A GREEK FALSEHOOD

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 18, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 20.

Read the full edition

A GREEK FALSEHOOD.

IGNORANCE OR DISHONESTY? WHICH?

Theological teachers are fast learning that the English version of the Scriptures cannot be used with any effect among English readers to uphold the doctrine of a Sunday Sabbath; for with the Bible in their hands, such readers can easily satisfy themselves, whatever inferences and sophisms may be set up to the contrary, that there is absolutely no testimony therein to be found in favor of such an institution. There is no record that Christ ever spoke one word concerning it; and when the apostles came to make up their testimony, they gave no instruction nor counsel in reference to it. They gave no law for it; they never kept it; and they left no example in its behalf. Hence we transgress no inspired authority when we devote it to secular uses.
But past generations, we do not now stop to inquire by what means, have introduced throughout all Christendom the practice of Sunday Sabbatizing. The Church finds itself to-day with this custom on its hands. Some who wish to know for themselves the foundation of their faith, question the practice and challenge its authority. They appeal to the Scriptures which Protestants profess to acknowledge as the sole authority in such matters. What ought all true Protestants to do in such a case?—They ought to submit the question fully to that tribunal, and abide by its decision; and if its authority does not sustain such an institution, then they should discard it as a doctrine of men, and return to the original institution as taught in the word of God, which men have tried to supplant by their new invention.
But few, alas! seem ready to take this course, but rather the opposite. Finding themselves, though by no fault of their own, observing Sunday, they seem determined to maintain the practice at all hazards, by fair means if possible (which is all right if it can be done), but if these fail, then by questionable methods, by sophistry, assumption and false assertion, rather than admit the truth, change their practice, and return with humble and honest hearts to the way which the Lord marks out in his word. This latter is the course to which we object, and which we shall try to expose for the sake of honest souls who may be endangered thereby.
Ask yourself, reader, seriously, these questions: Of what avail will error be to me in the great day when men shall be judged according to the truth that has been set before them? And even if by adhering to it, I might for a time enjoy the pleasure of going with the multitude and retaining a good name among men, of what profit will that be to me in the day when the Lord shall make up his jewels, and when he will account as such only those who have preferred his word above the traditions of men, and esteemed his favor more than the friendship of the world?
As remarked in the outset, theologians are learning that very little can be done with the English version in behalf of Sunday. But the New Testament was first written in Greek; the people generally are not acquainted with that language: can we, therefore, not manipulate that so as to make it appear to teach the sacredness of the first day of the week? Such is the question which they seem to propose to themselves; and such is the end which those who are either ignorant or dishonest seek to attain. The way in which they attempt this, and the real facts in the case, we propose now to lay fully before the reader.
There are eight texts in the New Testament in which the first day of the week is mentioned: Matt. 28: 1; Mark 16: 2, 9; Luke 24: 1; John 20: 1, 19; Acts 20: 7; 1 Cor. 16: 2. It is of course to these that appeal is made. The construction is exactly the same in all these passages. It will be noticed that in the common version in each instance the word “day” is printed in italics, indicating that that word has been supplied by the translators. We shall show before closing these remarks that this is the right word to supply, and that it is really necessary to bring out the sense of the passages in full; but at present these remarks are confined to just what is expressed in the Greek. Omitting that word “day,” we have “first of the week,” for which we have equivalent words in the Greek.
But the word rendered “week,” is the Greek word sabbaton in some of its forms, which is also the word for “Sabbath,” and is translated “Sabbath” in numerous instances, when only the seventh day is intended.
Learning that “week” in the passages referred to, comes from the same word as “Sabbath,” some, in defiance of the fact that it is sometimes necessary to translate it “week,” propose to discard that translation, and call it “Sabbath.” Then they have this reading, “first of the Sabbath.”
This senseless phrase (senseless because they so translate it) does not quite read to their satisfaction, so they attempt to slur it over into “first Sabbath,” and then, “first-day Sabbath,” which is Sunday; and then, with a great flourish of trumpets, they proclaim, “Lo! Sunday is called the Sabbath in the New Testament! It is always called so. The inspired writers never call it anything else!” The stupid wickedness of this claim can easily be made to appear.
To do this it will be necessary to look at the construction of the Greek; and it will be sufficient to take only one out of the eight passages in question, the construction, as already noticed, being the same in each one. Matt. 28: 1 enjoys a certain distinction in being the first expression of the kind, hence the attention of the reader is invited to that.
The following are the Greek words of the passage, with a transliteration into English characters, accompanied with a literal word for word translation:—
Ὀψὲ δὲ σαββάτων Opse de sabbatōn “Late but of the Sabbath τῇ ἐπιφωσκούσῃ εἰς μίαν σαββάτων tē epiphōskousē eis mian sabbatōn, it beginning to dawn into the first of the week.”
A word or two in regard to the meaning of this passage, before we enter upon a particular examination of the construction and the terms employed. Some have taken the ground, on the strength of this language, that the resurrection of Christ took place before the Sabbath ended. But this cannot be correct; for it is not a supposable case that Matthew and Mark would directly contradict each other in regard to such an event; but Mark says plainly, referring to the same time, “And when the Sabbath was past” (διαγενομένου τοῦ σαββάτου).
Accordingly we find that this word opse is used in reference to what is already past. In the vocabulary to Greenfield’s Greek Testament, the following definition is given to this word: “Adv. late, viz., past for the first watch, at evening (Mark 11: 19; 13: 35); ὀψὲ σαββάτων, late in the Sabbath, i. e., after, or at the end of, the Sabbath (Matt. 28: 1).”
Dr. Barnes in his “Notes” explains Matt. 28: 1, as follows:—“Matt. 28: 1. In the end of the Sabbath. The word end here means the same as after the Sabbath, i. e., after the Sabbath was fully completed, or finished, and may be expressed in this manner: In the night following the Sabbath (for the Sabbath closed at sunset), as it began to dawn.”
Bloomfield in his “Greek Testament with English Notes,” remarks upon this passage as follows:—“Matt. 28: 1. Opse de Sabb. This must, with Krebs, Wahl, Tittm., Kuin., and Fritz, be explained, ‘after the Sabbath,’ i. e., as Mark more clearly expresses it, διαγενομένου τοῦ σαββάτου, [the Sabbath being past] which must determine the sense here. Of this signification the commentators adduce examples from Philost., Plut., Ælian, Xenophon.”
In the well-known Commentary of Dr. Adam Clarke, under the 28th chapter of Matthew, we find these words:—“Verse 1. In the end of the Sabbath] Opse de Sabbatōn. After the end of the week: this is the translation given by several eminent critics; and in this way the word opse is used by the most eminent Greek writers. Thucydides, lib. IV. chap. 93, tēs hēmeras opse ēn—the day was ended. Plutarch, opse tōn basileōs chronōn—after the times of the king. Philostratus, opse tōn Troikōn—after the Trojan war. See Rosenmüller. In general the Jews divided their natural day, which consisted of twenty-four hours, into day and night. Their artificial day began at the rising, and ended at the setting, of the sun; all the rest of the time, from the setting to the rising of the sun, they termed night: hence the same word, in Hebrew, signifies both evening and night. Gen. 1: 5; Mark 6: 47. Matthew has employed the word in this extensive sense here, pointing out the latter part of the Jewish night, that which immediately preceded the rising of the sun, and not the first part, which we call the evening. The transaction mentioned here evidently took place early on the morning of the third day after our Lord’s crucifixion; what is called our Sunday morning, or first day of the week.”
Robinson, the standard lexicographer of New Testament Greek, in his lexicon gives the following as the definitions of the word opse:—“1. Absol. late, late evening. Mark 11: 19. Put for the evening watch, Mark 13: 35. 2. With a genitive, i. q. at the end of, at the close of, after. Matt. 28: 1, opse de sabbatōn, at the end of the Sabbath, i. e., after the Sabbath, the Sabbath being now ended, i. q. Mark 16: 1. For the genitive, see Buttm. §132, 5. b.”
In the case before us, opse is used with a genitive (sabbatōn being in the genitive case), and hence has here the second of the definitions above given. This word occurs in the New Testament but three times, and in both the instances besides Matt. 28: 1, is rendered “even,” referring to the beginning or early portion of the dark part of the day, as in Mark 13: 35. When used in connection with the word “Sabbath,” it certainly carries us over into the evening or dark part of the following day (the evening according to the Bible method of computation being the first part of the day), and shows that the Sabbath was wholly past, as stated in all the authorities above referred to.
Let it be noted, then, on the evidence thus far presented, that the language does not teach that one series of Sabbaths there ended to make way for a new series, as some contend, under cover of which they wish to slip in the first day of the week. It only asserts that “when the Sabbath was past,” and it was drawing on toward daylight on the first day of the week, the women came to the sepulchre, etc.
(Concluded next week.)