The Short-Dress Objection

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 14, 1883

FromReview and Herald, Supplement, Vol. 60, No. 33

Read the full edition

The Short-Dress Objection.

BY ELD. G. I. BUTLER.
Perhaps there is no objection urged against the visions with more pertinacity than this about the short dress. It is well known that for several years Sister White advocated a style of dress some eight or nine inches from the floor, with pants clothing the lower extremities; and that the Testimonies taught that this style of dress would be sensible, healthful, and well pleasing to God. But this dress was never made a test, and there were some classes, such as the aged, and those whose husbands were opposed to it, and others, whom Sister White did not advise to wear it. To others she did recommend it, but never approved of its being pressed upon those who were unwilling to wear it, as a test, by their brethren and sisters.
It may be proper to give a few of the reasons which she assigned why such a dress should be worn. It was thought it would be preferable to have some sensible, established style of dress for our sisters to wear, rather than to follow the fickle, changeable, ridiculous fashions which emanate from the godless city of Paris. The tyranny of fashion at the present day is marvelous. If any church or ruler required such changes in dressing, it would be thought unbearable. Had Mrs. White recommended and tried to enforce anything in the dress line one-tenth as objectionable as many things which are put on by Christian ladies in obedience to the goddess Fashion, she would have been abused, if possible, far worse than she is at present.
It was claimed for this reform dress that it was a healthful dress; that it avoided tight lacing; that its weight was supported from the shoulders; that it protected the lower extremities, was not in the way when going up stairs, avoided the filth of the streets and the wet grass after dew or rain, and was in many ways preferable to the fashionable dresses usually worn. Many not of our people liked the appearance of the dress when tastefully worn; others did not. It was claimed to be in harmony with the Bible requirements of plainness and simplicity of dress. It was thought that it would be a means of helping our young people to keep away from worldly society, as they would not care to go where their dress was a subject of remark, and was not popular; and as the people of God anciently had the ribband of blue upon their garments to distinguish them from the world around them (Num. 15:38), so it would be well that God’s people now should differ in their dress from the world, for the same reason.
These reasons have much weight, even to-day; and if the proposed change had been cheerfully made, we are sure much good would have resulted; but the effort to make this change cost us much labor and trouble. From the first there was much opposition to it. It is a sad fact that many of our sisters do not desire to differ from the world in dress; on the contrary, they desire to imitate them as much as possible. While there was on the part of many of our most humble and devoted sisters an acceptance of the dress in good faith, on the part of many others there were complaints, fault-findings, murmurings, heart-burnings, etc., innumerable. Some lacked taste in putting it on, and it appeared unbecoming. Others made it the main theme of their discourse, and a main point in their religious faith, tested their sisters by it, and had little faith in those who did not wear it. They became narrow and bigoted and exclusive. They made the dress, which was designed as a blessing, a galling yoke.
The trouble which grew out of these things was great, not because there was anything about the dress which was ridiculous, but because of the unreasonable course concerning it pursued by many. Our ministers were forced to spend much time to keep the elements quiet, and to talk about the dress question. Sister White had often to speak about it at large meetings, to try to get some to take a reasonable, sensible course, but did not always succeed. I could give many particulars on this point, if necessary. Suffice it to say, that a point was reached where it became evident that the short dress, which was designed to be a blessing to our people, became an actual hindrance to the cause, because of the unreasonable course of many among us concerning it. Sister White ceased to speak in its behalf, and did not wear it herself, and it soon ceased to be generally worn.
Many had said they were willing to dress plainly, if not required to wear the short dress. They did not like that, and found many things they considered objectionable about it, etc., etc. These were taken at their word; but many of them soon showed that their hearts were really longing for worldly fashions, and their objections to the short dress were merely excuses. Many of those who opposed the short dress most violently, just as soon as the change was made, turned around and found even more fault with Sister White than before. Ever since that time, there has been quite a large class who have used this dress question as their strongest objection to the visions. Though they hated the short dress, and did all they could to oppose it, or murmured and complained about it, and made it hard for those who upheld it, yet as soon as it was dropped, they began to find fault with that, and said it was inconsistent to leave it off, and a strong evidence against the visions being of God. They said Sister White had pursued a very unreasonable course, and how could they have any confidence in her? etc., etc. It is a very hard thing to please some people, especially when the murmuring spirit is in their hearts.
Of course our enemies have made the most of this, and have done their best to deepen and intensify these feelings. They exclaim in their “Extra:” “Just think of this idea! the Lord giving them a particular style of dress, and because they would not wear it, he modifies his directions to suit their taste!” “Does the Lord ever lower his standards to suit people’s tastes or ways?” They have here placed this objection in just as strong a light as they are capable of placing it, and we propose to take hold of it, and show from the Bible that in some things the Lord does accommodate his requirements to people’s ways, even when he would prefer they should do some other and better way. Though he does not always do it, or do it concerning some of his requirements, or generally do it, yet in matters of lesser moment, and of expediency, where he has recommended a better way he sometimes permits them to follow their own choice, though it always proves less beneficial to them than if they had done as he directed. We propose to prove this too plainly for denial.
We first notice Numbers 11. We learn here that the Lord designed to provide food for his people other than flesh-meats. He gave them manna, the “corn of heaven,” and it was for their best good to be satisfied with it; but they were not. “They fell a lusting,” and “wept” and said, “Who shall give us flesh to eat?” “Our soul is dried away; there is nothing at all, beside this manna, before our eyes.” Moses was displeased with them. God was provoked at their course, but told Moses that they should have flesh to eat, even for a month, till it became disgusting to them. Moses could hardly believe this himself; but the Lord fulfilled his word by causing an immense number of quails to fly through the camp about three feet from the ground, and the people killed great quantities of them, till those that had the least had ten homers apiece. This seems almost incredible, when we consider the amount. But the record says: “While the flesh was yet between their teeth, ere it was chewed, the wrath of the Lord was kindled against the people,” and vast numbers perished. The Lord wanted them to be satisfied with the food he gave them, but they were not, and he gave them their desire; but it was in wrath, and they suffered because of it.
Another instance is recorded in Numbers, chapters 13 and 14. God designed that the children of Israel, after seeing his mighty works in Egypt, and receiving instruction at Sinai and sufficient discipline in the wilderness, should go at once into the land of Canaan. It seems he had promised them this, though of course the condition of faithfulness and obedience is always to be understood. When they came to the borders of Canaan, twelve spies were sent to see the condition and fruitfulness of the land, its inhabitants, walled cities, etc. They viewed it, and returned, bringing with them of its marvelous fruits. Ten of these men told falsehoods about it, and weakened the faith of the people by saying they could not conquer it. Two of them, Caleb and Joshua, gave a good report, and said, “Let us go up at once, and possess it; for we are well able to overcome it.” But the others said, No; “let us make a captain, and let us return into Egypt.” They would not go up, as the Lord wanted them to do. God took them at their word, and said, “As truly as I live, as ye have spoken in my ears, so will I do to you: your carcasses shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me, doubtless ye shall not come into the land concerning which I sware to make you dwell therein, save Caleb, the son of Jephunneh, and Joshua the son of Nun.” “After the number of the days in which ye searched the land, even forty days, each day for a year, shall ye bear your iniquities, even forty years, and ye shall know my breach of promise.” Chap. 14:28–34. It seems that the Lord does change his course toward individuals when they manifest disobedience and murmurings toward him, and lets them have their own way, even when he had made the most solemn promises to them. Conditions must always be understood in connection with God’s promises.
Another instance we notice in 1 Sam. 8, where the children of Israel wanted a king. God and his prophet were both displeased with this desire on the part of the people. The Lord said concerning their proposal, “They have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.” He told Samuel to “protest solemnly unto them,” and show them the evils which would result from such a course, showing them that it would be far worse for them than it had been under his arrangement; but they still persisted in their purpose to have a king, and God let them have their desire. He directed his servant to select and anoint a king for them, and Saul was chosen by the prophet of the Lord; yet the very evils which God had foretold, did follow, and their kings were a cause of many of their calamities at last, and it was far worse for them than if they had cheerfully accepted the Lord’s plan.
Another instance where this principle is apparent is in the case of divorces. Matt. 19. The Lord through Moses had given a law in Deut. 24:1, permitting the people to put away their wives for various causes. When the matter was referred to Christ, he said, “Moses, because of the hardness of your hearts, suffered you to put away your wives; but from the beginning it was not so.” Then he lays down the original principle, that there was only one proper, rightful cause for divorces, which was adultery; and that those who procured them from other causes were guilty of sin. This was God’s original plan; yet he permitted another course, because of the “hardness of the people’s hearts.” But there is no question but the original plan would have been better, had they been willing to follow it, and that they brought grave evils upon themselves by not doing so. Yet the prophet of the Lord gave them such permission, no doubt by divine consent.
This astute Marion editor might better study his Bible a little more, and be a little more candid, and he will find that God has “modified his directions,” and has “lowered his standard,” in some instances, to “suit people’s ways.” Here are four instances in which God has changed his course, because the people were not willing to take that course which would have been best for them; and no doubt many others could be mentioned. God, in his infinite love for man, and desire to save him, accommodates his ways to him in matters of lesser moment, and does the best he can for him under all the circumstances, rather than to lose his hold on man altogether. His standard of purity and right is ever the same, but in matters like eating, drinking, and dressing, having one form of government or another, or even in the greater matter of divorces, he has permitted that to be done which was not really for their best good, rather than force the people to do that which they were wholly unwilling to do. This we have proved beyond successful contradiction.
And here is a principle which is precisely analogous to that on which the charge in the dress question is based. There is no question in my mind but that if our people had cheerfully accepted the reform dress in the spirit in which it was given, had worn it without murmurings and fault-finding, and had taken a reasonable, sensible course concerning it, we should be far better off to-day for so doing. Many of our young people who have gone over to the world would have been saved from such temptation. We should not see among us such violations of the Bible teaching on the subject of dress as we now do. It would have been better for us in many ways. Yet taking the situation as it was, with all the bitter complainings and murmurings about the dress which were going, and with a set of extremists and narrow-minded ones who were making it their test of religious character, and forcing it upon the unwilling, we think it was far better to treat it as we did. It took more effort to keep our people in a right state of mind concerning it than we could afford for the benefit to be obtained from it.
The dress question should never be exalted to an equality with the great moral questions of the Bible, such as keeping the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus. Meekness, humility, charity, goodness, patience, and other Christian graces, are ever more important than the cut of the clothes we wear, or the eating of certain kinds of food. We should give those subjects just the place God gives them in his word; and if we will notice closely, we shall soon discern that that place is not near so prominent as that which he gives to the great moral principles of his law, and the teachings of Christ. We claim that Sister White in her teachings has ever taken this position.
And in conclusion we inquire, What is there in all this question of the short dress which proves the Lord has never given special light through visions to Sister White? We fail to find any such evidence. All that we can see in it is simply this: At one time Sister White taught that it would be well, health-wise and spiritually, for our sisters to wear a certain form of dress because of certain reasons. But after a new class of circumstances had developed, because of the utter unwillingness of many of our people to adopt it, and opposition and complainings on the right hand and on the left, she ceased to urge it upon any, let all act their own pleasure in the premises, and set before them for their acceptance a dress more in conformity with those commonly worn, but plain and unobjectionable. What is there in all this so bad or so provocative of unbelief? For our part, we fail to see anything of the sort. Every reason which could be brought against her for doing in this matter as she has, can be brought against God’s servants in other days, and even God himself, as we have plainly shown. The Bible contains many instances where the Lord has thus, in minor matters, permitted his people to take their choice, though his way would have been better for them, and though they reaped results from it which were not for their good. Brethren and sisters, let us be reasonable; let us be candid; let us put away our fault-finding and our unbelief, and treat the work of his Spirit with respect.