THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 15, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 20.

Read the full edition

THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE.

FIFTH PAPER.

In 1854, Eld. James White and wife made their first visit to Wisconsin, appointing a meeting in Koshkonong, Jefferson Co. But they were not used to holding meetings in States which had no railroads, and the notice proved too short, as very few received the appointment in time to get to the meeting. This was unfortunate for the work there, and a disappointment on all sides, as no general meeting was possible under the circumstances. However, they visited a number of places, and much good was the result. Many were strongly confirmed in the faith.
Elds. Stephenson and Hall, for a time after this visit, professed much confidence in the work of Sister White, and in the Testimonies given through her. But soon they began to see the effect which the teaching of the message was having on the Age to Come, which they had so diligently preached in Wisconsin. They were traveling among the churches of Sabbath-keepers, where they taught “publicly and from house to house” their favorite doctrine. A few were dissatisfied with such a course on their part; but many had believed that doctrine before they kept the Sabbath, and as Elders S. and H. were known to be able preachers, the majority were opposed to doing anything which would cripple them in their labors. As I had had so good opportunities to know what the Age-to-Come theory was, and that it was impossible to harmonize the third angel’s message with it, I could not conscientiously labor with them or give countenance to their preaching. Accordingly I retired from the field, and took a position in a printing office in Oshkosh until there should come a change.
About the same time a disaffection arose in Jackson, Mich., where the message was first preached in this State. Difficulties had arisen between some members, which was not unusual, as some had imbibed very erroneous views of the text, “Many shall be purified and made white and tried.” Trials appearing to be necessary to purification, they seemed to think they were bringing their brethren and sisters under great obligations to them if they succeeded in keeping them under trial. Sister White had a message of reproof for one party. This gave the other party great satisfaction; they heartily indorsed the Testimony, and with strong emphasis, and with no small degree of exultation, declared that they knew it was right,—that the message was from the Lord. But that very night a message was given to Sister White for the other party. This message did not take a particle from the force of the preceding one, but it strongly condemned the spirit of exultation with which they had indorsed the other, and it said that this was in keeping with the spirit they had been manifesting, and the course they had before pursued; that they had “pushed with side and shoulder” against those who did not agree with them. And then how speedily the scene was changed! They who so recently knew the Testimonies were from Heaven; who so heartily indorsed the work and words of Sister White, were very sure that the Lord was not leading her; that he never showed to her what she then professed to have seen. Indeed, they declared that she had contradicted herself by reproving them so soon after reproving their opponents: as if both parties could not, to some extent, be wrong. But the wisdom of God was manifested in these reproofs. The least in fault were reproved first, which gave the others an opportunity to show their true spirit, that all might realize just where they stood.
But they were not the first, and by no means the last, who have rejected Testimonies because they did not come in harmony with their ideas and feelings. Many, both before and since that time, have taken the same position, and tested the Testimonies, not by the Bible evidence, not according to the Scripture characteristics of true spiritual gifts, but by their own judgment as to what the Lord ought to reveal! Elders Stephenson and Hall would have indorsed the Testimonies heartily if the Testimonies had indorsed the Age to Come. Now it is a fact that Sister White knew nothing of the doctrine of the Age to Come; such a theory had never been presented to her mind. But the Testimonies given through her laid the ax at the very root of that doctrine. She had never mentioned the Age to Come, nor its adherents, in any manner; yet they plainly saw that they must renounce the Age to Come or reject the Testimonies. They chose the latter course, and began to fight against the Testimonies. Time soon showed that they had engaged in an unequal warfare. They risked all, and we sincerely believe they lost all, in the controversy.
From this defection in Jackson grew up what was called “the Messenger party.” Together with some kindred spirits, such as Ransom Hicks, of Rhode Island, and an Elder Wyman, of Vermont, they started a paper called the Messenger of Truth. But never did a paper more completely belie its name. This party professed to believe, and we presume they did believe, that the Testimonies given through Sister White were the one great hindrance to the speedy and complete triumph of the message. They said the visions had a scattering influence, subversive of the spirit of the message; that it was full time for the “loud voice” of the third angel to be heard, and that it would no doubt be heard very soon if this cause of complaint were removed. They claimed to have a mission to free the cause from that burden, and to give the present truth in its purity; and they confidently predicted a great revival of the work through their instrumentality.
Another interesting point in their course was this: they claimed that, in the publication of the REVIEW, and in the general management of the cause, Bro. White took too much power into his own hands. “The one-man power” was a familiar phrase with them, as it has been with others since that time, and with no better reason. Their inconsistency in this matter was most marked, as I will soon notice.
In the summer of 1855, I visited the office of the Messenger, in Jackson. At that time the editor of that paper called my attention to some things which Sister White had written, which were omitted in making the book, “Experience and Views.” After carefully examining the points, it was conceded that no ill motive could underlie the omission, inasmuch as the omitted lines did not contain anything to which opposers could reasonably object, while some things were retained to which they had very strong objections. Seeing that the things to which they most strongly objected were not omitted, the attack was made on us for not reprinting the book in which the objectionable expressions were used. Now that the book has been reproduced, the first which Sister White ever wrote, the old charge has been renewed, and enforced by as much misrepresentation as is possible to be brought to bear on the point. This, also, will be shown in due time.
The Seventh-day Adventists had no organization, and of necessity the REVIEW office was held as private property. But at different times committees of publication were appointed, by Conferences of the believers, to help bear the responsibility of the paper. In imitation of this course, the Messenger party called a Conference in the State of New York, of which Ransom Hicks was chairman, and a publishing committee was appointed, of which Hicks was one. But some time afterward it was noticed that the name of Hicks was silently dropped from the paper, without the action of any Conference. Such a thing was never done in the management of the REVIEW. I asked a prominent member of the party in Michigan why this was done. He said Hicks wanted to be head, and to have everything his own way. “Yes,” promptly replied the wife of this man, “and that’s what ails all of them.” And she spoke the truth. The whole movement was started in self-justification and self-will. By reason of my acquaintance with them, I was able to learn somewhat of the intrigues carried on among them to supplant one another. The editor did all he could to destroy the influence of his associates in Jackson in order that he might obtain full control of the paper. After the name of Mr. Hicks had been dropped from the paper, he opened correspondence with Mr. C. P. Russell, of Jackson, who appeared to be the most conscientious one among them. Mr. Russell told me that Hicks sent to him a letter which he had received from the editor of the Messenger, and he said he had never before seen so many falsehoods on a single sheet of foolscap!
Elder Wyman, of Vermont, had been reproved by a vision, and he rose up in rebellion against the reproof. Of course he was indorsed by this party, and they moved him to Michigan. They exalted him as an excellent Christian man, and, said the man who furnished him a house in Jackson County, “If it were not for the visions, nobody would ever have thought of calling Bro. Wyman a bad man.” But his change of location did not change his character. He was detected in evil doing, and he suddenly vacated the house furnished to him, leaving the neighborhood, as the saying is, “between two days.” On my next visit to that place, I called on the man on whose place Wyman had lived, as was my custom. “Bro. D.,” said I, “where is Wyman?” Plainly showing his chagrin, he answered, “Oh, Wyman is a bad man; we were deceived in him.” “But you told me that nobody would call Wyman a bad man were it not for the visions. Have you been having visions also, that you now call him so?” Poor man; I pitied him, though I spoke thus. They had indeed been deceived, but the deception was of their own choosing.
From that time they declined rapidly. There was no union among them; they had no message from Heaven; they were fighting against that which had brought up a people united in all the truths of the third angel’s message. They all became disgusted with the conduct of their editor, and no one had sufficient confidence in their work to take his place. The paper died, and the last we heard of the editor was a report from Canada, where he had taken a school, that he was committed to jail for assaulting one of the pupils with a deadly weapon. And thus “the Messenger party” buried itself, for the REVIEW paid but little attention to them. And such was the party who professed to have a mission to correct the errors of the Seventh-day Adventists! J. H. W.