NO COMMAND FOR SUNDAY-KEEPING

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 10, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 24.

Read the full edition

NO COMMAND FOR SUNDAY-KEEPING.

ADMISSIONS OF FIRST-DAY KEEPERS AND WRITERS.

BY E. VAN DEUSEN.
“Admissions in favor of truth from the ranks of its enemies, constitute the highest kind of evidence.”—Pres. Mahon.
Heylyn says: “Thus do we see upon what ground the Lord’s day stands: on CUSTOM FIRST, and voluntary consecration of it to religious meetings; . . . after, from the canons and decrees of councils, the decretals of popes, and orders of particular prelates, when the sole managing of ecclesiastical affairs was committed to them. . . . The Lord’s day had no such commands [as the Sabbath had] that it should be sanctified.”—Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 352.
Smith says,—after quoting the first-day passages and advancing the usual arguments: “Taken separately, perhaps, even altogether, these passages seem scarcely adequate to prove that the dedication of the first day of the week to purposes above mentioned, was a matter of apostolic institution or even of apostolic practice.”—Bible Dic., Art. Lord’s Day, p. 356.
“Chamber’s Encyclopedia” says: “By none of the Fathers before the fourth century is it identified with the Sabbath, nor is the duty of observing it grounded by them, either on the fourth commandment, or on the precept of Jesus or his apostles.”—Art., Sabbath.
Luther Lee, D. D., says: “There is no express commandment for observing the first day of the week as a Sabbath, and yet it is almost a universal custom.”—Lee’s Theology, p. 562.
Lyman Abbott, editor of the Christian Union, says in that paper of Jan. 19, 1882: “The current notion that Christ and his apostles, authoritatively substituted the first day for the seventh, is absolutely without any authority in the New Testament.”
The Watchman (Baptist), in reply to a correspondent, says: “The Scriptures nowhere call the first day of the week the Sabbath. . . . There is no scriptural authority for so doing, nor, of course, any scriptural obligation.”
The Prot. Epis. Church says: “The day is now changed from the seventh to the first day, . . . but as we meet with no scriptural direction for the change, we may conclude it was done by the authority of the church.”—Explanation of Catechism.
Sir Wm. Domville says: “Centuries of the Christian era passed away before the Sunday was observed as a Sabbath. History does not furnish us with a single proof or indication that it was at any time so observed previous to the Sabbatical edict of Constantine, in A. D. 321.”—Examination of the Six Texts, p. 291.
At a “ministers’ alliance” held in Sedalia, Mo., Feb. 25, 1884, Mr. Fuller cited the fact that there was in reality no divine legislation establishing the Christian Sabbath.—Sabbath Sentinel, March, 1884.
The Encyclopedia Britannica, after calling attention to the usual scriptural arguments, says: “Still, it must be owned that these passages are not sufficient to prove the apostolical institution of the Lord’s day, or even the actual observance of it.”—Art. Sabbath.
The M. E. Theological Compendium, p. 103, edition of 1865, says: “It is true there is no positive command for infant baptism, . . . nor is there any for keeping holy the first day of the week.”
Richard Watson, in his Theological Dictionary, says: “Now there is not on record any divine command to the apostles to change the Sabbath from the day on which it was held by the Jews to the first day of the week.”
Dr. Fallows says: “The New Testament is silent about a change of days. The apostles doubtless observed the same Sabbath before and after the resurrection of our Lord, as would be very natural.”
Robert Hall, D. D., says: But to “commemorate the resurrection of Christ by the religious observance of any day, we have no express command in all the Scriptures.” And again, there is not “a particle of scripture law.”
Confession of the Swiss Church: “The observance of the Lord’s day is founded not on any commandment of Christ.”
Hear Prof. Burgess: “Can we find the text in the Bible enjoining the observance of this day? No!”
Now hear the Rev. Dr. Barnes: “No precept for it is found in the New Testament.”
The Townsend Herald says: “It must be admitted, too, that no statute can be altered or repealed by any power inferior to that which enacted it. . . . You may search from Genesis to Revelation for a command or injunction to this effect [first-day observance], but you will search in vain.”
Buck’s Theological Dictionary, p. 403, after presenting all the first-day arguments, says: “These arguments, however, are not satisfactory to some; and it must be confessed that there is no law in the New Testament concerning the first day.”
The Augsburg Confession, drawn up by Melancthon, says: “The observance of the Lord’s day is founded not on any command of God, but on the authority of the church.”—Cox’s Sab. Manual, part 2., chap. 1, sec. 10; also History of Sabbath, p. 434.
Dr. Heylyn says: “Take which you will, either the Fathers or the moderns, and we shall find no Lord’s day instituted by any apostolic mandate; no Sabbath set on foot by them upon the first day of the week.”—History of the Sabbath, p. 266.
Sir Wm. Domville says: “Not any ecclesiastical writer for the first three centuries attributed the origin of Sunday observance either to Christ or his apostles.”
Neander says: “The festival of Sunday. . . was always only a human ordinance; . . . far from the early apostolic church to transfer the law of the Sabbath to Sunday.”—Rose’s Neander, p. 186; Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 229.
Bishop Jeremy Taylor says: “The primitive Christians did all manner of work upon the Lord’s day, even in the times of persecution, when they are the strictest observers of all the divine commandments; but in this they knew there were none.”—Doctor Dubitantium, part 1, book 2, chap. 2, sec. 59.
Coleman, another first-day writer and observer, says: “No law or precept appears to have been given by Christ or the apostles, either for the abrogation of the Jewish Sabbath or the institution of the Lord’s day, or the substitution of the first for the seventh day of the week.”—Ancient Christianity, chap. 26, sec. 2; Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 336.
Morer says: “The Lord’s day had no command that it should be sanctified; but it was left to God’s people to pitch on this day or that for public worship.”—Div. on Lord’s Day, p. 233; Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 344.
Kitto, speaking of the time of Chrysostom, A. D. 360, says: “Though in later times we find considerable reference to a sort of consecration of the day, it does not seem at any period of the church (ancient) to have assumed the form of such an observance as some modern religious communities have contended for. Nor do these in any instance pretend to allege any divine command, or even apostolic practice, in support of it.”—Cyclopedia of Biblical Literature, Art. Lord’s Day; Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 363.
Frith says: “The Jews have the word of God for their Saturday, sith [since] it is the seventh day, and they were commanded to keep the seventh day solemn. And we have not the word of God for us, but rather against us; for we keep not the seventh, . . . but the first, which is not commanded of God.”—Frith’s works, p. 198; quoted by Hessey; Andrew’s Hist. of Sab., p. 460.
“The conclusion of the whole matter:” “No positive command” “for keeping holy the first day of the week;” “not on record any divine command” “to change the Sabbath to the first day of the week.” And again: “The New Testament is silent about a change of days;” “no express commandment in all the Scriptures;” and “there is not a particle of Scripture law;” its “observance” “is not founded on any commandment of God.” Again: “Can we find the text” “enjoining” “this day? No!” “No precept for it” “in the New Testament.” Further: “You may search from Genesis to the Revelation for a commandment,” “but you will search in vain.” And again: “It must be owned” that “the usual” “passages are not sufficient.” And “it must be confessed that there is no law in the New Testament concerning the first day.” The “Lord’s day is founded not on any commandment of God.” And again: there was “no Lord’s day instituted by any apostolic mandate.” “No ecclesiastical writers of the first three centuries attributed” Sunday “observance either to Christ or his apostles.” “The festival of Sunday” “was always only a human ordinance.” “The primitive Christians did all manner of work upon the Lord’s day.” “No law or precept” “given by Christ or the apostles” “for the substitution of the first instead of the seventh day of the week.” “The Lord’s day had no command that it should be sanctified.” “Nor do these [early Christians] in any instance allege any divine command, or even apostolic practice” for it. “And we have not the word of God for us, but rather against us.” “The Lord’s day had no such commandment” “that it should be sanctified.” “By none of the Fathers” was its observance “grounded either on the fourth commandment” or “the precepts of Jesus or his apostles.”
And yet again: There is “no expression for observing the first day of the week.” The substitution of “the first day of the week for the seventh day is absolutely without any authority in the New Testament.” “There is no scriptural authority for so doing.” “We meet with no scriptural direction for the change.” It is a “fact that there was in reality no divine legislation establishing the Christian Sabbath.”
Now we ask in all candor, Why rob the Creator of that which is his? If there is no such commandment, as these writers say (and the truth have they spoken), is it not right to “return unto the Lord,” and walk in the “old paths?” These men were not trying to tear down the first day; on the contrary, very many of them were trying to support it at the time they made these utterances. There is this much in their praise,—they spoke the truth.