AdventAI

SO FAR, SO GOOD.

By D. E. M.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 61, No. 36., September 2, 1884

In looking over my notes, fresh from President Hitchcock’s lecture this morning, I am so much interested in them that I can hardly withhold them from the readers of the Recorder,—readers I have met in the columns of that excellent paper so often, and through so many years, that they seem like a kind of family circle to me. The President is at work in the Ante-Nicene period of church history, a period reaching from the beginning to early in the fourth century, more exactly to the council of Nice in A. D. 325, about the same period Neander goes over in his “History of the Church During the First Three Centuries.”

The first somewhat remarkable thing about the lecture is, to find a man with so much learning, and with fairness and candor so nearly matching it that he never evades or garbles facts to save cherished theories. This morning his chapter was upon the observance of weekly days during the first three hundred and twenty-five years of the church, and of course the Sabbath was prominent in the lecture. He made emphatic the following facts of history: The Lord’s-day was prominent during the period. [Not quite true.] The name of the day as used among the Christians themselves, was sometimes first-day, sometimes Lord’s-day, but when they conversed with the heathen, they called it Dies Solis, day of the sun. All through the period it was observed as a festival, to celebrate the resurrection. This Dies Solis, as a heathen festival, had its origin in Egypt. Nobody during the whole period [325 years] ever called this festival day Sabbath; it was always a festival and only that. At the same time, beginning with the apostolic church, and entirely through the period, the Saturday was the undisputed Sabbath-day. The Lord’s day was first called Sabbath by Eusebius about 340 A. D., in his commentary on the 92d Psalm, but all through the period, the seventh day was called Sabbath, and observed as Sabbath. There had been no breaks in this Sabbath from the apostolic practice of it till after the Ante-Nicene period. It was an apostolic inheritance.

In this view, our able lecturer fully agrees with his teacher, Dr. Neander, who says in his history to which allusion has just been made, page 186, “The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intention of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect; far from them and the early apostolic church to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday.” Upon this point our able historian of the church is clearly within the trend of the whole historic verdict. Upon being asked upon what authority the Ante-Nicene church based the observance of the Lord’s-day festival, he answered, “They never discussed that question.” In the light of this history, how utterly without bottom is the claim of apostolic authority for the observance of the first-day Sabbath. Dr. Hitchcock has given the unvarnished facts of history, and it all comes to this. Till some ways into the fourth century, near the middle, 340 A. D., the first day of the week was never called or esteemed by the Christian church to be the Sabbath, but uniformly and without exception, the seventh day was so called and esteemed as an apostolic inheritance, Eusebius, in 340, for the first time calling it Sabbath. Put with this the other fact, that when the Sunday began to be regarded Sabbatically, it was only in thep. 565 Western or Latin half of the church that this idea ever took root; and, as all historians know, that half of the church was the most corrupt, and the one which at that very period was fast degenerating into the Roman hierarchy. To this day the Oriental, or Greek half of the church, have never drifted from the Sabbath to Sunday, but still observe the seventh day. To this our learned and excellent Dr. Schaff bears witness in “History of the Christian Church,” p. 372. Up to 340 there was not so much as a theory, much less a practice, of Sunday observance, and therefore, as Dr. Hitchcock truly says, it was never discussed.

There is some significance in the date 340 A. D., at which the Sunday was first called Sabbath. It will be remembered that already, nearly twenty years before, Constantine had legislated the venerabilis dies solis into semi-respectability, as a kind of subterfuge for currying favor with both his pagan and Christian subjects. Of this act Dr. Hitchcock says, “It was a stroke of consummate policy,” and so it was. But what shall we say of that state of the church as it was passing into its post-Nicene period, in which the political cunning of a pagan emperor could lay for it the foundation of lapse from so glorious a boon, so rich an “apostolic inheritance” as was the Sabbath of the Bible, the Sabbath of the Lord, and his apostles! To the critical student of the Roman character, and system of government growing out of that character, it is sufficient to say that they were Romans. The Greek church did not get aboard the gilded galley of the splendid apostasy. It was not in the natural tendency of the Greco-Oriental church to float off into apostasy under lead of the Latino-Occident. Soon after the Sunday got into the records of Eusebius as Sabbath, nineteen years after Constantine’s edict, a large council of bishops at Laodicea took up the line of ecclesiastical legislation, and by decrees, about 360 A. D., enjoined work on Saturday, “after divine service,” and abstinence from work on Sunday, “if they could;” and, says Dr. Hitchcock, “This kind of legislation formulates Sunday observance, for the sake of breaking down the sanctity of the Sabbath.” How little occasion have the observers of the popular day for pride in its popularity, when their most learned historian, at the head of one of their most popular seats of theological training, thus exposes the utterly unwarranted, not to say disgraceful, roots out of which its popularity has grown!

On being asked, if he thought it proper now to speak of Sunday as Sabbath, the Doctor with a smile said, “Call it the Christian Sabbath,” and then as if fearing his answer would be misleading, went on to give caution as to such a designation to Sunday observance; and he made this, to me, unexpected statement: “Do not call Sunday Christian Sabbath until you are sure you can go clear back to Eden and find its foundation in the original Sabbatic institution.” This statement he emphasized by repetition. He had just said of the Sabbath, “It was instituted to commemorate the rest of God after his finished creation.” And now he sets up the cruel task to base the keeping of the first day of the week upon the commemoration of God’s rest on the seventh day, after a finished creation. I almost thought I saw a strain of sharp irony running over the President’s face, as he set us this task, and forbade us to call Sunday the “Christian Sabbath,” till we could do it. Work enough for a post graduate course of indefinite extent. “Christian Sabbath” is one pet name for Sunday, and to be forbidden to use it, except upon terms verging so hard upon the impossible! Alas, where shall we coming Presbyterian ministers flee when Dr. Schaff demolishes our decrees, and our Pedo-baptism, and our honored President follows with such a blow upon our “Christian Sabbath”? O Princeton, shelter us; shades of Hodge and Edwards, ora pro nobis.—D. E. M., in Sabbath Recorder.