PENNSYLVANIA

20%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 29, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 31.

Read the full edition

PENNSYLVANIA

PENFIELD, JULY 21.—The Methodists secured the help of Dr. J. Litch and Eld. Osler from the East to attack us. These men are of what they call the Church of the Messiah. They came here to hold a meeting in a grove one mile from our tent. The Methodists asked them to come to their house and preach upon the two covenants, nature of man, destiny of the wicked, and the Sabbath. We requested the privilege to answer before the same congregation. They promised to grant it. Eld. Osler spoke first on the two covenants, taking the usual position that the ten commandments were the first covenant, etc. We followed, showing our position. After we were through, Eld. Osler spoke again, claiming, as usual, that Moses wrote the ten commandments on the last two tables of stone. We asked the privilege to answer this, but he refused to grant it. The next evening Dr. J. Litch spoke on the Sabbath, saying there is now no law for a Sabbath, abolishing all the commandments of the decalogue, and at the same time claiming that in the Greek the first day was always called Sabbath. We answered him, calling upon him to give good authority for his position upon the word “Sabbaton.” The people had heard he was going to prove the first day the Sabbath from the Greek, and they all expected to hear him reply. He spoke some time after we were through, but spent the time in trying to show that Moses wrote the second table of the law. We again asked the privilege to show the congregation the truth of that matter, but were not permitted to do so. Eld. Osler was to speak next evening on the state of the dead, and we were to follow. After the meeting closed, the Methodist minister informed us that we could not answer them in their house. This was all understood between them.
The result has been most satisfactory. We went on with our meetings in the tent, and they in the church across the street, our congregations being much larger than before, while theirs grew smaller. They held two meetings after they refused to let us answer. The people were indignant. Some of the leading members of the Methodist church followed us to the tent. Our interest is much better than it was before. We now have hopes that some will take a stand for the truth. They tried hard to prejudice people against us as a class. Eld. Osler told the congregation that if they knew what Eld. Litch said he did, they would weep. The spirit he manifested in all his talk betrayed his real motive. Most of the people could see his true character. We entered the controversy with some fears as to the effect it might have upon our interest, but can say we are truly thankful that they came. While they showed anger, we were by the help of God enabled to keep calm, not even contending for what was really our right. We feel that the Lord has been with us. Our courage is good.
F. PEABODY.
C. O. HOLDEN.