What S. D. Adventist minister has not had occasion to correct false notions among the people concerning conscience? “My conscience does not condemn me for working on Saturday,” say they; or, “My conscience wouldn’t let me work on Sunday,” etc. Now the fact is that people often do wrong conscientiously, which fact, while it may lessen the individual’s guilt, does by no means, therefore, make wrong right. God’s law is the standard of right; and whosoever transgresses that law commits sin, whether his conscience condemns him therefor or not. If it does not condemn him, it ought to; for the word of God most certainly does, and his conscience ought to condemn what the word does. It is seldom we find the truth upon this subject stated more clearly and forcibly than in the following article from the S. S. Times of Aug. 23. May its reading send conviction to some hearts of the importance of having the conscience enlightened by the word of the Lord and also fully in harmony with it:—
“There is no human attribute or faculty which is more commonly misunderstood, and none certainly which is more wretchedly misused than conscience. Some references to the untrustworthiness of conscience, made by Dr. George Dana Boardman in his recent article on ‘Secret Faults,’ has disturbed, or confused, quite a number of our readers, and they are turning to us for help in their perplexity. A specimen of the letters we are receiving on this subject is the following, from Iowa:—
“I have just finished reading the article on ‘Secret Faults,’ and I wonder have my ideas on conscience been all wrong! I have fancied that conscience, unbiased by habit, education, and influence, was infallible, because ‘God-given’ for that purpose. Dr. Boardman says conscience has shared in the disaster of the fall; that conscience, if followed even against our judgment, our wishes, and our will, ‘will lead us into all truth;’ that, if we ‘sin in conscience,’ yet it is not conscience which sins, but other of our depraved faculties which hinder us from hearing conscience aright, or from seeing ‘the more perfect way;’ that even Paul acted impulsively on a ‘blind belief,’ rather than because he had patiently sought to know the truth. True, we have the word, and should study whether a desire is in accordance with its teachings. We use our judgment, but shall not the Spirit, speaking through our conscience, be the only true judge? or may we hear the Spirit outside of conscience? And are they two separate powers, one of God and the other of man? for he saith, ‘I will put my Spirit within you.’ If you think it of sufficient interest to take up your time, I would like to see another word on this subject.”
“Conscience is not a faculty given to us by God to enable us to know what is right and wrong. Conscience is not a teacher of God’s law. Conscience, whether pure or impure, is not in itself a sure and safe instructor as to the path of duty. God has not implanted in every man’s mind, by nature, a knowledge of God and a knowledge of God’s law. Such knowledge comes by revelation, not by conscience. God has revealed himself and his law in his word. Those who have the light of the Bible are to look to that for a knowledge of what is right and what is wrong. Moreover, there is not a man on the face of the whole earth who has not before him by tradition, if not in written word, some vestige of God’s revelation to his ancestors. What we call ‘conscience’ is a monitor, rather than a teacher; it is that faculty or attribute of man which tells him that he ought to do right, although it does not tell him what right is; and again it reminds him that he has done wrong, when he purposely has done that which he supposed was wrong, or has failed to do that which he understood to be his duty. Hence it is true, that, when a man acts against his conscience he is at fault, because so far as he knows he does wrong, and his intention has been to do wrong. But, on the other hand, if a man does what his conscience approves, it does not follow that he is doing right. Many a man is serving the devil conscientiously. ‘To the law and to the testimony.’ There is the standard of right. Your duty is to do right as God commands the right; not merely as your conscience approves or dictates. It is your duty, first to know what is right, and then to do what is right. You may think you are all right, while yet you are all wrong. You may be walking by the light which is within you. ‘Take heed, . . . that the light which is in thee be not darkness.’ ‘If . . . the light that is in thee be darkness, how great is that darkness.’ It is true that the Holy Spirit is promised to dwell in the believer’s heart; but the Holy Spirit is to take of the things of Christ as they are disclosed in the revelation of Christ, and to make them clear unto the disciple. He in whom the Holy Spirit dwells seeks the Spirit’s guidance in the study of the word of God, which was written by those whom the Holy Spirit inspired to its writing. The Bible, not the conscience, is the repository of God’s truth. Beware lest you be wrong conscientiously.” C. C. L.