THE VAGARIES OF EVOLUTION.
By J. O. Corliss
It seems strange that any one with a common stock of reason and good sense can accept the theory of evolution. That theory insists on a constant tendency upward to a higher, better, and more perfect condition. This is contradictory of facts, as is well known to the most casual observer. Every one who cultivates grains, fruits, and flowers, as well as the breeder of stock, knows that the tendency is to deterioration, and that only by the most intelligent and persistent efforts can man prevent the running down of species. It is also a noticeable fact that the improvement of species is limited to those places where men have cultivated reason by study and observation, and then by careful selections, and judicious crossing, have helped nature. The absurdity of living creatures being evolved from a speck of floating albumen, requiring long ages in their slow march upward to the present state of perfection, is well set forth in the following extract which we take from an old newspaper:— “There has been no such prevalence of evolution as that all the various tribes of living creatures on land, in air and water, could have sprung from ‘a common fleck of albumen, polyp, protozoan, rhizopod or moneron,’ no matter how much time you give them for change, and you may even throw in spontaneous generation. It may be conceivable that an animalcule might take on additional matter during ages, so as to become a larger animal of the same structure, or if large at the beginning, it might cast off or reject matter, and diminish from a mammoth, or elephant, to an animalcule; but to suppose evolution from a moneron or speck of albumen, floating upon the surface of water, without parts, organization, or life, to become an active fish with life, and a complete organization with instinct, all at once, would require creative power; and even if it may be supposed to involve ages of duration for effecting the changes, it would not help the matter much; for the accretions of matter added must be intelligently added, and uniformly placed, or there would be no regularity in form to accomplish a systematic purpose. The matter must think, or there must be some thinking outside of itself. It will not do to leave these accretions of matter to chance if we are to make a systematically organized creature of them for a definite purpose. For matter without life in nature never takes uniform shape that tends to reproduce itself or its like. Rivers and streams do not deposit the mud into organized forms. “New matter without life, in nature, may be added to top, bottom, or sides or middle, and result in no describable form; but in living beings there is uniformity and symmetry in the accretions, not only in increasing the volume, but tending to the accomplishment of a definite end, showing the existence of an intelligent mind directing the formation to that particular end. If evolution might be true at all, it could not be unreasonable to suppose that the process might as well be from the higher to the lower as from the lower to the higher. We might as well suppose a mammoth or an elephant, a whale or a crocodile, to be the original protozoan as a fleck of albumen, if there was no intelligent creator or designer. If we consent to give up the world to chance, or make it an orphan, we might have any condition for its beginning, if indeed it had any beginning. If we begin with a mammoth to develop downward, we must see that it is necessary that matter be taken away to reduce the body to a gnat, and we must take care from what part we take the matter, or we shall defeat the end toward which we may be tending. In any event there must be an ever-present intelligence to guide and control, no matter which way, whether up or down, development advances. It seems to be much more agreeable to many minds to suppose a little fleck of albumen to be invested with the attributes that have been ascribed to Deity, than to allow that there is a personal God, the Creator and upholder of all, present to all, and exercising control over the forces of the physical and moral world. But these intelligent Christian scholars may be disposed to demur to their impeachment, and claim that they admit a superintending intelligence. But even that does not relieve them of the absurdity of the evolution theory. If all the beings in the world were of similar organization, it would not be inconceivable that they might eject or reject matter, or add matter by the use of the functions of living organs, and become larger or smaller; but the difficulty becomes formidable when we have to provide bridges across from one mode of life to another, as aquatic to land animals, or to those that fly in the air, from graminivorous to carnivorous. “The exceedingly slow progress that is always claimed for evolution must involve that theory in serious difficulty; for now there must be an entire revolution of the appetite and the masticatory and digestive apparatus, and therefore there must be an immense period in which those parts of the system would be neither the one nor the other. Now let those evolutionists get them across this enormous gulf, that upon their own theory involves ages of time. So, to pass from aquatic animal life over to air-breathing animals, there must be a complete revolution of the locomotive, the masticatory, the digestive, the respiratory and the generative apparatus and instincts, and the auditory and visual apparatus must undergo great changes. What is to become of these poor creatures in the state of betweenity while the organs are undergoing the changes for so long a time, in which they are in a condition very poorly adapted to either state of existence, and in which the transitionary matter may have been at first quite sure of its proper place, while a slight change in the end toward which the organization is drifting must confuse the destination of accretions, for what was the survival of the fittest for one condition and purpose might not be such for the changed purpose and destination. The generative apparatus of hardly any two species is so similar as to make propagation possible in a state of transition from one species to another, even in a single generation. “If birds were evolved from fishes, it would be very difficult to determine what could have been the condition of the fishes for ages, encumbered with rudimentary wings, feathers, and legs in water. They must have made very awkward work of swimming below the surface in that condition, for a few thousand years. And if organization had been approximating the seed and fruit-eating families of birds, they must have had a very hungry time of it for a few centuries before they could leave the watery element and go where their appetites and their digestive apparatus could be supplied with what could be adapted to them, and then the food that had been suitable to them while they were fishes proper, they could no longer eat nor digest, for how long a time, who can tell? “Let the wise, theistical scholars try to construct a bridge for the transit of these poor creatures across from one of these conditions to the other, before they ask their fellow-students to accept the theory of evolution. It is wonderful that these amazing changes of which these astute men are so confident, should all have got through so nicely, before there was a man upon earth to observe and record a few notes of so remarkable a process! What a pity we could not find at least one specimen of some living creature in this process of evolution, so that we could have something besides baseless conjecture to stand upon, and thus relieve this theory of those ugly doubts that will spring up in spite of the high authority and the brilliant eloquence which so naturally backs the announced opinions of these mighty men. I should suppose that God would have known (if there be a God) that these doubts would arise and perplex intelligent creatures, and that if they were to be evolved at any time by the survival of the fittest, he would have had these evolutions continued in some such way as we see he has in giving a clue to his methods in other things, as to their propagation of species. “Either intelligent beings should have been introduced earlier, or these transitions should have been continued longer, that we might have been better prepared to do justice either to the wonderful wisdom, power, and skill of evolution, as our god, or to some other power that might be accepted as worthy to be worshiped as Creator, Preserver, and Judge of all. The uncertainty that scientists feel might have been all avoided by a little attention to these transitions, to relieve inevitable doubts that would arise. “None of these scientists has ventured to inform us whether the gills of the fishes closed up before the trachea and lungs were formed, or after, and therefore they have not touched the question of the how about their breathing in the transition state, or whether the revolution was not instantaneous. If they were to allow it to309 be instantaneous, there would be some danger of suggesting to an inquiring mind the question whether there was not creative power about at such a time. If a tendency ever existed to such wonderful evolutions upward, it is very surprising that traces of it should not remain and be discovered in this age of greater intellectual activity than was ever seen before; an age when thousands of keen, brilliant geniuses are peering into every nook and cranny of nature for traces of the origin and methods of creation. If such tendencies ever did exist, and have been suspended, it is very strange that those who have been able to pry open the bolted doors of Nature and discover such profound secrets as evolution and the survival of the fittest, have not found out when and where such processes have been interrupted. “All other processes of which we have any hint in nature, are continued, else science would be an impossibility.”