed in the prison between the commencement and the completion of Paul's letter. Furthermore, a day or a single hour by some new communication brought to the apostle from the imperial palace might cause him to be more hopeful or more dejected in spirit. Sister White through the aid of the Holy Spirit may have spoken advisedly in this matter though we, not possessed of the facts in the case, might find it difficult to harmonize her statements with what appear to us to be conflicting declarations in the epistle itself. Seeming contradictions of a like character appear in the Bible itself; yet we believe that they are not irreconcilable.
Thirdly, we think that any person who will carefully read the Testimony of Sister White will be satisfied that in her remarks she speaks of both first and second Timothy as comprising the dying charge of Paul to Timothy. In speaking of it as the dying charge, she was correct even though the apostle had not understood it as such, provided that practically speaking it proved of that character. In other words, if these were really the last writings from Paul to Timothy, they might properly be spoken of as a dying charge. That the second epistle was such, our friend admits. Well, we understand that Sister White, while classing the two epistles under the head of a dying charge, both having been written from the dungeon from which Paul was taken forth to die, refers to what is contained in the second epistle (chapter 4, verse 9) when she says that he urged the immediate presence of Timothy. Such a view reconciles her statements with those of the two epistles; first, by showing that the two epistles may properly be considered as one dying charge in the sense that they were the last charge of Paul to Timothy, both having been written from his prison at Rome not long before his death; and, secondly, by reconciling the statement in 1 Tim. 3:14, that Paul hoped to go to Timothy shortly, with the declaration of Sister White that he despaired of his life, by showing that her remarks referred to the condition of his mind at the close of his first epistle which was perhaps located some days later than the time at which he wrote 1 Tim. 3:14.
3. There is no evidence whatever that Paul employed any one to write the epistle for him. There is rather evidence to the contrary. 1 Tim. 3:14.
Ans. It is not enough that our friend should say that there is no evidence whatever that Paul employed any one to write the epistle for him. Before he can invalidate the Testimony, he must advance positive proof that he did not employ any one for that purpose. Is the text which he introduces of that character? Manifestly not. In it the apostle simply says, “These things write I unto you, hoping to come unto you shortly.” “What we do through another we do ourselves,” says a maxim of the law. A man who dictates a letter can with perfect propriety say that he wrote the same. Such a practice is according to the usage in our time and also in ancient times.
In favor of the idea that some one did write the epistles to Timothy, we might cite the circumstance that it appears to have been the practice of Paul to employ an amanuensis generally for such purposes. See Col. 4:18; 1 Cor. 16:21; 2 Thess. 3:17. While at large, if not while in the prison at Rome, he was chained to a soldier. This would have made writing very difficult if not impossible. Again: Scholars like Conybeare and Howson have supposed that subsequently to the blindness occasioned by the vision near Damascus, he never regained his eyesight so fully that it was not troublesome for him to write. The probabilities, therefore, are in favor of the Testimony on this point.
4. As to the second epistle to Timothy, there is every evidence that it was written while Paul was a prisoner in Rome, expecting soon to suffer martyrdom. 2 Tim. 1:8, 16; 4:6–8. This second epistle therefore contains Paul's dying words to Timothy; but there is no evidence that it was written by any one else than Paul himself.
Ans. In the above, there is an acknowledgment that the second epistle to Timothy contains the dying words to Timothy. Thus far our friend is in harmony with the Testimony. All he has to do, therefore, in order to be in harmony with it to the full extent, is to admit (what we have proved above) that in the sense Sister White used the term, the first epistle is likewise of that character.
In reply to our friend's presumption that Paul wrote the second epistle, it is only necessary to refer to what we have said above in regard to the writing of the first epistle. All the probabilities are against him.
5. It is certain that Mark did not write 2 Tim., as Paul urges Timothy to bring Mark with him. 2 Tim. 4:11.
Ans. In the preceding we have a point more difficult to meet than any which has been considered hitherto. At first glance, it would seem to present an insurmountable obstacle in the way of maintaining the truthfulness of the Testimonies. But let us consider the situation for a moment. It is very evident that Sister White, whether inspired or not, was familiar with the contents of the second epistle to Timothy, since she quotes from the same quite largely. First, she quotes four verses found in 2 Tim. 2:2–5. Again, on page 142, she quotes 2 Tim. 4:9, 10, barely leaving out a line in the latter verse which was not necessary to her then present purpose. Now be it remembered that the verse upon which our friend relies to prove that Mark was not at Rome at the time that Paul wrote the second epistle, is the eleventh verse of the fourth chapter, or the very next one to the last one which she quotes. Be it remembered, also, that she quotes the tenth verse, as mentioned above, leaving out a line therefrom intentionally. Now, if she was inspired when she made those quotations, then that ends the controversy between us. If, on the other hand, she turned to the text in question, copied them from the Bible, stopping as she did to drop out a line from the tenth verse, it is quite certain that she would have read the eleventh verse to see that her quotation was completed. But if she read the eleventh verse, then she understood as well as our friend does what it says about Timothy bringing Mark with him, and consequently made the statement which she does make in her Testimony in regard to Mark's writing the epistle for Paul, with a full knowledge of all the difficulties of the situation. In other words, she did not say what she did inadvertently. Would it not be well, therefore, to consider the possibilities of the case for a moment?
Those who have been acquainted with the Testimonies of Sister White for years, and have seen many evidences that they are from the Lord, will wait long before rejecting them on the ground of inconsistency, unless that inconsistency is made out in the most conclusive manner. Inspiration never errs; but it is one of the easiest things in the world for men to come to wrong conclusions where they are not in possession of all the facts bearing upon the case. That which we are now talking about occurred eighteen hundred years ago. A single word from Paul or Mark might place the affair in a light such as to show that Sister White was exactly correct after all. Since, therefore, her statements were made quite positively and with evident deliberation, let us see if we cannot conceive of a state of things which would render their truthfulness possible.
Well, suppose now that Mark wrote 2 Timothy in the dungeon at the dictation of Paul, and then went as a messenger to bear it to Timothy in a distant province. Paul, anxious to enjoy the benefit of the labors of Mark in the future, writes to Timothy as follows: “Only Luke is with me. Take Mark, and bring him with thee: for he is profitable to me for the ministry.” 2 Tim. 4:11. Would not such a state of facts explain the situation satisfactorily? Paul was in the habit of sending men on just such missions. In verse twelve he says, “Tychicus have I sent to Ephesus.” These men were the bearers of important tidings. Paul was drawing near his end, and they could communicate in person much more than he could write. He was anxious to have Mark return. Such a return would involve the expenditure of considerable money. A word from Paul would secure all the necessary means for the journey and relieve Mark from all the embarrassment which would naturally result from asking for the same.
The only objection which can be raised to this view is found in the declaration of Paul that “only Luke was with him.” Verse 11. This objection, however, is not really a valid one. If Mark was the attendant of Paul, as was unquestionably true, then Timothy was well aware of this fact from the very necessity of the case, and it was altogether unnecessary that Paul should mention him by name since it would be well understood in the absence of proof to the contrary that wherever Paul was, there Mark would be found also.
Furthermore, Mark was about to depart, and when he should do so, Paul would be left alone with Luke. When Timothy read the letter, he would at once take in the situation and conceive of Paul in just the lonely condition in which he was at that moment, understanding, of course, that Mark could not be with him, since he was standing in his own presence as the bearer of the letter from Paul. It was the design of Paul to impress upon Timothy the importance of coming to him immediately by representing to him that he was left almost entirely alone and destitute of needed help and counsel. It would, therefore, have been superfluous to mention the presence of one who in a few moments, or in a few hours at the outside, was to leave him to enter upon a long journey, and consequently could be of no service whatever to him at Rome.
In the latter portion of verse eleven we have an266intimation that Mark was actually with Paul when the second epistle to Timothy was written. There we read as follows: “Take Mark and bring him with thee: for he is profitable to me for the ministry.” The reader will observe that the verb is in the present tense. Paul says that Mark is profitable to me for the ministry. Mark it; he does not say bring him because he will be, but bring him because he is profitable now. That is, he is profitable now, and it follows that he will be in the future, so bring him with you when you come. But if Mark was not with Paul at the time that the letter was written, how could he with propriety have said he is profitable to me; and why did he not rather say he will be profitable to me? The natural explanation of the use of the present tense is apparent if the Testimony is right, but not so manifest if the Testimony is wrong. In other words, if we admit that Mark was with Paul, and wrote the epistle for him, then the use of the verb in the present tense was proper, whereas, it can hardly be said to be such if he was not present at the time in question. But if he were there, then our friend is wrong, and the Testimony is right. W. H. L.