A PLEA FOR LIBERTY

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jul 13, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 28.

Read the full edition

A PLEA FOR LIBERTY.

The same number of the St. Louis Republican from which we give this week an article on “The Sunday Question,” contains the following able discussion of the question of enforcing the Sunday law. Under the heading above given, James E. McGinnis says:—
“Permit me at the outset to disavow any hostility to the religious observance of Sunday as the Christian Sabbath, and to declare my reverence for it as an institution of the Church, and my enjoyment of it always as a day of rest and respite from labor. But I oppose attempts to enforce its observance by law, as being contrary to the true spirit of our free institutions, and beyond the legitimate field of legislation.
“The real functions of government are few and simple, and are well defined in our bill of rights, which declares ‘that all persons have a natural right to life, liberty, and the enjoyment of the gains of their own industry;’ that to give security to these is the principal office of government;’ and whenever it exceeds these duties, it becomes intermeddling, if not tyrannical, with expedients, experiments, and plans ‘for the welfare of the people.’ Thus we are governed too much. We have too many laws, most of them upon subjects which do not pertain to the true domain of law. Of these are all such as assume to direct what the citizen shall not himself do on Sunday above any other day.
“It is the duty of the State to protect all persons within its jurisdiction in the exercise of their religious rights; and persons who believe it is morally wrong to labor on Sunday, should be protected against being compelled by their employers to labor on that day in violation of such religious belief. But I fail to recognize any constitutional power or authority in the State to say that the employer shall not himself labor on Sunday, and that he shall not permit his servant to labor on that day. . . . Such enactments are usurpations of authority, and violative of natural right. The supporters of such laws seek to justify them upon either moral or hygienic grounds; but upon neither can they be supported, although rational, voluntary observance of Sunday may rest upon both. To place such laws upon moral grounds, is to amalgamate the functions of Church and State in a manner not permissible under our system of government; and to refer them to hygienic requirement, is to open the field to sumptuary legislation without end. It may be admitted that health is promoted by Sunday rest; so it certainly is by cleanly habits, and by temperance in eating and drinking. But no one will seriously claim that the State could rightfully compel everybody to take a bath on Sunday, or that it could establish regulations governing the times and methods of taking food and drink; and yet such regulations, upon such grounds, are no farther from the legitimate scope of legislation, than are Sunday laws upon hygienic grounds. I am aware that the constitutionality of Sunday laws has been upheld upon moral grounds by a most remarkable opinion of the supreme court of this State, delivered by the late Judge Scott (20 Mo. R. 214), which is strictly in harmony with the spirit of such laws, and is quite as unrepublican and narrow as the theory which underlies them. It plainly states that this is a Christian State, with a Christian constitution, made by and for Christians, and not for ‘strangers collected from all quarters of the globe, each with a religion of his own.’ This un-American, anti-republican decision is not a true exposition of the law. This is not a Christian State, nor is it under a Christian constitution, but one made for Jews, Mohammedans, pagans, infidels, and Christians alike; and that this may long remain the land of perfect religious liberty is the fervent aspiration of every patriot and real lover of his kind.
“The true criterion of Sunday laws is the great rule that ‘the citizen must so exercise his rights as not to invade the rights of others;’ or, differently stated, ‘every one has a right to do as he pleases so long as he does not interfere with any one else.’ He may labor on Sunday if he chooses to do so, but he must not compel his servant to do so, nor must he labor in such a way as to interfere with the rights of others. For instance, he has no right to carry on a very noisy business close to others who may desire rest in quiet on that day, and who have a right to such quiet, subject only to the necessary noises of an urban population. And certainly he must not carry on his business, nor pursue his pleasures, in such a way as to disturb the solemn quiet of religious worship. Thus people have no right to parade the streets with brass-bands on Sunday, and especially during the hours usually devoted to congregational worship, any more than the congregations have the right to make the air of the whole city vibrant with the clangor of church bells on that day. Both are offensive to many people, and in fact the bells, separated from the traditions, romance, and sentiment which surround them, are much the greater nuisance. Subject to the limitations suggested, every man has a perfect natural right to spend Sunday just as he pleases; and any law which assumes to abridge, or in any manner interfere with, the exercise of those natural rights which one does not necessarily surrender in becoming a member of the State, is in the very nature of things unconstitutional and void, and practically declared a nullity by the customs and habits of mankind.
“Once admit the right of the State to legislate upon the subject of Sunday observance, further than for the protection of the citizen, and logically there can be no limit to the exercise of that right. Let legislation begin by providing that the citizen shall cease from labor, traffic, and travel on Sunday, and it can logically proceed to the enactment of a law that he shall go to church on Sunday, then to one that he shall aid in building the church, and so on, by easy gradation of usurpation, until it reaches the climax of pointing out by law the particular faith to which he shall subscribe, and of enforcing the mandate by imprisonment and the stake. That we have not retrograded to such a culmination is due to the free spirit of the age as opposed to the intolerance of religious bigotry.
“It is generally conceded that regular stated periods of rest are necessary, both to the mental and physical health. The recurrence of day and night presents the natural allotment of time to labor and rest; and by the customs of civilized nations, as well as by the ordinances of Christian churches, one day out of seven is set apart for rest. This is believed to be natural, and therefore right.”
“Rest can only be found in change; and to the toiling millions, that rest obtained in these stated periods of repose, is the most perfect where it is sought amid conditions farthest removed from the surroundings of their daily lives. They naturally rush for, and are delighted with, a touch of that variety which is said to be the spice of life. Our Sunday laws, if enforced, would seriously interfere with this choice of change. Their Procrustean requirements seek to make all men rest in the same way, which totally negatives the idea of rest to the majority of persons; for that which is rest to one is unrest to another. And the municipality should increase the facilities for the recreation and amusement of the people, so that the clerks, artisans, mechanics, and laborers of the city may find cheap, accessible, and restful occupation for their Sundays, that their enjoyment of life may be thereby greatly enhanced, and their contentment and love of country correspondingly increased.”