The 144,000 and the Living Generation

8%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 12, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 40.

Read the full edition

The 144,000 and the Living Generation

THE 144,000.

A BROTHER sends us the following statements taken from a sermon by a first-day Adventist, saying that an inquirer handed them to him, and wished our opinion on them. The statements relate principally to the 144,000 of Rev. 7 and 14, and are as follows:— “The 144,000 were all Israelites. Not one of them were of the Gentiles. They were the ones that came up after Christ’s resurrection, and were the first-fruits of the resurrection. They were of the twelve tribes of the children of Israel; therefore they were not the living that are translated when Christ comes. The wave sheaf represented those raised after Christ’s resurrection. God foreknew and predestined that this company should be raised.” Again he said, “Prophetic time has not run out because there can be no tarrying time; for Daniel will stand in his lot at the end of the days, and he is still in the grave. The 1290 years reach to 1844, therefore we are about at the end of the 1335 years.”
If our brother has a copy of “Thoughts on Daniel and the Revelation,” as all should have, to show to this inquirer, he will there find the reasons given in full to show that the 144,000 are gathered out of the last generation of the living before Christ comes. Space will allow only a brief recapitulation here.
1. The 144,000 are indeed all Israelites and all from the twelve tribes; but if it is a fact that all Christians to the end of time are called “Israel,” and are reckoned as the “twelve tribes,” the 144,000 can be taken from the last generation as well as from any other, and still be from the twelve tribes. Now the Scriptures are very explicit in their teaching that all Christians are Israel and the twelve tribes, and are the only ones who are now recognized of Heaven as such. All who are Abraham’s seed are Israel. But Paul says, “If ye be Christ’s then are ye Abraham’s seed.” Gal. 3:29. Then all Christians are Israel.
2. Since the first advent of Christ, the literal descendants are not counted as the seed; but only those who are connected with Abraham through Christ; that is, Christians. Rom. 2:28, 29; 9:6–8. How a person can read these passages and deny that Christians are the only Israel now recognized as in existence, is past comprehension. Paul declares plainly that being a literal descendant of Abraham does not, of itself, now constitute a man an Israelite at all; it does not make him a child of God, nor connect him with the “seed” to which the promises of God pertain. And who then are the real Israel, the true seed, since the days of Christ?—They which are Jews inwardly, not outwardly; they which are children after the Spirit, not after the flesh; they who are “children of the promise.” These Paul says positively are the ones who “are counted for the seed.” These and no others are Israel; but these are Christians.
3. Israel is represented as a tame olive tree having branches. There were twelve of these; for there were twelve tribes. By rejecting Christ these were broken off; and then wherever a Gentile was found who was willing to become a sincere, humble child of God, and believe in Christ, he was grafted in, and became a part of the Israelitish tree. Rom. 11:17. And the Jews themselves, if they will renounce their unbelief, and accept of Christ, may be grafted in also (verse 23); but there is no other way for them now to be reckoned as Israel. The whole basis of relationship to God is changed since the introduction of the gospel dispensation; that is, people are not now connected with him as nations, but as individuals, and our acceptance with him is secured, not by having the blood of Abraham in our veins, but by having the Spirit of Christ in our hearts. Was the olive tree destroyed because the natural branches were broken off?—No; it was perpetuated by the Gentile grafts. Were all the branches compressed into one, so that now the tree has but one limb?—No; such a supposition would be ridiculous. Every branch of course is grafted; and the twelve branches are continued by the grafts. And when the Gentiles began thus to be grafted in, did the tree become a Gentile tree?—No; but these Gentiles lost their foreign and alien character, and became members of “the commonwealth of Israel.” Eph. 2:12, 19. And the same process continues to this day. Every man who is out of Christ is a Gentile; and just as soon as a man accepts Christ, and is accepted of him, he is no longer a Gentile, a stranger and foreigner, but a member of “the commonwealth of Israel;” and the whole flourishing top of the true Israelitish tree, with its twelve branches, is now composed exclusively of these Christian grafts. So “Israel” and the “twelve tribes,” the twelve branches, are now found only in the Christian world. Any other position is squarely contrary to this plain teaching of the apostle.
4. No one can reasonably deny, and we presume no Adventist will be disposed to deny, that the epistle of James is addressed to believers who were to live in the last days, when “the coming of the Lord draweth nigh,” and when “the Judge stands before the door.” James 5:3, 7–9. But James addresses these Christians under the title of “the twelve tribes scattered abroad.” James 1:1.
5. The genealogical distinction of tribes is not preserved during the period of the development of the spiritual seed, because it is not necessary, there being no object to be gained by it. This distinction was kept up strictly till the seed, Christ, came, that it might be demonstrated that he sprang from Judah, according to the Messianic prophecies. That being accomplished, this distinction is no longer needed among men, and has consequently disappeared, even the Jews themselves having been unable to preserve their own genealogy. But the church of the first-born (Christ) is “written,” or “enrolled” (margin) in heaven. Heb. 12:23. And in this record, for a purpose to be hereafter secured, the distinction of tribes is doubtless preserved.
6. This purpose, it would seem natural to conclude, is that the company of the redeemed from all lands and all dispensations may be properly classified, as they enter through the gates into New Jerusalem. For this Christian city, which has on its foundations the names of the twelve apostles of the Lamb, has on its twelve gates the names of the twelve tribes of the children of Israel. Hence all who ever enter there, Christians as well as Jews, will be belonging to some one of these twelve tribes of Israel. These reasons are certainly sufficient to show that the 144,000 may come from the last generation of Christians, and still be Israel and from the twelve tribes.
That the 144,000 are the ones who are translated when Christ comes, is evident from what John says of them in Rev. 14:4. They are redeemed “from among men,” not from among the dead. This can be spoken only of the living. The first five verses of Rev. 14 belong to the line of prophecy of Rev. 12 and 13. They are a company whose religious experience closes with a terrible conflict with the beast and his image. Rev. 13:15–17. But these powers are just what the world is warned against by the third message of Rev. 14:9–13,—a message which goes forth just before, and reaches to, the second coming of Christ. Verse 14.
Those raised with Christ are doubtless the ones referred to in Rom. 8:29, 30; but they are not the 144,000. There is no intimation that that was the number of that company. Nor are they the “first-fruits;” for Paul declares plainly that Christ is the first-fruits. 1 Cor. 15:20. The wave sheaf did not typify any of the human family raised from the dead; but it typified the resurrection of Christ. For Paul says again that the “body” of all the types “is of Christ,” not of the church, or any part of it. Col. 2:17.
As to the prophetic periods, the idea that the 1290 years ended in 1844 is pure assumption. Nothing occurred in 554 from which to date them. The prophet says that they begin from the taking away of “the daily” in order to the setting up of the abomination that maketh desolate. Dan. 12:11, margin. The “daily” refers to paganism, and the abomination that maketh desolate, to the papacy. The latter was set up in 538, and paganism was broken down preparatory to this event, thirty years before in 508. See testimony of Apollos Hale in Advent Manual, as quoted in “Thoughts on Daniel.” The two periods, the 1260 and 1290 years, ended together in 1798. The 1335 years extended 45 years later to 1843. The days at the end of which Daniel stands in his lot are not the 1335, but the longer period of the 2300. The word “lot” does not mean a piece of real estate, and Daniel’s standing in his lot does not refer to his resurrection. It simply refers to the favorable decision to be rendered in his case in the preliminary Judgment work of the sanctuary before Christ comes, just as the Israelites had the land divided to them by lot (the same word), before they entered into Canaan. The 2300 days bring us to the opening sanctuary work in heaven; and there Daniel stands in his “lot” in the decisions of that tribunal, previous to entering upon the actual possession of his portion of the heavenly Canaan.