BY ELD. G. I. BUTLER.
We mean by “the new recruits” two writers in the Sabbath Advocate, who have recently, in a special supplement gotten out for circulation among our people, delivered themselves of five or six columns each of matter which none but apostates from our people could write. There is an intensity and bitterness in the expressions of such which it is hard for ordinary mortals to imitate. We refer to “Prof. A. Mc Learn,” and the “eminent lawyer,” J. S. Green. We do not propose in these columns to notice to any great extent what they say. It is hardly worth while. We think all candid persons will find no difficulty in discerning the spirit and animus of their articles. From a few specimen extracts they will readily discover whether they have the spirit of Christ or not. We should say that those who could be influenced by such articles might as well go with them at once. They could certainly not help us in our work of warning the world, and preparing for the coming of Christ. After such an exhibit of their temper and feelings, we feel honored by their denunciations of us, and pity those who have been so unfortunate as to have their praises. We feel it is much better to have some people denounce us than praise us.
“Prof. Mc Learn” starts out by heading his article, “An Unpleasant Duty,” tells us that it is “with great reluctance” that he proceeds to discharge it, and says, “I have been well treated by the S. D. Adventist people.” “There are many excellent people among them whom I love and respect.” After mentioning a young man who had changed his mind concerning the meaning of a text of Scripture because of statements in Mrs. White’s writings, he says:—
“And this is a fair sample of how the people are taught to stultify their judgment, ignore facts, and destroy their individuality. They are afraid to investigate the Scriptures, lest something will be discovered unfavorable to the positions taken by Mrs. White.”
Our people will probably know how truthful this statement is without any comments of mine. Again he says:—
“No man who is known to doubt the Testimonies is allowed to hold any position of trust, nor is he fellowshiped by the mailers; and that means the church, for the people simply do whatp. 6 they are told. The church polity makes it a hierarchy of the most despotic character.” (Italics are his.)
We think this veracious statement will be rather startling news to most of our people. A few lines below he says, “Is Jesuitism more unreasonable and heartless?” By the way, is it not a little singular that this statement should be made that no one cherishing doubts of the visions “is allowed to hold any position of trust” among us, when in the same issue of the Advocate the editor claims to prove that Eld. U. Smith has no faith in the visions whatever; yet he holds the position of principal editor of our leading paper, and is a member of the Committee on Publications and of the Board of Trustees of the Publishing Association? We hardly know how to harmonize the statements of these very truthful people. Our readers may believe which of their statements they choose, or what is safer, neither of them.
But we proceed to give a few more utterances from Prof. Mc Learn:—
“Now we know that these men are not sincere in what they declare. We mean the men who are now in authority, and are working for the sake of personal aggrandizement.”
The writer is forced to take this statement as referring largely to himself, because a few sentences below he is singled out as the one specially in mind. We suppose our worthy colleagues will have to share a little of it with us, and possibly Bro. Smith must take a little of it also, seeing he is so unfortunate as to be still in office. It would seem from these grave statements of the “Professor’s” that our people might better be hunting up a better class of men to place in positions of authority,—men who are not hypocrites, but “sincere,” and men who are not looking for their own “aggrandizement” alone,—such men, probably, as Prof. Mc Learn, and the “eminent lawyer,” Mr. Green.
Again, let the “Professor” speak:—
“And indeed a large proportion of the most intelligent of the S. D. Adventist people are perplexed and confused by the glaring inconsistencies of Mrs. White. They feel the demoralizing effect of this horrible nightmare that is distressing and destroying the church, and groan on account of it. There is not a minister in the denomination who feels that he is a free man. If he does not believe the Testimonies, he must either act the hypocrite or walk the plank, crushed under the iron heel of ecclesiastical despotism.”
What surprising discoveries and fearful denouements the “Professor” has brought forth! One would think S. D. Adventists had restored all the ancient paraphernalia of persecution,—racks, thumbscrews, the fagot, and the dungeon,—with which to destroy the good people who will not believe in Mrs. White. And yet he says he has been “well treated” by this people. Is it not strange he has got away with his life? How is it that he can understand so well the feelings of every minister among us, when he never saw one-half of them in his life? It is strange we should all stay in a church where we feel we are slaves. We should suppose there would be a regular stampede to follow the “Professor’s” example, and go over to our S. D. Baptist brethren. But we have not heard of it yet.
Speaking of Sister White’s explanation of a certain vision which he claims to think is very absurd, he uses the following language:—
“It is insulting to the intelligence of decent people. It is trifling with sacred things. It is blasphemy in the sight of God. But why will not the people rise in the majesty of their blood-bought rights, and shake off this destructive incubus?”
How strange that so gentle and kindly a man as Prof. Mc Learn has usually appeared, could utter such language as this we are quoting! It can only be accounted for by the fact that he has become inoculated with the Marion virus of bitterness.
In speaking of the College, he pretends that Sister White disapproves of education, because she fears our people will become intelligent, and reject her counsels. “The real purpose is to prevent those under her influence from becoming enlightened, that they may the more easily become her willing dupes.” Just as though our people did not everywhere know that the voice and pen of Mrs. White have done ten times more in behalf of education among our people than those of any other person in our ranks! He says furthermore:—
“You have too heavy a load to carry. You cannot cover such crooked tracks as Mrs. White has made for you. You are educated to deceive by means of her blasphemous pretensions. You are not free men, and you know it.”
And so on with nearly six columns of like tenor. And this is the kind of reward our people get for the good usage which he says he has received among us. Well, this is not so much Prof. Mc Learn as the “anti-vision” virus which he has been drinking down in such large draughts among his new acquaintances. Poor man! he is to be truly pitied.
We cannot afford as much space for the effusions of Mr. Green, the “eminent lawyer.” He uses this language of Eld. Waggoner, one of our ablest and most faithful laborers, one of the pioneers in this church of which Green still claims to be a member:—
“He is an old hand at such deceptive work, is paid for doing so, has a greater influence in deceiving our people than he is willing to allow that I have in the Advent faith. He is one of those old and tried visionists, who, under the lead of Ellen G. White, believed their work for sinners ceased in 1844.”
Eld. W. never embraced the Advent faith till after 1844; so of course, if this statement is true, he must have believed he was lost himself. It would be a peculiar thing for a man to zealously embrace a doctrine which taught his own damnation. Who can think Mr. Green himself believed his own statement?
This is a fair specimen of his accusations. They are largely a rehash of those just quoted, charging upon us that we are all in bondage and deception, trying to compare Sister White to Jo. Smith, and asserting that S. D. Adventists and Roman Catholics are much alike in spirit and church polity. And still he seems determined to stop with us, and boasts of his continued membership in such a church. It seems strange and wonderful how men who a year or two ago were among us, kind and friendly, and who seemed to be interested in all that pertains to the prosperity of this cause, could become so bitter, so unreasonable, and so cruel in their statements. If giving up faith in the visions of Mrs. White affects men in this way, as it seems to do in almost every case, we may well pray to our heavenly Father to preserve us from such a calamity.
This point, when properly considered, becomes one of the strongest evidences that the visions are from a good source, and opposition to them from an evil source. “By their fruits ye shall know them.” We have known of scores of men in our experience who were kind, candid, humble, and agreeable; but something came up which soured them against the visions. Perhaps they were reproved, or some of their friends were, or they taught something which displeased them, or their track was crossed in some way. Perhaps they had been ministers, and souls were converted under their labors, and they were doing good. But all at once the change came. They became bitter, unreasonable, and would make the most extravagant and unjust charges against those whom they had formerly considered their best friends. They began to hunt up everything they could rake and scrape to blacken the reputation of Sister White, and destroy faith in those pure and elevating Testimonies. Things that once would have had no weight as objections, now became magnified into mountains of difficulty. Their principal meat and drink seemed to be to denounce Mrs. White and all who had faith in her work. From our hearts we pity such victims. In charity we can only hope they know not what spirit they are of. But having seen so many such cases during the last twenty years, any recent examples do not surprise us. These last two recruits are only following the old familiar example. But the work of God has been able to stand through a “Messenger” movement, the Snook and Brinkerhoff defection, Charles Lee’s departure, H. C. Blanchard’s denunciations, and many other lesser apostasies, including those “two new recruits” to the opposition ranks. And yet its course is onward with a steady growth, and never were there more hopeful indications of its final success. We are sorry for those who act so unwisely; the loss to them is far greater than to the cause.