BY ELD. G. I. BUTLER.
WE feel it is a duty which we owe to those of our people who are young in the faith to give them a brief history of the origin and work of those who are so persistent in their attacks upon our people and the visions. Having long lived in Iowa, we have had an intimate acquaintance with this whole movement from its rise. It is not a pleasant subject, and were it not that they are making the most strenuous efforts to flood our churches with their tracts and extras, we would not say a word concerning them. It is purely a work of self-defense. They have complained that no attention was paid to their utterances. It is a subject we wish to avoid as far as possible, and would rather attend to our legitimate work of warning the world of the coming of Christ. But at times, when the inexperienced are endangered by our silence, we feel it a duty to speak out. Every statement we make we are able to verify by abundance of proof.
In May, 1865, Elds. B. F. Snook and W. H. Brinkerhoff, the president and secretary of the Iowa Conference, and the only ministers in it, attended the General Conference of our people, held in Battle Creek, Mich. They came there in all apparent friendship, and associated with their ministering brethren, and took part in the Conference proceedings, in apparent good faith; but according to their confessions afterward, they “were on the lookout to see if they could not find something to reproach” us with. They parted with the Christian salutation, and with professions of love; but before they had got far away, they began to show forth their spirit of hostility and treachery.
They returned to Iowa, and were actively engaged in going from church to church, telling falsehoods about Bro. and Sr. White and the Battle Creek church. This they confessed themselves. Taking advantage of their influence in this way, they destroyed the confidence of many good brethren in Iowa in the cause they had loved. In July, Bro. White appointed a general meeting at Pilot Grove, Ia., and many invitations were sent out, and a large attendance secured. I was present. One day was spent in considering the stories they had been telling, and Bro. White and others replying to them. The result was such that many who had come there with strong confidence in them lost it, and their followers dwindled away, and at last the men themselves confessed their wicked course.
Bro. and Sr. White went to Marion, and spent some time with them, and apparent union was restored. Elds. Snook and Brinkerhoff both wrote out confessions which were published in the REVIEW, copies of which can be seen in the book written by Eld. Smith in answer to the objections to the visions. In these confessions they admitted that they were in a “state of darkness,” had been “led by the wicked one,” had acted a dishonorable and wicked part, had abused the kindness and confidence of the friends of the cause, and begged for mercy and forgiveness. We should be glad to have all read these confessions for themselves.
In a very few months they turned back to the same course again, and returned to the service of the “one” they previously confessed they had been following. They came to Michigan to the remnants of the old “Messenger party,” who had years before been engaged in the same warfare against the visions and our people, procured what printing material they could, which had been left after the collapse of the old Hope of Israel, and started their paper in Marion, Ia. They went from church to church in that State, and did their utmost to destroy the confidence of our people in the work and in the visions. They had great advantages at the time, as they had been the only ministers of our people in the State, and the principal officers in the Conference; but they were met here and there, and soon their influence was broken. Several churches, however, were broken up, and perhaps one-third of the membership went with them for a time.
After a comparatively brief period, when these men found they were not going to accomplish all they had hoped to, their zeal waned, and they both went off into Universalism. The Iowa Conference, after passing through this crisis, and having the doubting, discordant elements removed from it, soon recovered from its effects, and made a most rapid growth. In a very few years it more than doubled its strength, and has become one of our strongest Conferences. Some of those who had been deceived by these movements returned to us, and have been valuable members. In several places where churches had gone down under these influences, better churches have been built up.p. 8
Those who were left after Snook and Brinkerhoff left them, have been dragging out a lingering existence ever since. They have most of the time kept up their paper. We believe it did stop a few months after their interesting experience with the notorious Fuller, referred to in another column; but it is still published.
It may be said, Why refer to Elds. Snook and Brinkerhoff, since they have closed their connection with them? We answer, The inception and birth of every religious movement goes far to show its nature. If the beginning bears the mark of a divine origin, it stamps the movement itself as of the right character, and vice versa. The history of the past verifies this. All Bible believers look back to the time when God moved upon Noah, Moses, John the Baptist, and the apostles, and discern the divine hand in every one of these cases. Their work was of God. So of Luther, Wesley, William Miller, and many others. These were moved out by the Spirit of God, and good fruits mark the progress of their work. We claim the same origin and results in this movement that we are engaged in.
But this was not so with Mahomet and Joseph Smith, neither is it true of spiritualism. While they make loud professions, we easily see the deceptive character of their origin. Here is an important principle by which to test every work: “The tree is known by its fruits. Either make the tree good, and its fruit good, or the tree corrupt, and its fruit corrupt. Every tree is known by its fruit.” The tree is the origin, the fruit the results.
It seems almost cruel to apply these well-established principles to the movement of which we are speaking, and we pity those who are so blind in it that they cannot discern these things. Here is a movement, which, according to the confession of both those who led out in it, started in deception, was led by the devil, was a violation of confidence and trust reposed in them by the friends of the cause, and was marked by treachery and ingratitude. From our own personal knowledge, we believe these confessions told the truth, though much more of the same sort might be added to them. This movement, then, in its inception, stands condemned by its own leaders, who were far the ablest men who have ever been engaged in it. It started in deception, and it has never yet extricated itself from that atmosphere. It would be a wearisome and unprofitable task to follow it through all its various meanderings and experiences. We shall not undertake it. We will but briefly notice a few more points.
Suffice it to say, that after S. and B. became Universalists, and they were deprived of their leading lights, things dragged somewhat, till finally one Goodenough (we always thought the first half of his name was a misnomer), from Wisconsin, came to their rescue. He was one who had greatly desired to preach among us, but there were certain weaknesses in his character which prevented it. He was joyously welcomed at Marion, and made us some little trouble here and there in our new churches, where the character of this movement was not well known. He became quite prominent for a while with them; but finally some difficulty and strife came into their counsels, and his weaknesses becoming unpleasantly prominent, he retired, and started another little movement of his own.
Nathan Fuller sojourned in Marion toward a year, and for a time was made much of, and did considerable preaching for them. His son worked in their office much longer, and was, according to the best of our recollection, elected to some prominent position. We know nothing against his moral character. But in the troubles among them arising from Goodenough and his (Fuller’s) father, etc., there came a split; and their General Conference went one way, and their Publishing Association another, and for several months the paper ceased to be printed. In giving a history of any movement, it seems necessary that some account should be given of the troubles through which it passes.
Things by this time had come to a low ebb. Jacob Brinkerhoff, the present editor, the brother of the one we have mentioned before, and one of the worthiest among them, was induced to return, and try to revive the paper. He had gone away to work in a secular printing office, rather in disgust. He took it as his own private property. (We believe their Publishing Association had collapsed.) He has labored with an earnestness worthy of a better cause, and has managed to keep the paper afloat.
In recent years the Long brothers, of Missouri, have come to the rescue, and seem to furnish most of the bone and sinew of the party. They figure as the principal controversialists, and have most to say of the “terrible fanaticism” of the S. D. Adventists, the “awful despotism” of Mrs. White, and the “Jesuitical hierarchy” at Battle Creek. They are at present very active, because we had some troubles with our College at Battle Creek last year under the administration of “Prof. McLearn,” which resulted in the closing of it for one year. But as these now seem happily over, and the prospect of its starting again under better auspices seems fair, we hardly know what will furnish them with their next ammunition. The “two recruits” spoken of elsewhere have also encouraged Eld. A. C. Long to great earnestness of late. If it were not so serious a question, it would be amusing to see the amount of crocodile tears these men shed at the terrible condition of S. D. Adventists, and their great sorrow (?) at being obliged to speak of our wickedness. One would judge from their words that they were forced, under a stern sense of duty which was terribly painful to them, to speak of these things, if he didn’t know that all through their history for the past eighteen years there has been no theme to compare with this in interest to them. This has been their leading stock in trade, and their main bond of union. So anxious have they been to welcome any one from our ranks that they have badly burned their fingers by picking up those in several instances whom we had cast off as bankrupt in character.
In closing this chapter of history, we must not forget to mention the two last recruits, Prof. McLearn, and J. S. Green, whom they call the “eminent lawyer.” (We think he has been as high in position as justice of the peace, if not higher.) Like all new converts, we judge from their recent utterances, that they are trying to equal or excel their predecessors in this movement. Who will drop in next, we are not able to say; but we can assure all prospective candidates, You will meet with a most cordial reception. Judging from the past, we should not anticipate any very close inspection of your character, if you only have one qualification,—dislike to the visions of Mrs. White, and can denounce them strongly enough. And we would cordially advise all who think they would like to train in that company to enlist at once.
In conclusion, we would speak briefly of the present condition and influence of this movement. It is about seventeen years since their paper started in Iowa. We have not visited Marion for a few years past, but the last time we were there we found their printing office in a medium-sized room in a private dwelling, the editor’s house. (It had at first occupied quite a large brick building.) The editor, his wife, and one hired girl, attended to the domestic duties, and did the printing. I should judge he made a fair living out of the business, with the help of his garden, advertising, etc. If hard work and sacrificing for their cause were worth anything, he would certainly be entitled to credit; for he has done more of these than all of the rest of that company we ever knew. Their work there may have increased some recently; we understand they publish their paper oftener; but we have never learned of any special increase. Their church in Marion, which, according to the best of our knowledge, numbered some fifty or so when they first drew off from us, had dwindled down quite small by removals and otherwise. Though well acquainted in the State of Iowa, we do not now know of another church of theirs in the State which keeps up regular Sabbath meetings, or, in fact, of any other church at all. We believe they have a very few companies in Missouri; at least they did some years since. And though we have traveled much through the country, we know of scarcely any other churches of this people that pretend to keep up public worship.
But have they not quite a numerous membership here and there? Yes; there are quite a number scattered in various places who sustain their organ, the Advocate. These hold a great variety of religious views. For years their paper had a standing notice at the head of a column, something like this: “The editor holds himself responsible only for editorials and selections.” Hence the contents of the paper were a sort of religious hash. One could get a great variety. You could be treated to “Sabbath,” “life and death,” the “soon coming of Christ” and the “age to come,” “non-resurrection of the wicked,” “no devil,” etc., etc.; but especially to a large amount concerning the awful wickedness of Mrs. White’s deceptions, and the terrible errors of S. D. Adventists. By accommodating all these different views, the paper has been enabled to live, if not to thrive. There are enough peculiar people in the world who hold some pet notion, and really want some place to ventilate it in, and the Advocate is handy for such. They want freedom, and here they can find it. But how do these people, with such diversified views, manage to get along together? Why, there is one bond of union to which none of them ever fail to respond, and that is opposition to the visions. All understand this key-note. It is the slogan which never fails to arouse them to battle.
At the present time this movement seems to be quite lively. They have received two new recruits, and hope for more. It has been quite a while since they have had any important accessions. Of course they will keep these gifts in lively exercise till they are worn out. We judge from present appearances this will not be long.
Well, on the whole, we are inclined to take this matter quite philosophically. We think perhaps this movement has a place in the economy of Providence. It furnishes a convenient lighting place for those who murmur and complain; for those whose heads are sore; for those who cannot endure the straitness of the way, and the pure teachings of the Spirit of God; for those who want a change, and “more freedom,” and, in short, for those who cannot harmonize with the spirit of our work. Why should we not recognize this necessity, and keep cool, and let every one find his proper place? But while we feel thus, we want every one to understand the facts, so that they may act freely, and know what they are doing. For this cause we have written this brief history of the “Marion” movement. We could add much more of a similar tenor. But perhaps this is sufficient.