THE DOCTORS DISAGREE

9%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 9, 1886

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 63, No. 44.

Read the full edition

“THE DOCTORS DISAGREE.”

GOOD SABBATH ARGUMENT FROM A METHODIST EDITOR.
BY W. R. PATTERSON.
WHILE reading the arguments usually brought forward to sustain Sunday observance, one is often reminded of the story of Balak and Balaam (Num. 22), though our opponents are not as faithful as the ancient prophet Balaam in not transcending the “word of the Lord.” Balak’s efforts to have Israel cursed, resulted in just so many blessings to them. So it seems when a modern doctor of divinity rises up to arrange the props under that “most Christian” institution, the Roman Sunday, that through some mishap he vindicates the thing of all others which he does not intend to vindicate—the “Sabbath of the Lord.” The following article from the Texas Christian Advocate is not an exception to the rule. It seemed of sufficient importance to be preserved, so I gave it a place in my scrap-book. It opens with a quotation from the Texas Monitor, a Catholic paper, published at Galveston, as follows:—
“Of course the Old Testament has many injunctions as to Saturday, the seventh day, which was the Lord’s Sabbath. But as the Catholic Church under the new dispensation chose Sunday instead of Saturday as the day of particular religious observance, these Old Testament injunctions do not apply. Sunday, as a day distinguished from other days of the week, is purely an institution of the Catholic Church—not a scriptural institution at all. As the Catholic Church established Sunday for a day of special observance, it logically rests with that Church to say how the day shall be observed.”
To the foregoing the Christian Advocate replies:—
“This assumption of the power of the Catholic Church is precisely the position it holds, though it is seldom expressed in such plain English as this assertion that God has given many injunctions as to Saturday, the seventh day, which was the Lord’s Sabbath, but the Catholic Church chose another day, and assumes the right to say how it shall be observed. We learn from the New Testament that the Lord’s day, or the day when Jesus rose from the dead, was observed as a day of worship in the apostolic church; and for this reason it has been accepted as the Sabbath under the Christian dispensation. These events in apostolic history transpired centuries before the bishop of Rome claimed dominion over the church and the world; and hence the assertion that the Catholic Church made this change is as unfounded in fact as it is arrogant in spirit.”
*“The claim that the Catholic Church can not only change at will the day God has appointed as the Sabbath [italics mine], but that it has the right to say ‘how Sunday shall be observed,’ is simply to set aside the command of God in creation, when he sanctified the seventh day as a day for rest and worship. It also presumes to set aside the authority of God on Mount Sinai. There God said, ‘The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy man-servant, nor thy maid-servant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates: for in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day: wherefore the Lord blessed the Sabbath day, and hallowed it.’ That law of God has never been annulled.”*
The attention of the reader is called to the foregoing statements, by the use of italics. He continues: “It is as binding on the pope of Rome as it is on the base-ball player who profanes its sacred hours by drunken revelry. When the Church of Rome in its general council, or the pope within the Vatican, or the bishops before their altars, assume that they have the power to amend or abrogate the law of God, they seek to set God aside from his throne, and assume for themselves all the prerogatives of the divine government. All the bulls that were ever issued from the papal throne cannot change one of the laws of God nor justify its violation. . . . God only can amend or suspend his law; and until he recalls his command on Sinai, and until Christ ceases to be the ‘Lord of the Sabbath day,’ no earthly authority can change its power and render its transgression acceptable in the sight of God.”
Unitia, Tex.