CAUTION, GENTLEMEN!

17%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 4, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 44.

Read the full edition

CAUTION, GENTLEMEN!

The uncertainties of theological speculation have often been held up to ridicule by the Positivists and scientists. Thus, for example, a distinguished modern apostle of science says quite euphoniously: “Extinguished theologians lie about the cradle of every science as the strangled snakes beside that of Hercules; and history records that whenever science and orthodoxy have been fairly opposed, the latter has been forced to retire from the lists, bleeding and crushed, if not annihilated; scotched, if not slain.” Without attempting to comment upon the exquisite taste of this comparison, or to assert that theologians are never “extinguished,” we may retort, if it be in order, that sometimes scientists get “extinguished” also by facts which show that their conclusions drawn with such absolute assurance are, after all, rather doubtful. An amusing as well as instructive instance of this kind occurred the other day in the Scientific Association held in Philadelphia. Professor Hall is the State Geologist of New York, and one of the greatest living authorities on fossils. Upon hearing Professor Williams declare, in a lecture, that the spirifer disjuncta and spirifer mesostralis, two kinds of fossils, existed side by side in the same rocks, Professor Hall replied: “If any one will show me the two spirifers side by side in the same rock, I will sacrifice my life’s work. I will give up my reputation, eat my hat, and make the person who shows me the rock a present of my coat and boots.” Professor Williams took the first train to Ithaca, and, returning the next day, came to the meeting, and solemnly dumped a big box of rocks on the floor. It was consigned to Professor Hall in the following words: “The enclosed rock contains the spirifer disjuncta and spirifer mesostralis side by side. You have it. Please eat your hat, and send me your coat and boots by express.”
All this was exceedingly funny—it is more than funny; it points to a moral, viz., that the advocate of science is quite as apt to be overconfident as the theologian, and that it is the part of wise caution oftentimes to refuse to accept hastily new conclusions, or, at least, to hold the judgment in suspense until knowledge has had time to ripen into substantial fruits. Another instance illustrating the advisability of such caution, was afforded in the sweeping statement of Professor Huxley, made in one of his lectures, to the effect that the theory of evolution was now as well substantiated as the Copernican theory, which established the sun in the center of the planetary system. Here the conviction was absolute, and it was stated in a form to render assurance doubly sure. And yet, so far is evolution from being on a par, in regard to certainty, with the revolution of the earth around the sun, that while no man in his senses can examine the proofs of the latter and doubt them, yet many of the finest minds in the world, and these, too, of the highest authority in science, have investigated the arguments in favor of the former, and have rejected them as groundless. Among these foremost scientists who either positively antagonize evolution, or hold it as unproven and uncertain, are Professor Virchow of Berlin, Tyndall, Agassiz, Dr. Elam, Principal Dawson, Mivart, Professor J. L. Smith, Barrande, Alfred Russel Wallace, De Quatrefages, Dana, Sir William Thomson, Carruthers, Clerk Maxwell, and a host of others, to say nothing of metaphysicians and theologians.
In regard to scientific facts, it is well always to hold the mind in a receptive, open, and welcoming attitude, but it is equally well to be on guard against a too ready adoption of the inferences and theories alleged to flow from these facts. Here, not less than in matters of dress and custom, Pope’s finely balanced couplet offers a safe guide:—
“Be not the first by whom the new is tried, Nor yet the last to cast the old aside.”
Not long since it was proclaimed with oracular voice, by a noted scientist, that the wonderful discovery had been made of a continuous sheet of gelatinous substance called “Bathybius” enveloping the globe, and in which had been found the origin of life—the germs of all living forms and things. It now turns out, however, that this so-called discovery was an ignis fatuus, an altogether false and delusive light of science, for no such continuous sheet of life exists, and the origin of things is left involved in a mystery as far off as ever. The discoverer himself has lived long enough to recognize and recant his error; but since he was just as sure in regard to Bathybius as he now is about some other theories which metaphysicians and theologians consider rather nebulous, it would seem to be the part of wisdom to think twice and earnestly before forsaking the old truths of revelation for the new inferences of so-called science radically opposed to them. This not to resist by any means real and well established scientific facts and their rational explanation.—Christian at Work.