A WOULD-BE REPLY

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 16, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 45.

Read the full edition

A WOULD-BE REPLY.

BY A. SMITH.
In the Michigan Christian Advocate of Aug. 21, under “Editorial Notes,” appears the following:—
“A certain Mr. Smith, of Grandville, Mich., sends us his criticism on our Sabbath articles, in which we endeavored to show that Jesus met with his disciples only on the first day of the week, after his resurrection until his ascension. A sample criticism reads as follows:—
“‘But it is with great brevity that the editor of the Advocate refers to the meeting at the Sea of Galilee (John 21 : 1-14), evidently afraid to have it known that the disciples went fishing on Sunday, and that Jesus taught them how to catch fish.’”
“Had Mr. Smith been as sharp as he imagines himself to be, he would have been more careful how he handled this two-edged sword. Those who turn to the passage referred to, will perceive that Jesus appeared to his disciples, not on the day they went fishing, but on the following morning, when, after a long night of fruitless toil, they approached the shore with nothing to eat. . . . Allowing that the appearance of Jesus to his disciples was on Sunday morning, it follows that the disciples went fishing on Saturday, thereby ignoring the Jewish Sabbath; and that his instructions to them as to casting the net on Sunday morning was for two purposes; viz., (1) To obtain food, which was lawful on the Sabbath day, and (2) To impress them with a sense of his divine character.”
The editor of the Advocate seems to know (?) that “Mr. Smith imagines himself to be sharp.” No doubt Goliath of Gath held a like opinion of the youthful David. As to the disciples’ going fishing on Saturday, as the editor claims, we deny it. Admitting that the meeting referred to was on Sunday morning, the seven disciples, congregated as they probably were at Peter’s house, in Capernaum, near the sea, having kept the Sabbath according to the fourth commandment, when it closed, at the setting of the sun, the resolution recorded in John 21 : 3 was formed and acted upon “immediately,” on “that night,” which was the dark part of the day on which Jesus met with them, or on Sunday eve. The assertion of the editor, therefore, that “the disciples went fishing on Saturday, thereby ignoring the Jewish Sabbath” has no foundation in fact or reasonable inference.
As to the miracle wrought on Sunday morning, we are surprised to learn that 150 great fishes were needed to supply seven men, with possibly the family of Peter, over one Sabbath (?), especially after taking of the ample breakfast Jesus had prepared for them. The editorial in the Advocate closes with these words:—
“After they had all dined, Jesus devoted the day with them in imparting useful moral lessons, and teaching them the things pertaining to the kingdom of God. Thus how easily a ‘waspish dab’ is disposed of. Mr. Smith should direct his sting against something more vulnerable—a grindstone for instance.”
No doubt the Advocate would be right in supposing that Jesus spent the day with his disciples as he declares him to have done; and while he was thus instructing them, they were doubtless engaged in dressing and salting their fish, and drying their net.