The Sabbath and the First Day in the First Centuries
By R. F. Cottrell
THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 3.
We have now passed over the first two centuries of the Christian era in search of testimony in favor of first-day observance; and what have we found? Simply one clear allusion to that day as the eighth day,—the day of the resurrection of Christ,—and this in the writings of an unknown person calling himself Barnabas, the name of an apostle, but whose writings are generally condemned by the learned as deserving no credit. Here is a tremendous gap, a chasm of two hundred years in breadth, in the way of those who would trace Sunday keeping up to the time of the apostles. What! a new Sabbath introduced, and the one that had come down from the creation of the world discarded by a new sect, and yet no controversy elicited by this strange movement for a period of two hundred years! Controversies did arise concerning the two days, before the first day was established by the authority of the Roman Church, as we shall see as we proceed; but how shall we account for this silence on the subject for the first two centuries of its observance? First-day writers have said that the change was made “gradually.” The grade must have grown much steeper, the degrees of the graduating scale must have greatly increased in succeeding centuries, or the council of Orleans, in A. D. 538, could not, by that time, have made a Sabbath of Sunday by forbidding agricultural labor on that day, a thing which had never before been done. It is true that the writers of the New Testament mentioned the first day of the week eight times during the first century, but they never designated it by any sacred title. At the same time they always distinguished the seventh day by its sacred title, the Sabbath. If we follow apostolic example we shall do the same; and we shall not load the Sabbath by any epithet, such as “old” or “Jewish,” to cast odium upon the sacred day, for the apostles did not do so. Paul foretold of a falling away which would result in the establishment of the man of sin, predicted by the prophet Daniel. Dan. 7: 25. He said to the elders of the church at Ephesus, “For I know this, that after my departing shall grievous wolves enter in among you, not sparing the flock. Also of your own selves shall men arise, speaking perverse things to draw away disciples after them.” He also declared that “the mystery of iniquity,”—the secret wickedness,—was already at work, which would eventually reveal “that wicked” power whom the Lord will consume with the spirit of his mouth, and destroy with the brightness of his coming. See 2 Thess. 2: 3–8. Compare with Dan. 7: 25, 26. Considering these revelations of what was coming in the future, the greatest wonder is that no more was done during the first two centuries toward advancing the first day into the place of the Sabbath of the Lord. But the epistle of Ignatius of Antioch to the Magnesians is quoted as a proof of Sunday observance. He is represented as saying:—537 “Wherefore if they who are brought up in these ancient laws came nevertheless to the newness of hope; no longer observing Sabbaths, but keeping the Lord’s day, in which also our life is sprung up by him, and through his death, whom yet some deny (by which mystery we have been brought to believe, and therefore wait that we may be found the disciples of Jesus Christ our only master): how shall we be able to live different from him; whose disciples the very prophets themselves being, did by the Spirit expect him as their master.” Many eminent writers who observe the first day admit these epistles of Ignatius to be spurious. A few of them are accepted by some as genuine; but that to the Magnesians, from which the above quotation is taken, is not included in the number of those claimed to be genuine. And this one would say nothing of the day, were it not fraudulently inserted by the translator. Of the epistles of Ignatius, Dr. Killen says:— “In the sixteenth century, fifteen letters were brought out from beneath the mantle of a hoary antiquity, and offered to the world as the productions of the pastor of Antioch. Scholars refused to receive them on the terms required, and forthwith eight of them were admitted to be forgeries. In the seventeenth century the seven remaining letters, in a somewhat altered form, again came forth from obscurity, and claimed to be the works of Ignatius. Again discerning critics refused to acknowledge their pretensions; but curiosity was roused by this second apparition, and many expressed an earnest desire to obtain a sight of the real epistles. Greece, Syria, Palestine, and Egypt, were ransacked in search of them, and at length three letters were found. The discovery creates general gratulation. It is confessed that four of the epistles so lately asserted to be genuine, are apocryphal; and it is boldly said that the three now forth-coming are above challenge. But truth still refuses to be compromised, and sternly disowns these claimants for her approbation. The internal evidence of these three epistles abundantly attests that like the last three books of the Sibyl, they are only the last shifts of a grave imposture.” Dr. Killen also states the opinion of Calvin thus: “It is no mean proof of the sagacity of the great Calvin, that, upwards of three hundred years ago, he passed a sweeping condemnation on these Ignatian epistles.” Prof. C. F. Hudson admits three of these epistles to be genuine, namely, those addressed to Polycarp, the Ephesians, and the Romans. But these do not include the one from which the testimony for the first day is taken; and they contain nothing relating to the first day. Those who would see a critical examination of the claims of these epistles, especially of the one which by interpolation is made to speak of the day, are referred to the “History of the Sabbath” by Eld. J. N. Andrews, pp. 238–242. This work is for sale at the Office of the REVIEW AND HERALD, Battle Creek, Michigan. In the chapter following the above reference, Eld. A. has ferreted out and exposed a famous falsehood, which asserted that in Pliny’s time and onward the Christian martyrs were examined by their persecutors with the question, “Have you kept the Lord’s day?” If they had, they were Christians. This, it was affirmed, was the most evident token and badge of their Christianity. This, Eld. A. has proved to be entirely false by the most explicit and reliable testimonies, in which it is shown how some men love a lie, and will deliberately repeat it, after it has been fully exposed. It is truly remarkable how in order to support an institution which has no foundation in the Scriptures, they have made lies their refuge, and under falsehood have hid themselves. See Isa. 28: 15–17. R. F. COTTRELL.