THEORY AGAIN

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 4, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 18.

Read the full edition

THEORY AGAIN.

BY E. E. MARVIN.
WELL-APPOINTED theory has led to the development and completion of noble and stupendous undertakings. The theory that “all men were created equal, and endowed with certain inalienable rights,”—being reduced to a recognized legal principle, became the chief pillar for the support of the government of this mighty nation, insuring to its teeming millions of subjects that most precious blessing,—civil and religious liberty. Theories whose principles of justice are so “self evident” as the above, will do to be reduced to practice; and the sooner and better it is lived up to, the less liable will we be to violate the golden rule. Notice how widely the papal-Roman theory differs from the above: “It is permitted neither to think nor teach otherwise than the court of Rome directs.”—Pope Marcellus. The closer this theory was lived up to, the more of the precious blood of saints flowed, the more groans and heart-broken cries rose to heaven.
A good theory in theology is a Bible theory; and the more literally it is reduced to practice, the more and better are the fruits to be seen. But a theory, even in theology, that it would be dangerous to carry into practice, is self-evidently unscriptural. To illustrate: James says, “Whoso looketh into the perfect law of liberty, and continueth therein, he being not a forgetful hearer, but a doer of the work, this man shall be blessed in his deed.” Chap. 1: 25. Now if the theory that “the law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul” (Ps. 19: 7), and that all the commandments stand fast forever and ever (Ps. 111: 7, 8), that Jesus came not to destroy one jot or tittle of them (Matt. 5: 17, 18), and that by walking in all the commandments of God we may be blameless (Luke 1: 6) and in keeping them we shall have a great reward, even eternal life (Matt. 19: 17; Rev. 22: 14), could be carried into practice, how quickly would “blamelessness” attach itself to every one, and a great wave of peace mingled with beams of God’s glory and songs of angelic approbation be wafted over this great ocean of obedient humanity!
Would it do to reduce such a theory as the above to practice? I can imagine that I can almost hear even the Antinomian’s hearty and responsive “Amen.”
But now let us look into the “law of liberty,” from the stand-point of the no-law theory. With Antinomian spectacles on, we see it a law of liberty in the sense that we are freed from obligation to obey its several precepts. We see that “Christ was the end of the law,” that he “nailed it to the cross, and took it out of the way.” Viewing it from the stand-point of the no-law theory, we see that if we keep the law, we are fallen from grace; therefore disobedience to each precept is the duty of him who looks into the law of liberty. To be a “doer of the work,” would be to do, according to this theory, just what the law of liberty had forbidden to be done. Now reduce your theory to practice, and be a “doer of the work” which freedom from the law gives you abundant license to be. Go forth and kill, swear, steal, commit adultery, bear false witness, worship Baal, and commit all the abominations covered by the restrictions of “the law of liberty,” and then occupy your place in the house which is called by the name of God, and say, “We are delivered to do all these abominations.” Jer. 7: 8-10.
But, says the no-law theorist, you know we don’t believe in all this wickedness. But why? Where no law is, no transgression can exist. See Rom. 4: 15. There is no neutral position to be occupied by the law of liberty. One of two things is sure: either the law is binding, or it is not binding; either it is right to keep it, or it is wrong to keep it. But, says one, the theory is all right if you will let it alone, and not give it such an offensively literal exposition; it’s the practice that puts this venerable theory into such an awkward light. Just so a bad egg will fill the recipe-of-a-cake “theory” as well as a good one, so long as the two lie upon the shelf; but just take action on this recipe—abominable! But dear Antinomian, that was very good in theory, it was an egg; and if we had “let it alone,” it would have filled its place with the others on the shelf.
There are certain practices among Christians that cannot by any possible means be reduced to theory conformable to Bible precept, prominent among which is the practice of keeping the first day of the week as the Sabbath of the Lord. Christian friends, would it not be well to have just enough Bible theory as to be ready always to give an answer to every man that asketh you, a reason why you keep the first day, upon which God worked, and permitted us to do so, too, in preference to the seventh day, upon which God rested, which he blessed and sanctified, and on the sacred hours of which he has commanded us not to work?
Brethren, a theological practice without a Bible theory is next-door neighbor to that theory of no law, which, if reduced to practice, opens as with a pass-word the great flood-gates of sin and iniquity, and throws sparks of human and Satanic depravity into the great magazine of governmental restraint. Anarchy, crime, and general diabolism cover the earth; but “the law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul.” Ps. 19: 7. Practical theory, indeed!
Alto, Ind.