Give me no guess for a dying pillow. Let my tongue cleave to the roof of my mouth and my right arm drop from its socket rather than that either should be employed in putting under the head of any man, woman, or child a mere conjecture, however plausible, as a support in death. For one, I have made up my mind that I will not go hence trusting my chances of eternal peace to the opportunity of repentance after death. What I will not do for myself I will not directly or indirectly recommend others to do.
Discussing the question, Does death end probation? first practically, next theoretically, and then exegetically, I am to maintain three propositions:—
1. If it be possible that death may end probation, the supreme dictate of practical wisdom is to repent now.
2. Mere reason shows that death may end probation.
3. The Scriptures show that death does end probation.
What have we to do, as practical people, with the seductive promise that those who do not have a fair chance here, may, possibly, have another chance hereafter? I want a fact, not a hypothesis, as my support in the dark waters which separate this world from the next. My conscience dictates repentance at this instant, and so does all practical wisdom. If we are not sure—and no man is sure—that there is an opportunity after death for repentance, and sure that we can use it in our own cases to advantage, it remains true that now is the accepted time and now the day of salvation for us. So obvious, so commonplace, is this proposition, that the very sound of it is offensive, perhaps; nevertheless, propositions become commonplace by being often repeated on account of their wisdom. The commonplace in this matter is the supremely philosophical proposition.
Governor Corwin, of Ohio, once met a negro who had run away from Kentucky, and was living in rags in the free State. “You made a mistake in running away,” said the Governor to the black man. “You had friends and clothes and money enough south of the Ohio, as I happen to know, for I was acquainted with your master. Are you not now in need of all these things?” “Yes,” said the negro. “Then,” said the Governor, “you made a mistake in running away.” “Governor Corwin,” said the negro, “the situation in Kentucky is open, with all its advantages, and if you choose to go and occupy it, you can do so.” I turn to any foremost representative of the doctrine that there is an opportunity of repentance after death, and I say: The situation is open, with all its advantages; do you purpose to go and occupy it? Not you, not I, in our senses. Do you purpose to recommend to any one near and dear to you that he or she shall go and occupy this opportunity, with all its advantages? Not you, not I, while we retain sound minds. Henry Clay was once taunted by Calhoun in the American Senate with defeat in debate. “I had him on his back,” said Calhoun, of the Kentucky senator; “I was his master.” Henry Clay walked down the aisle of the senate chamber, and shook his long forefinger toward Calhoun, and said, “He my master! he my master! Sir, I would not own him as a slave!” Looking at this whole matter practically, from the point of view of sound common sense, I say to any advocate of the doctrine that there is opportunity for repentance after death, “He my master! Neither in life nor in death would I own that theory or any one of its defenders as a slave!” —Extract from Prelude to Joseph Cook’s 152d Boston Lecture.