The Sabbath and the First Day in the Early Centuries

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 23, 1884

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 39.

Read the full edition

The Sabbath and the First Day in the Early Centuries

THE SABBATH AND THE FIRST DAY OF THE WEEK IN THE FIRST CENTURIES OF THE CHRISTIAN ERA.—NO. 7.

No greater fraud was ever practiced upon mankind than that which has led thousands of honest souls to believe that the Sabbath has been changed to the first day of the week by divine appointment, and that resting from labor on the stirring day of our Lord’s resurrection is obedience to the fourth commandment of the decalogue. The Judgment alone will determine how many of those who have had the means and capability to know the truth on this subject, if they would, and yet have perverted their God-given powers and given their influence and efforts to perpetuate the deception, have become accessories to the fraud after it was perpetrated, and as a consequence have lost eternal life.
All the evidence from history concerning the observance of the first day in the early church shows that it was observed only as a voluntary festival, in no way tending to rival the Sabbath, or to be a day of rest from common labor; and that about the close of the second century some began to dignify it with the title of Lord’s day, not, however, claiming any divine authority for this, nor connecting it in any way with the Lord’s day of Rev. 1: 10, which doubtless was the day which the Lord had claimed as his from the beginning. In the fore part of the fourth century, paganism put forth its ancient day set apart to the worship of the sun, giving it a Sabbatical character by commanding rest on that day in cities, but expressly permitting those engaged in agriculture and horticulture freely to labor on that day. At this time a bishop of Rome, by apostolical authority, gave it the name of Lord’s day, a name which some had before been wont to give it. Still it was no Sabbath to the people in the country till the council of Orleans recommended abstinence from agricultural labor on the day, A. D. 538. A merely voluntary festival, apparently innocent at first, placed by the side of a divine institution as old as the world, gradually increases in honor till it roots out the ordinance of Heaven and usurps its place. This was the result of the influx of paganism. As Gibbon expresses it, “Those who had laid the foundations of the church found themselves overwhelmed by the increasing multitudes, that from all the various religions of polytheism enlisted under the banner of Christ.”
But the truth was not crushed out of the earth. There was no age in which witnesses to the Sabbath of the Lord did not exist, though sometimes driven into dens and caves of the earth by the cruel hand of persecution. The apostles and primitive church observed the seventh day, and it was quite generally kept by the eastern churches. In A. D. 364 the council of Laodicea forbade it, pronouncing a curse upon those who should continue to keep it,—a curse upon those who should keep the commandment of God. Prynne says:—
“It is certain that Christ himself, his apostles, and the primitive Christians for some good space of time, did constantly observe the seventh-day Sabbath; . . . the evangelists and St. Luke in the Acts styling it the Sabbath day, . . . and making mention of its . . . solemnization by the apostles and other Christians, it being still solemnized by many Christians after the apostles’ times, even till the council of Laodicea [A. D. 364], as ecclesiastical writers and the twenty-ninth canon of that council testify, which runs thus: ‘Because Christians ought not to Judaize, and to rest in the Sabbath, but to work in that day (which many did refuse at that time to do). But preferring in honor the Lord’s day (there being then a great controversy among Christians which of these two days . . . should have precedency), if they desired to rest they should do this as Christians. Wherefore if they shall be found to Judaize, let them be accursed from Christ.’ . . . The seventh-day Sabbath was . . . solemnized by Christ, the apostles, and the primitive Christians, till the Laodicean council did in a manner quite abolish the observation of it. . . . The council of Laodicea [A. D. 364] . . . first settled the observation of the Lord’s day, and prohibited . . . the keeping of the Jewish Sabbath under an anathema.”
Observe, this council said that Christians ought not “to rest in the Sabbath.” Did they not know that Sunday had been the Sabbath for more than three hundred years? No other day than the seventh had ever been called the Sabbath at that time. The decree of this council tended to depress the Sabbath and to elevate the Sunday; but it did not wholly extinguish Sabbath-keeping. John Ley, an English writer, says:—
“From the apostles’ time until the council of Laodicea, which was about the year 364, the holy observation of the Jews’ Sabbath continued, as may be proved out of many authors; yea, notwithstanding the decree of that council against it.”
After the decree of Constantine, and the effort of Sylvester to exalt the first day at the expense of the Lord’s Sabbath, there was yet a revival of Sabbath observance, the Sabbath gaining ground in the churches, as the following testimonies will show. Of the period between Constantine and the council of Laodicea, A. D. 364, Prof. Stuart says:—
“The practice of it [the keeping of the Sabbath] was continued by Christians who were jealous for the honor of the Mosaic law, and finally became, as we have seen, predominant throughout Christendom. It was supposed at length that the fourth commandment did require the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath (not merely a seventh part of time), and reasoning as Christians of the present day are wont to do; viz., that all which belonged to the ten commandments was immutable and perpetual, the churches in general came gradually to regard the seventh-day Sabbath as altogether sacred.”
Mr. James, addressing the University of Oxford, says:—
“When the practice of keeping Saturday Sabbaths, which had become so general at the close of this century, was evidently gaining ground in the eastern church, a decree was passed in the council held at Laodicea [A. D. 364] ‘that members of the church should not rest from work on the Sabbath like Jews, but should labor on that day, and preferring in honor the Lord’s day; then if it be in their power, should rest from work as Christians.’”
Testimonies might be multiplied corroborating those already quoted as to the way that Sunday, by a protracted struggle, supplanted the Sabbath of the Bible. The origin of the Sabbath and the festival of Sunday is truthfully expressed by Eld. J. N. Andrews as follows: “When God made the world, he gave to man the Sabbath that he might not forget the Creator of all things. ‘When men apostatized from God, Satan turned them to the worship of the sun, and, as a standing memorial of their veneration for that luminary, caused them to dedicate to his honor the first day of the week. When the elements of apostasy had sufficiently matured in the Christian church, this ancient festival stood forth as a rival to the Sabbath of the Lord.” The way in which it succeeded in gaining the precedence has been sufficiently shown.
As corroborating the testimonies given, and as a fitting close of this series of articles, the present claim of the Roman Catholic church is presented, taken from the Doctrinal Catechism:—
“Ques. Have you any other way of proving that the church has power to institute festivals of precept?
“Ans. Had she not such power, she could not have done that in which all modern religionists agree with her;—she could not have substituted the observance of Sunday, the first day of the week, for the observance of Saturday, the seventh day, a change for which there is no Scriptural authority.” R. F. COTTRELL.