Not long ago, the Interior, of Chicago, received the following letter calling for light respecting the condition of the righteous after death and previous to the resurrection:—
“Dear Interior: Will you kindly, in ‘Piths and Points,’ give an earnest inquirer some thoughts upon the teaching of the Bible concerning the state of the righteous after death and previous to the resurrection and the Judgment day? Upon this the writer’s views are somewhat obscure, as are doubtless those of many another of your readers. “A. WARREN ROBINSON.”
It will be noticed that the letter calls for thoughts “upon the teaching of the Bible” concerning this question; and the reader will watch with interest to see what Bible instruction the learned editor of the Interior will produce. Below is given, with comments, every syllable of evidence which he professedly draws from the Bible. The answer starts out with the following sentence: “The souls of believers are at their death made perfectly holy, and do immediately pass into glory.” The writer does not name chapter and verse for this quotation; and as it sounds suspiciously like the Westminster Confession of faith, it is to be presumed that it was quoted merely as a concise statement of the Interior’s belief, for which it will presently give Scripture authority.
Accordingly we will pass on to the next sentence: “Enoch immediately passed into glory, as did Elijah and Moses—as the latter two re-appeared in their glorified estate.” But Enoch and Elijah were translated without seeing death, and consequently can never with propriety be quoted as proving anything respecting the condition of the righteous after death. And as for Moses, there is nothing improbable in the supposition that he had been raised from the dead, and was present on the occasion of the transfiguration to represent the righteous dead, who shall be raised immortal at the coming and kingdom of our Lord, as Elijah also fitly represented the righteous living, who at that time shall be gloriously translated. This view also explains that vexed passage in Jude, where Michael is represented as disputing with Satan about the body of Moses. See Whitby on Matt. 17:3 and Jude 9, also Dr. Clarke on the same passages. But however that may be, his case is clearly an exception, and cannot be relied upon to prove a general doctrine concerning the state of the righteous dead.
“The Saviour said that Abraham was living.” The Interior should have told its correspondent where the Saviour says this; for as the matter is now left, he will have hard work to find the statement. Probably reference is had, however, to the case of the rich man and Lazarus in the sixteenth chapter of Luke. Now this account is either a parable, or it is not. If it is, the language is figurative; and it is nothing unusual in such a case to represent inanimate objects as being alive and conversing. For examples, see Judges 9:7–15; Isa. 14:9–20, etc. If it is not, the language is literal; and heaven lies within speaking distance of hell, where the occupants of either place while away the hours by conversing across the separating gulf! Again, if the language be literal, the scene is located beyond the resurrection (that being the time when the saints are gathered by the angels, and the wicked see Abraham in the kingdom and themselves thrust out, Matt. 24:30, 31 and Luke 13:28), and hence proves nothing concerning the state of the dead before that time.
“The angel who appeared to John told him that he was his fellow-man.” In imagination I see the Interior’s correspondent searching for that text. But he will not find it; for the word “fellow-man” is not in the Bible, at least it is not to be found in Cruden’s complete concordance. In Rev. 19:10 and 22:9 occurs language very nearly like that referred to: “I am thy fellow-servant.” This must be the text; for it is spoken to John by the angel who appeared to him. But the question arises, Why does the Interior say “fellow-man”? Perhaps the revised version translates it thus. But no; it has “fellow-servant” like the authorized version. Possibly the original word would be better translated “fellow-man.” Not so, however; for three standard lexicons give “fellow-servant” as the chief, without giving “fellow-man” as a possible meaning; and the Greek concordance shows that in the New Testament the word is translated only by the former term. In some translation, then, “fellow-man” must be employed; but a search through about a dozen versions fails to bring to light anything but “fellow-servant.” What, then, can be the matter? I find myself thinking like this (I wish I could help it, but I cannot): If the angel said to John, “I am thy fellow-servant,” there is nothing in that to show that “the souls of believers are made perfectly holy, and do immediately pass into glory;” but if the angel said, “I am thy fellow-man,” it might be very plausibly inferred that that being, now an angel, was once a man like John, and therefore—come now, dear, good, candid, Presbyterian Interior, own up: what did you say “fellow-man” for?
“Paul says the souls of believers become ministering spirits.” It is not too strong language to employ with reference to this statement to say that it is a deliberate, bare-faced perversion of Heb. 1:13, 14. Lest some may think this language is unwarranted, I will quote the text mentioned; for this must be what the Interior had in mind, as it is the only place where Paul says anything about ministering spirits. Here is the passage: “But to which of the angels said he at any time, Sit on my right hand, until I make thine enemies thy footstool? Are they not all ministering spirits, sent forth to minister for them who shall be heirs of salvation?” Now, after reading the passage, is it not just to remark that “Paul does not say the souls of believers become ministering spirits?” He does not say anything about souls at all. He says the angels are ministering spirits. But angels are not men; much less are they the souls of dead men. Man was made a little lower than the angels (Ps. 8:4, 5); Christ took not on him the nature of angels, but the seed of Abraham (Heb. 2:16); and in the resurrection “believers” will be equal, only, to them (Luke 20:36), all of which texts show conclusively that angels are distinct from man, superior to him, and were created before him.
And this is all—absolutely all—the Bible proof the Interior offers in support of its proposition that at death the souls of believers immediately pass into glory; after being delivered of which its learned editor complacently remarks: “There is perfect uniformity in the teaching of the Scripture on this subject, both directly and by implication—so far as that teaching extends. There is no specific statement written for the purpose of describing the place and the state of the dead previous to their re-clothing in spiritual bodies. Like our correspondent, we often dream over this subject, in waking dreams, for there is no way of reaching certainty as to particulars. It seems to us in this way.” Here follows half a column of speculative philosophy about the material universe being the “lowest form of the manifestation of creative power,” above which is physical force, “that wondrous and beautiful and mighty thing,” still above which is spiritual force, “as far at least above physical force as that is above inert matter;” and far above all, the Divine Force, “the source of all below, as the sun is the source of all physical forces in the solar system;”—and so on until the mind is dazed, and the reader feels as though he had been listening to the ravings of a modern Spiritualistic medium inspired by some antediluvian ghost, or wandering in the mazes of Swedenborg’s Apocalypse Revealed; or he is reminded of the Concord philosophers, who are said to—
“Climb the slippery Which-bark tree To watch the Thusness roll, And pause betimes in gnostic rhymes To woo the Over-Soul.”
Why not take what Paul says, for example, in 1 Thess. 4:13–18, and let that settle the matter? There the brethren were sorrowing over the supposed fate of their friends who had died (having in some way imbibed the error that those who did not live to see Christ come were hopelessly perished), and Paul enters upon the task of correcting their error and comforting their hearts. Suppose, now, that Paul believed, with some of our modern preachers and editors, that “the souls of believers are at death made perfectly holy, and do immediately pass into glory;” can any one for a moment suppose that he would not immediately have said so? But on the contrary we find Paul pointing his brethren forward to the resurrection as their hope,—to the glorious time when the Lord should descend from heaven with a shout, and the dead in Christ should rise first, and be caught up with the righteous living to meet the Lord in the air, and so to be ever with him; and he exhorts them to comfort one another with these words.
In concluding this article, the writer feels like requesting some one of the readers of the Interior to furnish its religio-philosophical library with a good, old-fashioned Bible; and then, if possible, to get the editor to study it; and when he has become sufficiently familiar with its teachings to be responsible for what he says concerning it, to call his attention to that ancient document which says, Thou shalt not—indulge in “waking dreams.”
C. C. L.