BODILY DEFILEMENT

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 7, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 60, No. 32.

Read the full edition

BODILY DEFILEMENT.

BY ELD. M. H. BROWN.
In Matt. 15 and Mark 7, we have an incident in the life of Christ which gave him an excellent opportunity to reprove the Pharisees for holding so scrupulously to their traditions, while they trampled upon the commandments of God. The Pharisees had complained to Christ that his disciples failed to follow the tradition of the elders in not washing their hands before eating.
This tradition rested on the whimsical idea that any particles of dust or accidental impurities that were on the hands might be transferred to the food by contact, and with the food, be conveyed to the stomach, and thus become a source of defilement; hence the thoroughness with which they washed their hands before taking bread, and the religious exactness by which it was enforced.
Some have concluded from the words of the Saviour, that it is proper to eat and drink what we choose without fear of injury or bodily defilement. Some have even argued that the Saviour’s language justifies a person in the use of tobacco.
A superficial reading of the language may give an air of plausibility to the argument, but upon a closer examination we find, no foundation upon which such an argument or conclusion could be based. That which so often misleads the mind and leads to wrong conclusions in examining the writings or words of others, is overlooking the object and scope of the argument and the subject of discussion.
It should be noticed that the relation of foods and drinks to the human system is not under consideration. The Pharisees brought no charge against the disciples of Christ in regard to their eating or drinking that which was contrary to their traditions or ideas of propriety. The offense they committed was in not washing their hands before partaking of food. The object of the Saviour in answering the charge of the Pharisees, was to sweep away the foolish notion which they entertained that bodily or moral defilement would result from eating with unwashed hands, and thus show the true character of their tradition, and also place in contrast with their unreasonable traditions, the commandments of the divine law.
We would also call attention to the fact that if the Saviour designed to teach that no food or drink would defile a man, then intoxicating drinks can be used under the sanction of the great Teacher. This conclusion is certainly very repugnant to our reason and better judgment; yet it is a legitimate conclusion from the premises, and proves the premises unsound and the position untenable.
Had the Pharisees understood the Saviour to teach such views, how ready and eager they would have been to seize the opportunity to catch him in his words, and array him against Moses and those Scriptures that he had exhorted them to search! Certainly the disciples did not understand our Lord to teach that all substances and liquids were proper to introduce into the human body; for we find Peter, years afterward, at the time of the vision given him at Joppa (Acts 10), declaring that he had “never eaten anything common or unclean.” Some seem to have drawn comfort from the vision of Peter on that occasion, flattering themselves that it gives license to eat all manner of four-footed beasts and creeping things. It is clear, however, that Peter, guided by the Spirit of God, came to a very different conclusion; for he testifies (Acts 10:28) as follows: “God hath showed me that I should not call any man common or unclean;” or, as stated in verse 34, “I perceive that God is no respecter of persons.”
Now we will notice the Saviour’s conclusion. This certainly must end the controversy. After giving a list of those things that come forth from the heart, he says, “These are the things which defile a man.” Does he then add, “But to eat and drink such things as we choose or our appetites call for, defileth not a man”? Not at all; but he does conclude that to “eat with unwashed hands defileth not a man.”
How clear, consistent and reasonable! May both reader and writer practice that self-denial, and so crucify the flesh with its affections and lusts, that we may share in the final reward of the overcomer.