THE WESLEYAN BOYCOTT—AS IT WERE

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 25, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 21.

Read the full edition

THE WESLEYAN BOYCOTT—AS IT WERE.

In the Wesleyan Methodist of May 5, 1886, appears an article, entitled, “Earnest Counsel,” in which the editor says:—
“We most earnestly counsel all our dear brethren to have nothing to do with the Seventh-day Materialistic Adventists.” He then goes on to exhort his readers not to give these Adventists the least hearing, but to take the books and papers with which they “flood the community,” and “kindle the morning fire with them before they are read.” “We have gone over their theories,” he says, “and are shocked at them.”
Passing over the charges that our main purpose is to break up churches, and that we are notorious for making all the disturbance possible on Sunday, with the evident purpose of annoying those who keep that day, the wicked falsity of which all who are acquainted with our people will at once perceive, we can but remark that the counsel offered is the safest that could be given to hold them to their present creed. If when the principles of the Reformation were beginning to work in the hearts of men, leading to the struggle through which they were to emerge from the superstition, stagnation, and ignorance of the Dark Ages,—if then all investigation and progress could have been suppressed, as papists tried to suppress them, Christendom would have been held back from that birth to enlightenment and liberty which speedily followed. But the spirit of inquiry could not then be stayed; and perhaps people to-day will not be found any more ready to bow to the nod of some would-be theological boss.
Our Wesleyan friend is “shocked” at the idea that God will not keep the wicked to all eternity in the flames of hell, screeching and howling in unutterable and everlasting torment, and hurling curses and blasphemies into the face of Heaven, while God, by the direct act of his almighty power, keeps them alive that he may thus torment them, and exerts all his divine attributes to make them as keenly sensitive as possible, and their wretchedness as intense as he can make it. He may gloat over this as a delightful picture. We do not. And we can assure every one who will candidly investigate the Scriptures, of sufficient evidence to show that God—the God of the Bible, the God of love—is not such a friend. And if it is desired that men shall continue to believe these God-dishonoring dogmas, the very best way to secure it is to do as the Wesleyan advises—listen to nothing, and read nothing, that sets forth a better view, burn the books and papers, shut your eyes, seal up every avenue of intelligence, and stagnate and fossilize in superstition and error!
He further says: “If professed Christians glory in reasoning themselves out of an immortal soul, debasing themselves to the level of mere brute life, do not allow them to deceive you into believing that you are no higher than the beast that perisheth.”
It is amusing to witness the scare which believers in natural immortality fall into over the idea of being brought down to a level with brutes, by our position, when it is precisely their own view, and not ours, which leads to this conclusion. A few facts will prove this. Thus, they base their views of the immortality of the soul on what the Bible says about the “soul” and “spirit.” But the Bible just as expressly declares that all beasts, birds, reptiles, and creeping things, have a “soul” and “spirit” as that man possesses them. See Gen. 1:20, 21, 24, 30, where “life” and “living creature” are from the same terms that are translated “living soul,” and applied to man in Gen. 2:7. See also Gen. 7:22, where fowl and cattle and beast and creeping thing are associated with man, and it is declared that they all have in their nostrils the “breath of life,” or stronger still, “the breath of the spirit of life,” as in the margin, or “lives,” as the word is plural. Now, as our friends hold that soul and spirit always signify an immortal part, they make every beast, bug, worm, and midget, an immortal being, just as much as man. Is this bringing man down to the level of the brute? or is it bringing all brutes up to a level with man? or what is the difference, any way?
Such is the inevitable result of the views they hold. It can by no possibility be avoided on their ground. But our position compels us to no such conclusion; for we deny that “soul” and “spirit” as used in the Scriptures (nephesh, ruach, psyche and pneuma) denote any such immortal part as is claimed for them. Hence all breathing organisms may possess them in common, and the way be still left open and clear to give to man an almost infinitely higher position through the superior mental and moral organization which God has conferred upon him.
Misrepresentation and abuse we expect and are prepared to receive with great equanimity and composure; but the truth will be proclaimed just the same; and this little attempt to boycott it, we do not imagine will prove a very conspicuous success.