AdventAI

“EXTREMELY DIFFICULT TO MEET.”

By F. Peabody

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 41., October 14, 1884

In the New York Christian Advocate of Sept. 18, 1884, is the following question and answer:—

“Question 1586. ‘I find no command in God’s word to keep the first day of the week holy, but a command to keep the seventh day holy. I know it is affirmed that we Christians keep the first day of the week as the Sabbath in commemoration of our risen Lord, but is that sufficient for man to change the day appointed for the Sabbath? Who changed the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day of the week? Is there a command in the Bible for us to keep the first day of the week holy? Some agree that it matters not which day we keep for the Sabbath, if we keep one day in seven. That is too hap-hazard to suit me. I desire to keep the day appointed by God. I am not an Adventist and never expect to be, but an earnest inquirer after truth as it is in Christ Jesus.’”

“Answer. That is a difficult question to despatch in a few words. For some time after the ascension of our Lord the Jewish Christians kept both days. Gradually the first was substituted for the seventh. The principles given by St. Paul justified the change. You will find he specially discusses the relation of the Christian to the Jewish dispensation with respect to various holy days and so on. The original command to keep one day holy has not been abrogated. The spirit of the new dispensation is not one of slavish adherence to the letter. The guidance of God through the Church, and the blessing that has followed the observance of the Lord’s day, must be taken as satisfactory evidence of divine approval; though argument in favor of keeping the seventh day, so far as the same is drawn from the letter of the Bible, is extremely difficult to meet.”

Anxious inquirer after truth can now see what is before him. He is told that a change has been made from the seventh to the first-day of the week, that that change was justified by Paul, and that he laid down principles to justify such a change. He is also informed that the original command is not abrogated. He will no doubt read that command carefully, as it is given in Ex. 20. He will not find the command changed, but always saying, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” If the original command still stands, and the Sabbath has been changed from the seventh day to the first, he will wonder if that original commandp. 650 does not enforce that same first day by the “slavish adherence to the letter”?.

He asked if the Bible commanded that we should keep the first day of the week holy, and is told that argument drawn from the letter of the Bible in favor of the seventh day Sabbath is extremely hard to meet. Well, we are glad this earnest inquirer has been told plainly what is before him. Others besides this one who gives the timely warning have found the same difficulties. This I honestly think is why so many contradictory positions are taken. They come to this Gibraltar of truth, and try to change or overthrow it; but they fail, as all must, and then flounder about for some straw to support them,—one upon this, one upon that; and in the last dying agonies they will say it is extremely difficult to meet! “So they wrap it up.” F. PEABODY