BY H. W. KELLOGG.
In J. S. Green’s articles in the Advocate Extra, he makes statements that are erroneous and misleading in regard to the Harvey estate, and as I have some knowledge of the facts, a statement of them may be proper.
On the 15th of January, 1877, James Harvey and Adeline P. Harvey, his wife, deeded to Eld. James White all of the real estate that they owned in Indiana (Bro. and Sr. White, being in California at the time, knew nothing whatever of the transaction), and assigned to him three notes on which there was due $4,844.47. He also, at the same time, made payable by indorsement to Uriah Smith seven other notes, on which there was due $891.75. One or two days later, Bro. Smith, at Bro. Harvey’s request, transferred these notes to James White. Bro. Harvey at the same time deeded to his wife his property in Battle Creek, and made his will, leaving to his wife property, which, together with that deeded to her, he considered worth $3,000. Bro. Harvey put the papers which he had made out to Eld. White into the hands of Eld. S. H. Lane, to have them recorded, and delivered at the REVIEW Office for Bro. White when he should return from California. This Bro. Lane did about the time of Bro. Harvey’s death, which occurred early in March.
When Eld. White returned from California some months later, he found that notes, claims, and suits had been brought against Wm. R. Carpenter, the executor of Bro. Harvey’s estate, amounting in the aggregate to over $5,000. Some of these claims were settled without litigation; others were believed to be unjust, and expensive law-suits followed, and judgments were rendered against the estate in the most important ones.
The money to meet these expenses and settle these claims was furnished by Eld. White from the funds received from Bro. Harvey. The amount realized from the sale of property deeded to Eld. White was some less than thirty-five hundred dollars ($3,500); this, with the notes, would make only a small amount over nine thousand dollars put into Eld. White’s hands (and not nearly twenty thousand, as J. S. Green would have us believe), if all the notes had been collectible, but some of them were not. From this fund, Eld. White put $500 into the S. D. A. Educational Society as from Bro. and Sr. Harvey, and I believe a like sum into the Oakland church, also $100 into the ten-thousand-dollar fund. About one month before his death, Eld. White sent to Indiana for Wm. R. Carpenter, the executor, to come to Battle Creek, andp. 9 bring his accounts and papers, for the purpose of determining just how the Harvey matter stood, as Bro. C. had collected money on the notes, and settled claims, etc. He also sent for Eld. J. Fargo, president of the Michigan Conference; for the same purpose, as the real estate in Indiana was in his hands. Those brethren came, and Bro. White and the writer spent several hours with them in looking up this matter. The result of this investigation showed that of the amount which had then been received there was in Eld. White’s hands twenty-seven hundred dollars belonging to the Harvey trust fund. From this time until after Eld. White’s death (Aug. 6, 1881), no change was made in the fund. The execution of the trust then fell upon Sister White. The REVIEW Office charged James White’s estate with the twenty-seven hundred dollars, and credited the same to E. G. White, “Harvey Trust Fund,” and it never was placed to her personal account; and further, not a dollar of this fund was ever in her hands, only as on the Office books, as above stated. Sister White did not, nor did any of her family, ever have the use or the handling of a dollar of this fund.
In July, 1882, this fund received further credits by cash from J. Fargo, balance from sale of land after deducting expenses, $1,287.10, and cash per W. R. Carpenter, collection, $5.00, making a total of $3,992.10 in the fund for E. G. White to appropriate, to complete the execution of the trust. This she did by ordering charged to this fund, and credited—
| To the European Mission, | $2,395.26 |
| “ “ English “ | 798.42 |
| “ “ Danish “ | 798.42 |
| 3,992.10 |
During the spring and summer of 1882, J. S. Green wrote one or more letters to Sister White, in which he threatened to bring a suit against her to compel her to pay over to Sister Harvey a portion of this trust fund, and went so far as to put the matter in the hands of a law firm in this city. Sister White very properly refused to treat with or recognize him in the matter, and sent his letters to the General Conference Committee; and decided to execute the trust according to the expressed wishes of Bro. Harvey, leaving the General Conference Committee, who had charge of the different mission funds of our people, and who were here on the ground, and knew of the circumstances of Sr. H., to do as they thought best about letting her have money from the funds which had received donations from the Harvey trust fund.
In the execution of this trust, Bro. White made no charge for his time or services, and did not, nor did any of his family, receive a penny for such time or service. It is doubtful if ever a trust was executed in a more conscientious manner, or with greater fidelity.
The representation made by J. S. G. that at the time he wrote demanding money for Sr. H., the “little property” Bro. H. had left her was “nearly exhausted” is without foundation, as he well knows. The facts are that on the property, which was free from incumbrance, Sr. H. had made quite extensive improvements, costing not less than one thousand dollars, and she was owing not to exceed six hundred dollars at the time.
Now a word in reference to J. S. G.’s statements about the value of Eld. White’s estate. He says that that portion of it in Calhoun county was appraised at over twenty-seven thousand dollars. Now, as one of the appraisers, I deny the statement, and assert that this estimate included all the property of which he died possessed, both real and personal; and that this appraisal was too high is proved by the fact that the portion of the property which has been sold did not bring the appraised value. He is careful not to mention the fact that there were claims against the estate, amounting to several thousand dollars, that when paid would reduce it considerably below twenty thousand. His insinuation that Sister White fled from this city to California as a guilty criminal, is a silly and baseless fabrication. We cannot but believe this attack upon Bro. and Sr. White to be malicious in intent, satanic in origin, and slanderous and libelous in its publication.