LOOSE REASONING ON A PERFECT LAW.
By R. F. Cottrell
In Zion’s Watch Tower I find an article, apparently editorial, entitled “The Ten Commandments,” in which I find the following good admissions:— - “God’s law is nothing short of perfection.”
- “The ‘law of LOVE’ contains the spirit of the law to Israel,—the ten commandments.”
- “None thus actuated by the law of love have any desire to violate the law of commandments.”
- “The ten commandments demand absolute perfection. Matt. 22 : 37–40. On these two commandments hang all the law.”
In the above the italics and small capitals are as given by the writer. In the same article is the following assertion: “To any recognizing the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, there can be no bondage to the observance of any day.” According to this, though he admits the ten commandments to be a perfect law, and that “none actuated by the law of love have any desire to violate” them, yet Christ makes us free from “the observance of any day.” (The italics are his.) Then Christians, those who have no desire to violate these commandments, are not bound to keep the fourth commandment, at all. Are they at liberty to disregard the other nine commandments of this perfect law? An apostle calls this “the perfect law of liberty.” James 1 : 25; 2:10–12. And he teaches that we shall be judged by it. How can we be judged by a law which Christian liberty makes us free to disregard? Is it bondage to obey the law as God gave it by keeping the day that he appointed? Is it true Christian liberty to substitute another day, as we think best? If so, are we not at liberty to substitute what we choose for the other nine? But though our writer holds that we are not bound to the observance of any day, yet he reasons in behalf of a Sabbath as follows:— “The fact that the law compelled a rest every seven days, and that mankind seemed to require it, is an excellent reason why such a day should be observed. And love to God and a desire to worship him and to commune with his children are the best of reasons for observing such a day.” There were good reasons, then, for the institution of the Sabbath; why should it be abolished? Our author continues:— “As to which of the seven days should be the best to observe, the church very early in its history decided that the first day of the week would be very appropriate, since on it Jesus arose from the dead and met with them and caused their hearts to burn as he expounded to them the Scriptures. Luke 24 : 27, 32. Accordingly, we find that to meet on that day was very common among them, even before they came to appreciate fully their liberty, and132 while they still, to a great extent, observed the seventh day also.” Thus he clearly admits the human origin of the first-day Sabbath, and also that the early Christians still observed the seventh day. But they gradually came, as the Dark Ages approached, “to appreciate fully their liberty,” and the result has been no Sabbath, or a first-day Sabbath, just as you please; but to keep the day that God rested upon, blessed, sanctified, and commanded to be kept holy, and by the observance of which we “honor him,” is a bondage too grievous to be borne. Is it so? Is that which the spiritually minded call “a delight, the holy of the Lord, honorable,” indeed a yoke of bondage? Isa. 58 : 13.