RESURRECTION OF THE WICKED, AGAIN.
The remarks made on this subject in the REVIEW of July 8 seem to have seriously affected our esteemed contemporary, the Herald of Life, published in Springfield, Mass. The Herald is the organ of a class who do not believe that the wicked will ever be raised from the dead, hence its effervescence over that article which set forth some of the incontrovertible evidences showing that they will be raised. Because said article appeared in the REVIEW, the Herald thinks the doctrine of the non-resurrection of the wicked must be making inroads among Seventh-day Adventists. Not at all. This question was happily so thoroughly settled among us years ago by Eld. Waggoner’s work on “The Resurrection of the Unjust,” that it would take a greater theological earthquake than has happened since the fall of Adam, to make any disturbance in our ranks on this question. The subject simply had its place in a series of topics upon which the REVIEW was treating, hence its appearance. Were not the Herald’s position so serious an error, we should be sorry thus to spoil its self-congratulations on this point. In the introduction of our previous article we casually described the “non-resurrection of the wicked” doctrine, as a “brainless delusion.” This seems to act upon the editor of the Herald something like peas in his shoes; for it is wonderful how he prances around over that expression. Now we hope Bro. Pile will not take that too much to heart. We did not mean that a person holding that doctrine did not have any brains at all. He might have in other directions very many and very excellent ones too. But on the particular point before us, the position we are reviewing still seems to us to indicate a conspicuous absence of that commodity. However, the article in the Herald has inspired us with a little hope for those involved in this error; for the writer seems to be striking about for some more substantial footing than the slough he finds himself in, and at times to come near grasping the principles which would lead him to shore. We will kindly throw him another rope this week, and if he will lay hold upon it, we will see if we cannot draw him out upon firm Scripture ground. The Herald accuses us of using too little Scripture, and too many assertions. Now we were not professing to give the scriptural argument at all, but were treating only of the philosophy of those dealings of God with the human family which underlie this whole question. We were dealing with those great principles which show the resurrection of all men to be an absolute necessity, and which we may be sure that no text of scripture contradicts. This is evidently a new field to the Herald, and it finds some difficulty in taking in the scope of the argument so as to see its bearing, and perceive its force. But a little more study from this standpoint will, we think, bring it to the light. It seems to be perplexed over the new probation upon which Adam and his posterity were placed through the arrangement of the plan of salvation by a coming Redeemer, and asks, “Did any new fear accompany” the new hope that was set before him? If we understand the Herald’s position, it is this. Adam was given a positive command; and a plain penalty was threatened in case of disobedience. This was the fear placed before him; and the Herald cannot conceive how he could be placed upon a new probation unless a new penalty or fear was announced; and hence it asks, “Did any new fear accompany it?” that is, this new hope. Well, Adam and his posterity were placed upon a new probation, were they not? Yes; we suppose every one admits that who admits anything. But what does probation mean? It means a state or condition in which we are on trial for something which is to be gained or lost. And what is meant by a new probation? It means that one probation was past and the prize was lost. That entailed death upon Adam and all his posterity. And this death without the plan of salvation would have been eternal. Let that fact be settled.
Now mark the conclusion. If any member of the human family, having died, simply remains dead continuously and forever, such person suffers only a fate which comes upon him through the transgression of Adam, and not through his own transgressions! His own sins are in nowise taken into the account. His personal responsibility is ignored. And whatever threats God had made against that person’s sins, he backs down from! (Charge the irreverence of the expression to the heinous theory which makes it necessary.) This is the inevitable conclusion. It cannot be dodged or set aside. If any person with brains denies this, he will simply knock out what brains he has left against this Gibraltar of impossibility.
Oh! but, you say, he would have been brought out from that death, if he had not been himself a sinner. That does not alter the conclusion one particle. That does not in the least affect the question. For the Adamic death was, and is, eternal, only so far as it is affected by the plan of salvation through Christ. And hence the indisputable and overwhelming fact remains, that the individual is under the death in Adam alone, and, aside from the redemptive work of Christ, can never get beyond the effects of that death to all eternity! Then, on this hypothesis, where do his own sins come into the account?—Nowhere! Where is that person’s accountability?—Ignored! When, in his case, is the “indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish,” which God declares shall come upon “every soul of man that doeth evil” (Rom. 2:8, 9)?—Nowhere! God foregoes his word! The man didn’t regard it, and he lets it pass! But God does not act that way; and that is why we said in a previous article that it was no more possible that the wicked should not be brought up to answer for their sins and receive the punishment due to the same, than it is possible for God to lie! We hope our friends of the Herald family will be able to grasp this great principle; for it virtually settles the question. It knocks the bottom completely out of the non-resurrection theory.
But to come back to the question of probation—what becomes of that person’s probation? He virtually had none, for it is, on this ground, entirely ignored. But we repeat, what we suppose the Herald acknowledges, that Adam, and so all his posterity, was placed upon a new probation. And we are on probation, not for Adam, but for ourselves. And this implies personal responsibility, God’s will as expressed in his law being the rule of life; and it implies also rewards for righteousness and punishment for disobedience. It cannot be otherwise. Men would omit none of these features from such an arrangement: how much less shall God? Just how much instruction was given to Adam in regard to the new plan of salvation, we have no record. But inasmuch as he was instructed in regard to sacrifices typifying a coming Saviour, he must have been told in regard to the nature and object of his mission, and what would be the doom of those who would not obey his gospel. 2 Thess. 1:8. We think there was no lack of instruction, law, penalty, hope and fear, in the new arrangement. From the foregoing it will be seen that the plan of salvation could not be devised and a new probation be offered to the world, without limiting or cutting off in every case the effects of that first transgression. As that entailed death, the only limitation that could be placed to it, was to bring every one back again to life. Such a purpose therefore underlies the whole plan. Hence Paul says, “As in Adam all die, so in Christ shall all be made alive.” 1 Cor. 15:22. How do we die in Adam? We die because he brought himself into a mortal, perishing condition, and entailed the same upon his posterity. We die without respect to our own characters; whether we are righteous or wicked, personally innocent or guilty, we die just the same. Now how are men made alive in Christ? On the same terms exactly. It is not with any respect to our own characters; nor whether we are righteous or wicked, innocent or guilty. How many? All. It is useless to try to limit this last half of the sentence to Christians, as the Herald does. It does not say, “As in Adam all die, so all who are in Christ shall be made alive,” but all shall be made alive in Christ—the same “all” who die in Adam, which is the whole race. We admit that there is a limitation in this chapter, but not till after this verse; for the apostle continues: “But every man in his own order: Christ the first-fruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming.” And having thus distinctly specified this class, he confines his testimony to them during the remainder of the chapter. But not so in verse 22.
We know it will be asked how a man who is a sinner can be “in Christ” and be made alive in him. We answer, Just as a man who is righteous can be “in Adam” and can die in him. The “in Christ” of this passage does not denote a Christian any more than the words “in Adam,” denote a sinner. But the expressions signify respectively two states in which we are unconditionally involved—first, all dying through the first Adam, without any reference to our own course of action; secondly, all receiving life from the second Adam, that all may appear before his Judgment seat (2 Cor. 5:10), that each man may have the privilege of giving account of himself to God (Rom. 14:12), and may receive, on his own account, according to his deeds. Rom. 2:6.
The Herald stumbles, in its second paper, over Rom. 5:12: “And so death passed upon all men for that all have sinned.” We take the ground that the death which removes us from this state of being does not come upon us because we are personally sinners. The Herald seems to take the ground that it does; for, speaking of the Sodomites, Egyptians, etc., it says, “They would have died because ‘all have sinned,’ not simply because Adam sinned.” And yet in its first paper (and this gave us hope) it came so near getting hold of the truth as to say: “Adam sinned not only as an individual, but as a representative—the federal head of the race. He and they are accounted one in the transgression. Hence Paul says, ‘By one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin, and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned,’ or ‘in whom’ all have sinned (margin). Rom. 5:12.”
True, every word of it. And if we mistake not, it was the REVIEW which gave the Herald this very point. In Adam we are to a certain degree counted sinners. How far?—So far as to come all alike under the dominion of death. So in Christ we are to a certain degree counted righteous. How far?—So far as to be made alive from the dead. Rom. 5:18, 19. We believe in this kind of universalism; for Paul taught it. But it avails the sinner nothing; for while Christ is so far the “Saviour of all men” (1 Tim. 4:10), he “specially” saves those that believe (last clause of verse) by giving them eternal life, while the wicked go down again in the second death.505 A few more points in the Herald’s article remain to be noticed; but lack of both time and space obliges us to defer their examination till another week.