AdventAI

A FALSE ATTACK.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 26., June 29, 1886

In the report of the Des Moines (Iowa) camp-meeting last week allusion was made to the fact that the plain presentation of some of the Sabbath and Sunday arguments caused no little stir among those of the congregation who were of an opposite faith. Still further evidence of this is found in the Christian Oracle of June 17, 1886, a Disciple paper published in Des Moines. In an article headed “A False Attack,” the editor gives his readers his estimate of “one Uriah Smith” in the following language:—

He is “one of the most unfair men in the presentation of his subjects we have ever heard. He never states the position of those who disagree with him correctly, and perverts and distorts it in every way. In a sermon on the First Day, he stated the position of all those who observe it as believing that the day had been changed from a seventh to a first day Sabbath. If he is properly informed, he knows that the Disciples do not call nor do not recognize [negatives all his] the first day as a Sabbath. . . . We do not say he is dishonest, but he can misrepresent an opponent with a better grace than any man we ever heard, unless it be D. B. Ray, of the Baptist church. He cannot [can?] pervert the position of his opponents, but the Apostles he treats worse than all. . . . As a man who can make an attack on something that no one believes, he is a success.”

All of which is exceedingly bad, if it is true. But it strikes us as a little singular, if our attack was confined to what “no one believes,” that there should be such commotion over it in any quarter. People do not generally pay much attention to that kind of matter. We more than suspect that some things said came so near at least to what the Disciples believe that they could not refrain from wincing a little.

It would be gratifying to know in just what particulars the views we oppose were “perverted and distorted in every way,” so that a like error might be avoided in future. In this instance, however, it is quite easy to take in the situation. S. D. Adventists have trained their guns on the Sunday question so as to sweep the whole horizon; and the mistake our Disciple friends evidently make is in supposing that they fill the whole space, so that whatever is said is aimed at them; whereas there are other people in the world besides themselves and other views besides theirs that we have to meet. Of course, while we are reviewing some other position they might call it a perversion as applied to themselves. But they should be a little more modest in regard to the space which they occupy in this controversy. And we suppose even they will not deny that the view most largely taken in Christendom is, or at least has been, that Sunday has taken the place of the seventh day as the Sabbath, the change being made by Christ and his apostles. This view therefore demands proportionate consideration.

That the reader may understand this case more fully, and be able to judge for himself what chance there was for perversion and distortion, we will state that the subject of the discourse above referred to was an examination of the eight texts which speak of the first day of the week in the New Testament. Now we had always supposed that those who devote the first day of the week to religious uses, whether as a substitute for the seventh-day Sabbath, or as an independent institution, did so because of some supposed instructions to that effect in the New Testament; and our object was to show that if such instructions exist, they must be found in those texts which speak of the first day, but that those texts contain not a syllable of any such evidence. They record no facts necessary to form the basis of a Sabbatic institution; they attach no blessing to the day; they involve no reason why it should be set apart to rest or worship; they give no law nor directions for such a practice; they give no example of such rest upon that day; they contain no record of any day meeting ever held on that day; but some of them do show, by the example of the apostles which they record, and the acts they requested to be done on that day, that those chosen of God to give us the Scriptures of the New Testament, regarded the first day of the week as wholly secular time, and devoted it to secular uses.

The heaviest blow against the first-day institution, and one which is doubtless the greatest surprise to its advocates, is Acts 20: 7–14. On this we dwelt at some length, showing that the meeting was an evening meeting (verse 8); that if the Bible reckoning of time was followed, it occurred at a time corresponding to Saturday night as the days are now reckoned; but if Roman reckoning was followed, then the meeting was on Sunday evening. We have only these two positions to choose between; but take which we will, the occasion shows that the disciples regarded the day as secular time; for, if the meeting was on Saturday evening, Paul preached till break of day Sunday morning, and then started off on his long foot journey of nineteen and a half miles to Assos (verses 11, 13); and if it was on Sunday evening, then the breaking of bread, being after midnight (verses 7, 11), was on the second day of the week and not on the first, transferring all its hallowing influence to that day; but even in this latter case, the companions of Paul, among whom were Luke, the writer of the Acts, and the noted Timothy (verse 4), were off upon their journey, taking the ship around the promontory from Troas to Assos. Verse 13. So take it whichever way we may, either Paul or his companions (whose example in this case is just as good as his) went off freely on secular business on the first day of the week.

It is doubtless on this part of the subject that the Oracle charges us with “treating the Apostles worse than all.” And for aught we know, it may have been a Disciple who felt called upon to exclaim in the congregation, “That’s a lie,” as some of these facts were being brought out on the camp ground. Now all this may be looked upon as “misrepresentation, perversion, and distortion;” nevertheless we invite to our position and its defense the most searching criticism and the most rigid and logical tests.p. 409

The Disciples declare in the foregoing extract that they “do not call nor recognize the first day as a Sabbath.” This raises a query in regard to the position they really do assign to that day; for they do call it “the Lord’s day.” The paper we have before us, speaking of the “Commencement Week” at their university in Des Moines, says: “The services at the Central Christian church in this city were of special interest last Lord’s day, the matters of special interest being the Baccalaureate sermon of Prof. D. R. Dungan,” etc.; and a hasty glance over notes from the field in other parts of the paper, reveals to us six other instances where the term “Lord’s day” is applied to the first day of the week. Now how is this?—The “Lord’s day,” yet not a Sabbath; the “Lord’s day,” yet not a sacred day; the “Lord’s day,” a day belonging to the Lord, and yet a day which we may use as we will. An anatomical analysis of this mongrel which the Disciples have attached to their creed, would be an interesting study. Perhaps we shall learn more of him in the forth-coming discussion between Eld. Canright and Prof. Dungan.