CONVERSATION ON THE SABBATH QUESTION.
Sabbath-Keeper.—Our previous interview closed with the question before us whether or not the Sabbath is a type. The assumption that it is a type furnishes the foundation for many false positions. I was about to show that the Sabbath is not a type of anything, and from the very nature of the case cannot possibly be. This can be made clear to any one by a few questions. What is the object of all types as used in the Scriptures? Inquirer.—Their object is to point out something connected with the work of redemption; to prefigure, and instruct the world concerning, the work of the Messiah. They were “shadows of things to come; but the body is of Christ.” S.—Very true. When, then, were types introduced? I.—When a Redeemer was provided and promised; for then men were instructed to offer sacrifices, pointing forward to the death of Christ. S.—What made these types appropriate and necessary? I.—The fall of man and his need of a Redeemer. S.—Could a type have been introduced before man thus fell, and became a subject of redemption? I.—Certainly not; for the type would then have been to him only a constant and gloomy reminder of his coming apostasy, and would have led directly to that result. S.—Does it not, then, clearly follow that any institution which originated before the fall, or any service introduced before that time, could not have been in any degree typical in its nature? I.—That would certainly be the case. S.—Now when was the Sabbath instituted? I.—Ah! I see; it was before the fall; and hence it could not have been a type. This is all clear enough to me. Yet there are some who deny that the Sabbath was instituted at creation. S.—This we know very well; but there is the record; and he who denies it denies one of the plainest statements in all the Scriptures. Any professed Christian who thus refuses to hear the Scriptures we can only regard as Christ directs in Matt. 18 : 17. No one would ever have dreamed of denying that the Sabbath was instituted at the close of the first seventh day of time, had he not an object to gain—that object being to set aside the Sabbath of the Lord. I.—I have recently read an article on the Sabbath question in which the writer says: “The fact that God sanctified it [the Sabbath] is no proof that it was instituted for man, or even then made known to him;” and he illustrates his statement by Christ, whom he says the Father sanctified from eternity, but did not send him into the world till the fullness of time. S.—It is utterly astonishing that men should make such assertions. In respect to sanctification, there is no parallel between Christ and the Sabbath. But there is no record that Christ was sanctified from eternity. Not till the plan of redemption was devised, was he ordained to come into the world to suffer. But that has nothing to do with the Sabbath question. Christ says that “the Sabbath was made for man.” Had this writer never read that? Man was to use it; for him it was sanctified. When? In Eden. To sanctify is “to set apart to a holy or religious use.” How could the Sabbath be thus sanctified, and that, too, for the human family who were the only ones to use it? I.—It could have been done only by telling those for whom it was made how to use it. S.—Exactly; there was no other possible way. And did not this constitute a Sabbath law? I.—Certainly. It must be that most writers overlook this fact. This writer flies off to the idea that the Sabbath is not mentioned from Adam to Moses. S.—What if it is not? The record has given us the institution of the Sabbath in all its completeness, and the additional fact that a law was given at the very beginning for its observance; and what more could be expected in a narrative which comprises the history of about twenty-five hundred years within the brief compass of fifty chapters? But here is another fact: The Sabbath is not mentioned from Moses to David, a period of five hundred years. Shall we therefore say it was not kept during that time? We can say so with just as much consistency as any one can say that it was not kept from Adam to Moses, because the Scriptures do not mention it. But we know it was kept from Moses to David, and enforced under the penalty of death. To urge the silence of the Scriptures as against the Sabbath from Adam to Moses, is a quibble unworthy of any candid mind. I.—But did not Moses say to the Israelites that God had brought them out of Egypt, and therefore he commanded them to keep the Sabbath day? S.—Very true; but what has that to do with the general announcement of the Sabbath law as given from Sinai by God himself, forty years before this rehearsal by Moses recorded in Deut. 5, in which no such “therefore” occurs? I.—It is strongly urged as proof that the Sabbath was given to the Israelites alone, and was not binding upon any other people. S.—If this is so, then the same would be true of every other precept, in reference to which the same expression is used, would it not? I.—So it would seem; for certainly there can be no reason for making the Sabbath an exception. S.—Very well. Now turn to Deut. 24 : 17, 18, and you will read that they were not to “pervert judgment” because they had been redeemed from Egypt; “therefore,” said the Lord, “I command thee to do this thing.” Now will any one have the audacity to assert that this moral principle was given to Israel alone, and was not binding upon any one else? I.—It would be truly audacious to make such an assertion. S.—But they must assert it, or give up their assertion in regard to the Sabbath; for the statements are exactly parallel. But further, the same statement is made in reference to every one of the commandments. Turn to Lev. 19 : 36, 37, and there you will read: “I am the Lord your God which brought you out of the land of Egypt. Therefore shall ye observe all my statutes.” Now will any man who has a particle of either candor or conscience left say that the commands not to blaspheme, nor kill, nor lie, nor steal, nor commit adultery, were given to the Israelites alone, and were not binding upon any other people? If not, neither can he say that the Sabbath was given to them alone, on account of this expression which is used alike with reference to them all. I.—This puts the matter in a new light. But why is it that opponents of the Sabbath never notice these points? S.—Your question implies that you have observed, and if you watch them you will observe, that they studiously avoid these facts. I have been engaged in this Sabbath controversy now for nearly thirty-two years; and though these considerations have been repeatedly urged upon the attention of Sabbath opponents, I have yet to see on their part the first allusion to them; and the reason is obvious: it would spoil their argument. I.—Then they are not honest. S.—We pass no judgment upon them, but leave them to answer for their motives to Him who reads all hearts. But these nevertheless are the facts. And there is another feature in their course of action which certainly needs a little explanation: Why do they always appeal to Deut. 5 : 12-15, on the Sabbath question, instead of to Ex. 20 : 8-11? I.—I have noticed that they do this, but I have never particularly considered why they do it. S.—Then please think upon it a moment. The promulgation of the law by the great Law-giver, Jehovah himself, is recorded in Ex. 20. Forty years afterward, Moses, about to leave that people, delivers to them a solemn address, recounting the dealings of the Lord with them, and among other things rehearsing the principal circumstances of the giving of the law from Sinai forty years before. He does not pretend to be giving an original law, nor a verbatim repetition of the law. He says of the Sabbath, “Keep the Sabbath day to sanctify it, as the Lord thy God hath commanded thee,” referring back to the giving of the law recorded in Ex. 20. Now why do they not appeal to the original law in Exodus, instead of flying to this rehearsal by Moses in Deut. 5, forty years later? I.—I can see very clearly, as you remarked on the preceding point; it would spoil their argument to go to Ex. 20. S.—So it would; and every one else can see it as well as yourself. We are willing to give the words of Moses in Deut. 5 : 15; 24 : 17, and Lev. 19 : 36, 37, due consideration, and all the weight to which they are entitled. They are simply an appeal to the gratitude of the children of Israel by Moses, urging their deliverance from Egypt as an additional motive why they should be loyal to God, and keep his Sabbath and all his commandments, but not by any means intimating that others are not bound to obey him on the general ground of obligation to their Creator, though they may not have had the particular experience granted to Israel. I.—Yes; that is certainly a consistent view; and I see no evidence of fairness or candor thus far in the way the opponents of the Sabbath try to sustain their position. But there is another text which is urged to prove that the Sabbath was a Jewish institution. It is Ex. 31 : 17, where God tells the Israelites that the Sabbath was a sign between him and them throughout their generations. S.—Well, let us look at this. As a sign what was its significance? I.—I suppose it was both an evidence and a pledge of the relation existing between God and Israel. S.—And how would this relation be described? I.—It was on the part of the people an act by which they showed that they took the Creator of the heavens and the earth to be their God; and it was on his part the condition on which he had pledged himself to regard them as his peculiar people. It was the bond of union between them. S.—In this we agree exactly. And now let me ask further how this relation had come to exist between God and Israel? I.—Because all other nations had apostatized from the truth, and Israel alone were believers in the true God. S.—And was not that relation just such as exists, or should exist, between every true believer and God? I.—I never thought of it in that light; but I do not see why it is not so. S.—And, further, when any of the Gentiles joined themselves to Israel to be the people of the Lord, and began to keep his Sabbath, was it not a sign between them and God? I.—It must have been, certainly. S.—And if all the world had done this, would it not have been a sign between them all and God?153 I.—I do not see how to come to any other conclusion. S.—Then there was nothing to confine it to that people, only as they had the truth; and immediately the conclusion follows that all who have the truth in this dispensation as well as the former sustain this relation to God, and equally need the sign as an expression thereof. I.—This is to me a new view of the subject. I will think of it. S.—Please do so; and when opportunity offers, we will consider further this important theme.