Having apparently determined that they will not yield to the testimony of Scripture nor the claims of reason, in behalf of the Sabbath of the Bible, the opponents of this sacred institution nervously grasp about in all directions, as drowning men catch at straws, for any pretext, however flimsy, to support them in their rejection of the holy day.
In the whole range of absurdities to which they despairingly appeal, there is scarcely one which is weaker than the plea set up over an abolished penalty. The argument runs thus: “Under the Mosaic dispensation the violation of the Sabbath was punished with death. But under this dispensation that penalty is not inflicted. Therefore the law to observe the seventh day as the Sabbath, to which that penalty was attached, has been done away; for the penalty being abolished, the law is abolished also.”
The aim and object of this reasoning is simply to show that the law for the observance of the seventh day has been taken out of the way, and that we are under no obligation whatever now to regard that day. This indictment against the seventh day is easily quashed by reference to the fact that other laws which all right-minded persons admit to be still binding, had the same death penalty attached to their violation under the former dispensation; which penalty has been done away. For the first commandment of the decalogue, see Deut. 13:6-11; for the third, Lev. 24:16; for the sixth, verse 17; for the seventh, Lev. 20:10; for all, Num. 15:30, 31. In none of these instances is the penalty of death now inflicted at the hand of the minister of the Lord as it was then. That penalty has been done away, but yet the laws remain. Now if our opponents will do themselves the honor to manifest a little consistency, they must admit that according to their own reasoning we are under no obligation to refrain from idolatry, blasphemy, murder, adultery, or any of the ten commandments, because the penalty of death, as formerly inflicted, has been done away; which abolition of the penalty, they say, takes the law with it. If their argument is good on the Sabbath commandment, it is good also on all the others. But no sensible man will admit such a conclusion.
But now comes an attempt to parry the damaging force of these facts, as wicked as it is barefaced and foolish. Mr. I. I. Leslie, in the World’s Crisis of March 17, 1886, charges us with holding the position that there is now no penalty to any of these laws, though all are in force and required to be kept. There is not the least excuse for such a perversion. Our position leads to no such conclusion. It is only an attempt to divert attention from defeat by raising a false issue. To say that a penalty inflicted under the Mosaic dispensation is now done away, is not saying that laws to which such penalty was once attached have now no penalty, and never would be so interpreted except for some base purpose. Having stated the charge, he spends the strength of his article in ridiculing the idea of a law without a penalty. The careful reader will perceive that in all this he does not help his position at all, that the Sabbath is abolished because the penalty has been done away, but yet that other laws are binding, penalty for the violation of which has been done away to the same extent.
Who does not understand that it was to these commandments as incorporated into the civil code of the Jews that the penalty, to be inflicted at the hand of the human magistrate, was attached; and that the doing away of this arrangement in no wise affected men’s relation to that law as an embodiment of the duties which they, in the position of morally accountable creatures, independently of any national considerations, owed to God, and every violation of which he will visit with a just recompense of reward?
This penalty still attaches to the violation of the ten commandments, as the moral law of God. “Sin is the transgression of the law” (1 John 3:4); and “the wages of sin is death.” Rom. 6:23. The Sabbath law, and every other moral precept, has its penalty—not a penalty to be inflicted here by men, but one which God himself will inflict hereafter, when all men shall be judged by the “law of liberty” (James 2:11, 12), when all our actions, both open and private, shall be brought to the test of God’s commandments (Eccl. 12:13, 14), and every evil thing which has intruded itself into the universe as an offense and an insult to God the maker of all, shall perish from his presence forever, in the lake of fire.