BY ELD. J. H. WAGGONER.
In 1855 the “Messenger party” greatly exalted over their anticipated triumph over the Seventh-day Adventists. They confidently expected to see us give way, and yield to their demand that we should renounce “the Testimonies.” They brought themselves to really believe that “the visions” were the great stumbling-block to our people, and hindrance to the success of the message. They prophesied that many would leave us if we clung to the visions, while thousands would unite with us if we renounced them. The latter they could not know; and we knew that numbers could never make up for the rejection of any point of present truth,—for quenching the Spirit and despising prophesying. See I Thess. 5:19, 20, and context. And being quite well acquainted with the parties who were grumbling and complaining, we were not intimidated by the threat that such would leave us; for we knew that in very few cases would the departure weaken our cause. From that time to this it has been asserted that all the men of education and talent leave the S. D. Adventists, being cramped by the visions. But that is not true. I cannot now call to mind a single individual of liberal education who was ever thoroughly with us, who has left us. Very few educated men have ever come among us, and they are mostly now with us. The ministers who have left us were not educated men. And the visions do not restrain any from the exercise of any privilege to which they have a just right as Christians. If they ask more than that,—if they want to receive reverence because of their ability, without regard to their Christian standing and their devotion to the cause,—then we hope we shall always have something among us that will act as a check on their selfish ambition.
Instead of weakening on account of their crusade against “the testimony of Jesus,” we firmly avowed our conviction that it was a part of “the present truth,” a necessary means of bringing us to the unity of the faith and spirit; and God vindicated our position for his truth’s sake. The cause revived and prospered. Our enemies were scattered,—literally broken to fragments. Thus they proved that the visions were not the cause of disunion as far as they were concerned. They professed to believe the message, and they had a paper, and they rejected the visions; but the thousands did not join them! But the real believers in the message were more firmly united than before.
We are passing through a similar experience at present. A party who “know not what they do,” are trying to drive us from our position, telling us how many we have lost, and how much we will lose, if we cling to the Testimonies. But we are not ignorant in these matters. When they publish to the world that Elds. Hull, Cornell, and others left us because of the visions, they only subject themselves to scorn. If they know no better, they are ignorant indeed. We know better. And this proves that this Advocate party is animated by a blind, unreasoning prejudice, determined to carry their points regardless of the truth in the case. In almost every case where individuals have left us professedly on account of the visions, we know that that was the pretense; the real cause lay further back. Quite often it has been on account of the visions exposing and reproving the primary cause, and they, “willing to justify themselves,” say they leave because of the visions. And this far they speak the truth: if there were no means of exposing selfishness; if they could gratify their ambition, and have their own way unrestrained, they might not leave us. Thus far are the visions the cause of their departure. But we do not deplore it; rather we rejoice in it. Our strength and prosperity depend upon these things.
The “Advocate Extra” causes me thus to “call to remembrance the former days.” When the “Sunday question” was thrown into politics, and made the great—the only—issue in our State election last year, we felt assured that this was the beginning of a more aggressive movement toward the union of church and state. Their defeat made them no less determined, but turned their attention more to the national issue, where, and not in state action, only can they succeed. We have watched the skies since that time, and see many evidencesp. 7 of the coming storm. In a most surprising manner a spirit of inquiry is awakened among the people at large, and our publications are called for as never before. The subscription list of our “pioneer paper” has nearly doubled during the present year. The Spirit of God is moving the people, preparing for a mighty work in the third angel’s message.
And this vigorous movement on the part of the “Marion party” is another sign of the same thing. We have never known a revival of the work of God without Satan making just such efforts to counteract it. And we cannot deplore the event. It will turn to the benefit of the cause of truth. It will no doubt result in the overthrow of some, and they who instigate and abet the movement incur a terrible responsibility on that account. It will cause others who are lukewarm, lacking zeal in the spirit of the message, to take a decided stand on one side or the other. And whichever side they take, the result will be beneficial to the cause on which they merely hang in a half-hearted manner.
I have no desire to notice much in this “Extra.” I leave that to others if they think it necessary. I have elsewhere noticed the principles and the main facts involved. To those acquainted with the facts, most of the statements in this “Extra” appear ridiculous. Instance the following from J. S. Green. Speaking of me, he says:—
“He is one of those old and tried visionists, who, under the lead of the visions of Ellen G. White, believed that their work for sinners ceased in 1844. While under that delusion, he used to travel hundreds of miles to see and encourage those of the same faith. I wonder if he still adheres to this old delusion, to wit, that his work for sinners ended in 1844!”
Now it is generally known by those acquainted with me that I was not an Adventist until 1851; that I never heard a sermon on the advent in the first or 1844 message; and it is truth that when I embraced the advent faith, having never been acquainted with the Adventists, I did not know that anybody ever believed that the work for sinners ended in 1844; that I never saw a preacher of any kind who believed it; in all my travels I never met with a person who believed it; I never, to my knowledge, saw more than one person who believed it, and I did not know it when I saw him, but heard it reported of him afterward; and that when I first became acquainted with Bro. and Sr. White, they were laboring for all classes, as they ever did afterward, without any intimation that their work was limited to any class or classes. The above from J. S. Green is not only false in every thought and particular, but ridiculously false. A little knowledge with his blind zeal might save him from making many false statements which he is so free to make now. This is a specimen of the reliability of the contents of the “Extra.”
Again, his notice of my saying that Sister Addie Harvey was the second wife of Bro. Harvey, is deceptive, a mere cavil, unworthy of a man pretending to any honesty. He tries to leave the impression on the reader that I made a false statement; and any one knowing nothing of the circumstances, and believing his word, and reading what he says of me,—thus: “He is an old hand at deception;” and “has a greater interest in deceiving our people,” etc.,—would suppose I had intentionally deceived, and would take it for granted that she was his first wife. Now I will confess that I had no personal knowledge that Bro. Harvey was ever married to any woman before he was married to Sister Addie. But I had such confidence in him, and in the accomplished lady with whom he lived, and who was known in the community as his wife, whose hospitality I often shared, that I really believed they were married, and that she was his lawful wife; and I believe it still. Mr. Green may know that he had been married twice before his marriage to Sister Addie; but I do not know it. Then she would have been his third wife. But that would not at all change the nature of my statement; and Mr. Green knew this, therefore he tries to cast discredit on my word without giving any explanation to inform the mind of the reader, if he had such information. Perhaps I ought not to be surprised at his course; for I learn by this “Extra” that he is “an eminent lawyer” (I was also ignorant of that fact), and this may be characteristic of that wing of the legal fraternity to which he belongs. It looks to me, however, very much like the act of a quibbling pettifogger.
He refers to our holding the General Conference at Rome, N. Y., as though it were a great offense. But he has hardly been with us long enough, or occupied that position among us, to claim a right to dictate to us in such matters. Other church organizations move their Conferences from place to place continually, as we do our State Conferences. There is nothing in our organization to forbid our doing so. In this talk he may show his spirit, but he can never convince anybody that any wrong was done.
And his legal ability was shown in the opinion which he volunteered that, if we carried out our intentions to examine at Rome into the condition of our institutions, and to there ascertain the will of the stockholders concerning them, such expressed will to be carried out at the legal meeting in Battle Creek, we would endanger their charters! In California the laws are more restrictive in reference to corporation meetings than they are in Michigan. When we incorporated our College, we selected a lawyer in San Francisco as our counselor, and he is also a stockholder, but not an Adventist. I do not know that he is a professor of religion at all; nor do I know that he has ever been published as “an eminent lawyer,” but he is reliable and honorable, and that is far better. In order to get the minds of our stockholders without subjecting them to much travel, I suggested that we hold our annual College meeting sometime after our camp-meeting, where the stockholders would most likely be; that there we could ascertain their will in regard to the affairs of the College, take the proxies of those who could not or did not wish to go to Healdsburg, and then at the legal meeting carry out the wishes of the majority as previously expressed at the camp-meeting. Our counsel approved the plan as judicious, in every way meeting the requirements of the law, and one which could not fail to be satisfactory to the stockholders. But this action in the East, Mr. Green stigmatized as dangerous to the existence of our institutions at Battle Creek. With due deference to his great legal acquirements, I am free to say we knew better. He has not yet got over his soreness on account of this movement. He says at Rome “the people knew the least about the management of our institutions which were located at Battle Creek.” That may be a good reason for moving our meetings; let the people at large become acquainted with them. Further than this, he may learn that the business of our Conference is done by delegates, and the affairs of the institutions are controlled by the majority of the stock as represented, not by the people of Rome or Battle Creek.
Mr. Green is not the first one who has come among us whose strength and interest are manifested in finding fault with everything which he cannot manipulate. But if he has done that for the cause which would entitle him to a leading position, I have never heard of it. He says that he has an interest in these matters, as he is a member of the church. This may be. But if it shall fall to my lot to go East again, I shall try to remedy that unfortunate circumstance by bringing charges against him, not for disbelief of the visions, which he would fain have people believe is the universal ground of action, but for publishing falsehoods with malicious intention, namely, to injure the reputation of members of the church and laborers in the cause. If put to the proof on his statements, his unfitness for church-membership will be manifest to all. This is my only answer at present to some other matters of which he has spoken.
Having now given this matter all the attention to which it is fairly entitled, I leave it, and I trust, finally, except as above indicated.