THE NEW DEPARTURE

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 1, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THE NEW DEPARTURE.

BY ELD. S. BURDICK.
The revival and attempted enforcement, under the new penal code, of the Sunday laws of the State of New York, has become the occasion of a new departure on the part of the religious press, and many prominent leaders in religious circles. Under the popular ideas of personal rights and religious liberty, as guaranteed by the constitutional law of the land, there is an apparent indisposition to frankly demand and openly advocate legislation in favor of religious tenets and observances as such; hence, the new departure which apparently seeks to shun the question of personal rights, the constitutional barrier, and consummate the desired end by a new definition of the means employed.
The philosophy of the new departure, as stated in the form of a proposition, seems to be this: “Our government possessed no inherent or conferred right to legislate for or against the religious tenets, traditions, or practices of any part of the people, if in so doing, it has professedly in view their promotion or suppression; but it may enact and enforce laws which, under the name of civil or police regulations, do in effect override the personal rights of the citizen, and compel him to observe regularly a certain recognized religious rite, by suspending his worldly business on that particular day which certain of his fellow-men have made sacred to religion.”
This new departure virtually concedes the fact that our government has no right to control the action of men on the ground of religious obligation, and therefore imposes upon its advocates the burden of proving that there are (religious obligations aside) clearly within the rightful domain and cognizance of civil government, good and sufficient reasons for compelling citizens, by the penalties of the law, to cease from labor and business on a particular day of each recurring week. It really leaves the advocate of these Sunday laws no grounds for their justification or for demanding their enforcement, but those which are merely theoretic or incidental. It takes away from the background of these laws all religious obligation as the basis of their claim upon men. When it has been accepted as a fact that government cannot create or annul religious obligation, it becomes an important question whether it can rightfully do more than protect from needless disturbance or interference those citizens who observe the Sunday as a religious duty, leaving all others free to rest or labor on that day, as they may determine.
It matters very little whether the present law is called a law to provide for the better observance of Sunday as the Christian Sabbath, or a law to regulate the observance of Sunday as a civil institution, the results are the same. Men are compelled, willing or unwilling, conscious or unconscious of religious obligation, to observe the day by withholding from labor and business thereon.
It is doubtless true that the Sunday law is a civil law, but it is equally true that it does compel the citizen to observe, in the conduct of his business, as a civil regulation that which his fellow-citizen observes as a religious duty, while the fact remains that the Sunday law was made, and is still sustained, by a portion of the people because Sunday is regarded as an institution of religion, a day which should be respected by all men because of its traditional religious character.
The circumstance that the law does not require the citizen to spend the day, or any part of it, in attending church service or in religious worship, does not change the fact that it does discriminate between fellow-citizens, denying to the one the exercise of a personal choice and personal right to pursue his ordinary business on that day, which the other, in the free exercise of his personal choice and right, devotes to religious worship. Religious obligation aside, the right to work is just as clear as the right to worship, and it is just as much the duty of government to protect the citizen from interference in his work as in his worship, since government is made to protect, not to suppress, the rights of men.
It is the right of the citizen to devote the first day of the week to rest and worship, and also his right to be protected against needless interference in so doing; but here his right ceases, in so far at least as his control over the labor and business of another is concerned, since it is incompatible with the accepted doctrine of equal rights for all citizens, to make even the conscientious convictions of one man the pretext for suppressing another’s right of choice and action who has no such convictions. It is as clearly the right of the one to work on a given day as it is the right of the other to worship, while the fact must remain that neither the government nor the majority can practically alienate the rights of either without doing violence to the constitutional law of the land.
It is the right of the Jew and the Christian to religiously observe the seventh day of the week according to the literal interpretation of the law of God, and doubtless their right to claim protection under the law in so doing; but it cannot be their right to claim the protection of a law which shall compel all other citizens of the country to cease from labor while they religiously rest and worship, unless the law of God, as the source of religious obligation, is to be made the basis of civil legislation in determining the time when men shall rest from secular labor.
It is the prerogative of civil government to recognize certain days as legal holidays, and provide all needful regulations for their protection against perversion into occasions of immorality and evil, but in order to do this it has never been found necessary to interfere with the citizen who has chosen to devote any or all of these days to labor or business.
It is doubtless the right of government to make even a religious festival a legal holiday, and provide by civil law against the abuse of the leisure it affords; but if without the power to create or annul religious obligation, it cannot be its right to go between the citizen and his personal liberty and interests, and compel him to observe a religious festival by withholding from labor thereon, because honest, productive labor is the citizen’s necessity and inherent right, and not an evil to be suppressed by the penalties of the law. The real reasons for the law prohibiting labor on Sunday are not to be found in the nature and effects of legitimate labor, but rather in the fact that certain religious people regard it as a religious duty to cease from servile labor on that day, and therefore demand that their fellow-citizens who will not do this voluntarily shall be compelled to do so under the penalties of the civil law. They insist that the day called Sunday, and made sacred to religion, shall be observed throughout the land by universal cessation from labor. In other words, they insist that the festival of Sunday shall be upheld and honored by compelling all citizens alike to observe it as a civil institution. They seem disposed to keep in the background the important fact that it is man’s first and highest duty to obey the divine precepts of religion, and are apparently unwilling to go before the people in an earnest and united effort to convince them, by the testimony of God’s word, that the observance of Sunday is a religious duty. In the absence of any such effort, or any divine precept requiring it, any attempt to enforce such an observance by the civil law, is, in effect, an attempt to put the law of man in the place of the law of God, and base the obligation of Sabbath observance upon the law of the State. It may seem, to many, desirable to secure for the Sunday the hush and quiet of Sabbath rest; but this must prove vain unless behind the desired quiet there is a conscience enlightened by the word of God and voluntary obedience to his known law.
They build wisely in the cause of religion who build upon the foundations of divine truth; and if all zealous for religion could be induced to accept the fact that the word of God is the only sure foundation of truth, the only basis upon which to build up a religious service acceptable to God, there would be very little effort or disposition to seek the promotion of religion by invoking the aid of the civil law.