RESULTS OF THE LEIPSIC DISPUTATION

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 20, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 21.

Read the full edition

RESULTS OF THE LEIPSIC DISPUTATION.

BY JOS. CLARKE.
In July, 1519, a discussion was held at Leipsic, an important commercial city of Germany, between Martin Luther, the great apostle of the Reformation, and Dr. Eck, a notable champion of the papal church. At the time of this discussion, Luther had not left the papal church, but was an Augustine monk, and a priest of that order.
During this debate, which continued nearly three weeks, different subjects were discussed; such as the primacy of the pope, the infallibility of his decrees, etc. Dr Eck supported his positions by quotations from papal writers and laws; while Luther relied upon the word of God as the only infallible rule and guide in deciding such questions.
It was at this time that Martin Luther first publicly approved the doctrines of Huss; and here, too, I think, he first publicly announced that the existence of a place called purgatory could not be proved from the Bible, while he as yet admitted there might be such a place. Slowly but surely, step by step, Luther emerged from the darkness of the man of sin, continually proceeding on the principle of interpreting the writings of men by the word of God, and not the contrary.
It was this occasion which brought Luther to the final step of separation from the papal church. At this time he made this remarkable confession: “Learn from me,” said he, “how difficult a thing it is to throw off old errors confirmed by the example of all the world, and which, through long habit, have become second nature to us. I had then been seven years reading and explaining the Holy Scriptures with a great zeal, so that I knew them almost by heart. I had also the first-fruits of knowledge, and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ; and I even maintained openly that the pope is not the head of the Christian church by divine right. And yet I could not see the consequence that flowed from this; namely, that the pope is necessarily and certainly of the devil; for what is not of God must needs be of the devil.”
Luther adds, further on: “I no longer permit myself to be indignant against those who are still attached to the pope; since I, who for so many years studied the Holy Scriptures so attentively, still clung with so much obstinacy to popery.”—D’Aubigné’s History of the Reformation, Vol. 2, pp. 37-74.
Applying the same method of reasoning, we may come to the same conclusions as to errors we inherit from the papacy; and the motives which caused Martin Luther to exercise the gift of patience, should prompt reformers at this time to practice this excellent virtue.