The Sabbath and the First Day of the Week in Early Christianity
By R. F. Cottrell
THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 2.
Two eminent modern church historians, Mosheim of the eighteenth century and Neander of the nineteenth, directly contradict each other in respect to the standing of Sunday in the first century. Of this century Mosheim testifies as follows:— “All Christians were unanimous in setting apart the first day of the week, on which the triumphant Saviour arose from the dead, for the solemn celebration of public worship. This pious custom, which was derived from the example of the church of Jerusalem, was founded upon the express appointment of the apostles, who consecrated that day to the same sacred purpose, and was observed universally throughout the Christian churches, as appears from the united testimony of the most credible writers.” “The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance; and it was far from the intentions of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect; far from them, and from the early apostolic church, to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday. Perhaps at the end of the second century a false application of this kind had begun to take place; for men appear by that time to have considered laboring on Sunday as a sin.” Now all the writings that have come down to us from the first 140 years of the Christian era, which speak of the first day of the week, are the New Testament and the so-called epistle of Barnabas. This epistle speaks of first-day observance as follows:— “Lastly he saith unto them, Your new moons and your Sabbaths I cannot bear them. Consider what he means by it; the Sabbaths, says he, which ye now keep, are not acceptable unto me, but those which I have made; when resting from all things, I shall begin the eighth day, that is, the beginning of the other world; for which cause we observe the eighth day with gladness, in which Jesus arose from the dead, and having manifested himself to his disciples, ascended into heaven.” In regard to the authenticity of this epistle as coming from the Barnabas who was the companion of Paul in his labors, learned men are generally agreed that it is spurious. Testimonies to this effect might be quoted from Mosheim, Neander, Prof. Stuart, Dr. Killen, Prof. Hackett, Milner, Kitto, “Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge,” Eusebius, Sir Wm. Domville, and Coleman. From the last mentioned we give the following, which is in harmony with all the others:— “The epistle of Barnabas, bearing the honored name of the companion of Paul in his missionary labors, is evidently spurious. It abounds in fabulous narratives, mystic, allegorical interpretations of the Old Testament, and fanciful conceits, and is generally agreed by the learned to be of no authority.” We are authorized by all these testimonies to treat this epistle as a forgery. And yet this is the only writing, except the New Testament, purporting to come from the first century, in which the first day of the week is even alluded to; and Mosheim is one of the number of those who condemn it. Where, then, does he find the evidence that in the first century “all Christians were unanimous” in the observance of the first day of the week, and that this custom was derived from the example of the church at Jerusalem, and the “express appointment of the apostles?” Is not the testimony of Neander more in accordance with the evidence from history, or rather the want of any evidence of that kind, namely, that “the festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance”? The next writing in the order of time which is claimed as an evidence in favor of Sunday-keeping in the early church is the letter of Pliny, the Roman governor of Bithynia, to the emperor Trajan, written about A. D. 104. He says of the Christians of his province:— “They affirmed that the whole of their guilt or error was, that they met on a certain stated day, before it was light, and addressed themselves in a form of prayer to Christ, as to some god, binding themselves by a solemn oath, not for the purpose of any wicked design, but never to commit any fraud, theft, or adultery; never to falsify their word, nor deny a trust when they should be called upon to deliver it up; after which it was their custom to separate, and then re-assemble to eat in common a harmless meal.” This epistle proves nothing in favor of Sunday observance. Coleman candidly speaks of it as follows:— “This statement is evidence that these Christians kept a day as holy time, but whether it was the last or the first day of the week does not appear.” Tertullian, who wrote A. D. 200, evidently saw nothing in this epistle in favor of the observance of the first day of the week; for when speaking of this very epistle of Pliny he says:— “He found in their religious services nothing but meetings at early morning for singing hymns to Christ and God, and sealing home their way of life by a united pledge to be faithful in their religion, forbidding murder, adultery, dishonesty, and other crimes.” Mr. W. B. Taylor speaks of this stated day of Pliny as follows:— “As the Sabbath day appears to have been quite as commonly observed at this date as the sun’s day (if not even more so), it is just as probable that this ‘stated day’ referred to by Pliny was the seventh day, as that it was the first day; though the latter is generally taken for granted.” Yes; taking for granted the very point to be proved is the only means of defending a false position. Although Mosheim depends on this letter of Pliny as a chief evidence for Sunday observance, yet he was aware that learned men were of a different opinion. On this point he very frankly says:— “B. Just. Hen. Boehmer would indeed have us to understand this day to have been the same with the Jewish Sabbath.” On this letter of Pliny, Eld. J. N. Andrews sums up the evidence as follows:— “This testimony of Pliny was written a few years subsequent to the time of the apostles. It relates to a church which probably had been founded by the apostle Peter. It is certainly far more probable that this church, only forty years after the death of Peter, was keeping the fourth commandment, than that it was observing a day never enjoined by divine authority. It must be conceded that this testimony from Pliny proves nothing in support of Sunday observance; for it does not designate what day of the week was thus observed.” R. F. COTTRELL.