A CONVERSATION ON PORK, TEA, AND COFFEE.
By N. J. Bowers
A. I HAVE called, Mr. B., to have a talk on some points of your faith which I cannot fully endorse. I have enjoyed your lectures on the Sabbath and other topics, but your views about eating and drinking I am not at all satisfied with. The stand you take on the pork, tea, and coffee questions seems to me to be very extreme, and I fear the good impressions you have made upon the minds of so many will be turned to direct opposition against the doctrines you have so far preached. B. I am glad you are so frank and earnest in this matter, my friend. I hope to be able to help you over the hard places you may have found in regard to the subjects you mention. Please to proceed. A. In the first place, I do not think what we eat and drink should concern others. That is a personal matter, and as such, should not be interfered with. B. I think you mistake in saying that our eating and drinking habits concern nobody but ourselves. How many wives and children suffer from the drink habit. How many murders occur through whisky, and what a burden is laid on the tax-payer, arising directly or indirectly from alcoholic liquor. How many prisons, jails, asylums have to be built, and criminal prosecutions maintained, in great part because people will exercise this “personal prerogative” of drinking, which prerogative nobody has a right to interfere with according to the principle you have announced. This cry of “nobody’s business” is a great delusion. A. Oh, of course I do not mean alcoholic stimulants. These are very bad, and occasion much misery and crime. These are exceptions. But what we eat cannot so concern others. The Bible says, “Not that which goeth into the mouth defileth a man.” B. Whisky goeth into the mouth and yet defileth the man, according to your own admission. So the statement is to be understood in a restricted, and not in the broadest, sense. The words you quote are not at all relevant. Jesus was not preaching a sermon on physiology or hygiene. He was condemning some of the traditions of the Pharisees. He was not teaching the people that anything and everything was proper and good for food. He was not speaking from a health standpoint at all. That was not the topic of discourse. Right here is where you and others mistake the Lord’s meaning. From the Pharisaic religious point of view, and not from a hygienic, that which goeth into the mouth defiles not. The Pharisees were superstitious and careful about their ceremonies, even in small things. When they returned from the markets they would not eat until they washed their hands, not indeed from ordinary uncleanness, but for fear their hands had been in contact with that which their religion esteemed unclean. This was one of the “traditions of the elders,” and as such Jesus denounced it. Read Matt. 15:1–20, and Mark 7:1–19. You say, again, what we eat cannot concern others. You are much in error. Health is one of the greatest blessings. The apostle John considered it so. In writing to the “well-beloved” Gaius he wished “above all things” that he might “prosper and be in health.” 3 John 2. Health is related to happiness, and happiness to the general welfare. What we eat has much to do with our health. That only which is for the best development, vigor, and general well-being of the system, should be used for food. There are things as unfit to be eaten as there are things improper to be drank. Use that only which will give the best health. A. This seems all well enough, but do you think it sinful to eat pork? B. If it is unhealthy, and so not fit to be used, it is wrong. In cases of extreme hunger or of starvation, where nothing better could be obtained, the case would be different. Where there is better food than the swine, and so much of it, we had best not eat him. A. Does not the vision Peter had of the sheet prove the swine good for food? B. No. Because facts and investigation prove it not good. The Bible will not contradict them. B. 1. The swine’s habits. Filthy and disgusting in the extreme are they. 2. His mode of life. Breathing the foul and fetid air of his pen or enclosure. This air, taken into his lungs, cannot help but taint and poison the blood and affect the whole system. 3. He is diseased through and through. He is an animated mass of corruption and scrofula. He is often full of the dread trichina, and dies quickly of cholera. Hog’s flesh will soon putrefy. There is a widespread feeling that pork is not fit to eat. Avoid it. A. Well, what were swine created for? I think nothing was made in vain. If the hog is not for us to eat, of what use is he? What was he made for, anyhow? B. For a scavenger. He is good to devour putrefying animal bodies, and thus to destroy bad and sickening smells. He is to the earth what the buzzard is to the air. We needn’t eat him in order that he fill his mission. He wasn’t made in vain. Turn them loose, and let them612 go about their business. If they multiply too much, kill some of them off. They’ll make soap-fat and machine-grease. What were lizards, garter-snakes, crickets, and snails made for? If we can discover no other use for them, shall we eat them? A. Did not the Lord tell Peter what he had cleansed he must not call unclean? B. Yes. But let us examine a little into the case. In that “vessel” “were all manner of four-footed beasts of the earth, and wild beasts, and creeping things, and fowls of the air.” Acts. 10:12. This takes in all the animal kingdom. Has the Lord made all the beasts, birds, and reptiles on the face of the earth fit to eat? Has he cleansed all the snakes, lizards, turkey-buzzards, porcupines, dogs, and cats? Yes, if he has cleansed the hog. If one is clean and fit, all are. He didn’t tell Peter he had purified the hog and let all the rest go. No, he had cleansed them all. A. What do you think the vision teaches? B. That God had abolished the former national distinction between Jew and Gentile. He had broken down the middle wall of partition which had separated them, and he made it known to Peter in vision. Read Acts 10:28: “God hath showed me that I should not call any man common or unclean.” Peter was a Jew, full of the prejudices of his race, and he needed the lesson. A. Do you think the law against eating unclean animals is binding on Christians? B. As a physiological prohibition it is still in force. This law of nature still stands. The Lord has a reason for doing what he does. He does nothing arbitrarily. The reason why the Lord prohibited swine and other animals was doubtless because they were unfit for food. There is no animal in the Levitical list of prohibited animals that is commonly used among Christians but the swine. The rest are all but unanimously discarded. If the hog was unhealthy then, it is now. No change for the better has come over him. Domesticating hasn’t improved him hygienically. If any difference, he is less fit for food. We do not read in the Bible of swine being penned up and fatted as we do now. It seems that they were allowed to range at large under the care of keepers. Matt. 8:31–33. I think if the hog was not fit for the Jew to eat, he is not fit for the Christian. When the Lord separated ancient Israel from the nations, he sanctified them from their abominations, and bade them be clean. Lev. 20:25, 26; Deut. 14:3. Christians should also be separated from all that is unclean in flesh and spirit. 2 Cor. 7:1. The distinction between clean and unclean beasts was not a thing of the times of Moses. It was recognized before the flood. Gen. 7:2, 8. So it was not a Jewish peculiarity, and need not of necessity have been destroyed with the dissolution of Judaism. I grant that the law of which you speak may not be binding on us. But the physiological distinction upon which it was based still exists. A. Does not the Bible somewhere say, “Let not him which eateth not judge him that eateth”? B. Yes, in Rom. 14. In this chapter the apostle has reference to the Jewish feasts which were done away in Christ, and perhaps to meats offered in sacrifice to idols. He does not speak of eating in general. Compare Rom. 14 with 1 Cor. 8, particularly verse 21 of Rom. 14 with verse 13 of 1 Cor. 8. Read also 1 Cor. 10:19–33. A. How do you explain Col. 2:16 in reference to meats and drinks? B. The apostle may refer to the meat-offerings and drink-offerings of the Jewish system of worship, along with the annual sabbaths of that system. Read Lev. 23:37, where they are associated.