HENRY STETZEL AND THE SABBATH.
By J. S. Shrock
Henry Stetzel, a retired minister of the Evangelical denomination, has recently written a small treatise on the subject of the Sabbath; and inasmuch as this little work is attracting considerable attention at the present time, I have taken time to look into its peculiar claims. The author treats the subject under three different heads or divisions; viz., “The Original Sabbath,” “The Jewish Sabbath,” and “The Christian Sabbath.” The theory advanced is that Sunday is the original seventh-day Sabbath, but that God gave the Jews a new Sabbath, the sixth day of the original week. The author first shows how and when the Sabbath was instituted, and then traces its observance from creation to the exode. He says:— “That this Sabbath was continued and handed down from Adam to Noah and the flood, and from Noah and the flood to future generations, is a decided fact.” In speaking of Israel and this original Sabbath after the exode, he says:— “We have as yet here nothing to do with a Saturday Sabbath.” This is said, remember, in order to show that God’s people observed the seventh day of the week until after they left Egypt, and down to the time when the manna first fell. The evidence, however, that God did there and then change the Sabbath from the seventh to the sixth day of the week is based on the date of leaving Egypt. He claims that the 15th day of Abib was Thursday, and hence the manna first fell on Sunday, or the seventh day of the week! Notice, reader, what an array of evidence he is enabled to give in support of this theory:— “When did this exodus of the Israelites occur?” “There exists in reference to this question in Biblical chronology a dismal labyrinth, inasmuch as there are not two to be found who in every respect entertain the same opinion.”—Page 32. The truth is to be congratulated that its enemies never can agree. But he speaks further:— “The new arrangement of weeks and the change of the Sabbath day were a matter of necessity, because the relations of man were far different from what they were in paradise.” What profundity of thought! A pressing “necessity” of changing the Sabbath from the seventh to the sixth day of the week because man fell, and yet man and the angels and the Lord himself failed to discover this fact for a period of over twenty-five hundred years! And, behold, when this little discrepancy was discovered and rectified, it only answered the purpose for about fifteen hundred years, when they had to change it back again! But Mr. Stetzel exclaims, “Tell it not in Gath!” Certainly not. Will not the men of God rise up in Judgment and condemn such men? for they obeyed the voice of the Lord, and kept all his commandments. Josh. 22:2. There is, however, quite a difference between the Lord’s conclusion and that of Mr. S. The Lord claims that he gave the Israelites the very day on which he had rested, and the day which he had blessed and sanctified. Mr. S. says it was altogether a different day. The Lord claims he gave the seventh day, but Mr. S. says, No; it was the sixth! But did he not quote the fourth commandment, and would not that in itself betray his crooked course?—Yes; he quoted the fourth commandment as far as it answered his purpose, and the remainder he left out. He then proceeds with the claim that because God gave the Jews the sixth day of the week as their day of rest, the original seventh day became the first, and continued thus until the morning of the resurrection; “but afterward, according to the original plan, it was the seventh.”—Page 41. It will here be remembered that Mr. S. admitted that he was unable to find one man who fully agreed with him on his first premise; and certainly we are interested to know the amount of evidence he has on this. We find it in the quotation, “Biblical chronologists are not harmonious on that point.”—Page 37. It should be said, however, that they are much more “harmonious” than our author admits; but the fact is, they are arrayed against him. Mr. S. rests the question by asserting that after the resurrection morning, Sunday, or the resurrection day, “was the seventh.” What have we to produce against this claim? 1. The doctrine of the author’s own church, as follows: (Question 433) “Why does Christianity celebrate the first day of the week as the Lord’s day?”—“Because Jesus Christ our Lord rose from the dead on this day,” etc.—Evangelical Catechism, p. 142. 2. The Christian world, both Protestants and Catholics. 3. Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John all with one voice declare it is the “first day of the week.” 4. Luke, as late as the year 59, refers to this particular day, and says it is “the first day of the week.” Acts 20:7. 5. Paul, who was told what to do (Acts 22:10), wrote a letter to Corinth about the year 59, and in mentioning this day calls it by its right name—“first day of the week.” 1 Cor. 16:2. Here, before “so great a cloud of witnesses,” a man in the nineteenth century will dare to stand up and say, No; it was not the first day of the week after the resurrection morning, but the original seventh! In good keeping, however, with the foregoing, referring to those who are keeping the day which God has blessed and hallowed, he says:—629 “They cannot keep the Jewish Sabbath lawfully, and the Christian Sabbath they will not keep, thereby making themselves deplorable Sabbath-day breakers, who appear in sheep’s clothing. Only impudent hypocrites and falsifiers of God’s word,” etc. To whom does such language most fitly apply? We, in harmony with the word of God, say the Lord commanded Israel to keep the same day on which he had rested. Mr. S. says he gave them the sixth day of the original week. We, in harmony with the word of God, say the resurrection day continued to be the first day of the week. Mr. S. denies this. Before closing this article, I must mention one more point. On page 43, he argues that to keep the Sabbath of the fourth commandment is to deny the atonement. Here are his words:— “The Sunday [Saturday] Sabbath of the Jews cannot be kept by any one without ignoring the atonement and denying the resurrection of our Lord; and hence a denial of Christ.” Let us compare this statement with what the Evangelical Catechism says: “‘Remember the Sabbath day to keep it holy. Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work: but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy man-servant, nor thy maid-servant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates: for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day; wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.’ Ex. 20: 8-11; Deut. 5: 12-15.” (Question 426) “Has, then, this fourth commandment also the same divine importance for all mankind and all times as each of the other ten commandments?”—“By all means.” “It has the same divine importance as each of the other holy ten commandments.” “Matt. 5: 18, 19: ‘For verily I say unto you, Till heaven and earth pass, one jot or one tittle shall in no wise pass from the law, till all be fulfilled. Whosoever, therefore, shall break one of these least commandments, and shall teach men so, he shall be called the least [shall have no room nor space] in the kingdom of heaven.’ James 2: 10: ‘For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.’” Could any conscientious Christian and a member of the Evangelical church, with a knowledge of the teachings of their Bible and catechism, believe this assertion of Mr. Stetzel, that “if you undertake to keep the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, you deny the atonement”! Would you not, dear reader, in view of such a statement, exclaim, “Give me the Bible!” “Give me the commandments of God”! Yes, “Fear God, and keep his commandments; for this is the whole duty of man.” Eccl. 12: 13. Praise God for a truth that is ever in harmony with his holy will, a truth which is shining brighter and brighter, a truth through which we shall finally be crowned with eternal reward when it will be realized that “blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.” Rev. 22: 14.