RAISING ITS HEAD AGAIN

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 8, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 10.

Read the full edition

RAISING ITS HEAD AGAIN.

In 1882, in California, the movement urged on by religious bigotry to enforce the observance of Sunday by law, making no exception in behalf of those who conscientiously observed in its stead another day, received such a crushing blow as to paralyze it for a time. We know, of course, that it was restrained only temporarily; and the time has now come when it is raising its head again.
A Sunday-law bill is once more before the Legislature of California, and a meeting in the interest of said law, to discuss its principles, was held in Hamilton Hall, Oakland, Friday evening, Feb. 18, 1887. It is reported as having been a very “harmonious” meeting, not even a “dissenting voice” being raised against the sentiments expressed; but this is thought by some to have been owing to the fact that the chairman was so unique in his parliamentary management that he called only for an affirmative expression on questions submitted to vote, giving the negative no opportunity to make its voice heard.
In reference to this meeting and the sentiments there advocated, Bro. E. J. Waggoner, editor of the Signs, has issued “An Address to Thinking People,” from which we quote the following:—
“The speakers laid great emphasis on the statement that the law has no bearing on religion. Dr. Briggs stated that the law was to be discussed purely on a basis of civil necessity. And so it was, in the main; but the fact that it was discussed mainly from a political and economic stand-point, does not prove that it has not a religious aspect. The speakers well know that if they should plead for the Sunday law on the ground that Sunday is the Christian Sabbath, they would meet with far more opposition than they would otherwise, and so they throw a sop to the laboring men, to make people believe that it is a matter of political economy that the Sunday law is pressed.
“But unfortunately for their purpose, they were not able wholly to conceal the real animus of the movement. Prayer has been defined as the ‘sincere desire of the heart,’ and in the opening prayer by the Rev. Dr. Gray, we are let into the real secret of the matter. One of the petitions was, ‘May we be made to feel as far as possible the importance of hedging about with legal enactments that holy day which came to us from Sinai.’ Another was, ‘Grant that the people of this city, and our legislators, may be impressed with the sanctity of the Lord’s day.’ And another was to the effect that the time might speedily come when the Lord’s day should not be a day of amusement, but that it might be a day for undisturbed worship.
“We will not spend time to show the inconsistency of the first petition. Dr. Gray knows as well as we that ‘the day which came to us from Sinai’ is not Sunday, but the seventh day of the week, and we can assure him that although we regard that day as holy, and observe it strictly, we should vigorously oppose any attempt to hedge it about with human laws. The word of Jehovah is all the legal enactment that is needed to hedge about the holy day which came from Sinai. Legal enactments framed by men are necessary only for Sunday, since it has nothing higher in its behalf. But we are at a loss to know how to harmonize Dr. Gray’s prayer and Dr. Briggs’s speech. Dr. Gray is anxious that the Sunday may be hedged about with legal enactments so that it may be observed as a sacred day of rest. Dr. Briggs says that the law is desired purely as a matter of civil necessity. We believe that the prayer of Dr. Gray expressed the real design of the law. Indeed, Dr. Briggs himself so far forgot his caution as to intimate the same thing. Speaking of the plea that moral instruction is the work of the church alone, he said: ‘You relegate more instruction to the churches, and then give us the worst possible opportunity to labor, by providing amusements and opening the way for everybody to go as they please on the day of worship, so that we cannot get at them.’
“That lets us into the secret of the whole business. They want a Sunday law so they can get at people who will not listen to them unless they are forced to. In their zeal, they are going to force men to receive the gospel. We are strongly reminded of the missionary zeal of the Jesuits who founded the California missions, who, we are told, would mount their horses, lasso an Indian and bring him to the mission, where he would receive certain instruction, be baptized, and set to work, a converted Indian. In Christ’s time the kingdom of heaven suffered violence, and the violent took it by force; now it is purposed that the people shall suffer violence, and the kingdom of heaven (?) shall take them by force. This indicates the difference between the Saviour’s method of teaching, and that of modern teachers. Just fancy the Saviour or Paul pettishly complaining that they could not get at the people because the Roman rulers provided so many attractions for them, and begging that they might have the laws so changed that the people would have to listen to their teaching. It was not till pagan licentiousness had greatly corrupted the church, that such pleas were made, and then Constantine, the father of Sunday legislation, enacted his famous Sunday law, and raised the church to the throne of the world. The results were very advantageous to ‘the church’ but were fatal to true Christianity.
“Says Dr. Briggs, ‘We do not ask the Legislature to enact a religious law.’ No, but they do ask the Legislature to enact a law in behalf of Sunday, which is purely an institution of the church. Suppose, for instance, that a notoriously profligate man is a candidate for office; objection is made to him on account of his bad character, but his friends say, ‘We are not asking you to elect a bad man, but simply a citizen. It is not as a libertine that we wish him elected, but simply as a member of the body politic.’ Such a plea would be too transparent to deceive anybody. You cannot separate a man from his personality. If you elect a bad citizen to office, you have a bad officer, no matter upon what basis he is elected; he cannot be separated from his character. So you cannot separate the ecclesiastical character which the church has given to Sunday, from the day. You may say that you are enforcing Sunday observance from a civil stand-point, but the fact remains that Sunday is a child of the church, and a Sunday law is a law in behalf of religion.
“As one testimony among scores that we might bring in support of the statement that the Sunday Sabbath is an institution of the church, and that it is therefore a religious, although not a divine, institution, we quote the following from the Christian at Work, a leading Presbyterian weekly published in New York, of January 3, 1885:—
“‘We rest the designation of Sunday on the church having set it apart of its own authority. The seventh-day rest was [and is] commanded in the fourth commandment. . . . The selection of Sunday, thus changing the particular day designed in the fourth commandment, was brought about by the gradual concurrence of the early Christian church, and on this basis, and none other, does the “Christian Sabbath,” the first day of the week, rightly rest.’
“And in its issue of February 18, 1886, the same paper said:— “‘We hear less than we used to about the apostolic origin of the present Sunday observance. . . . It is now seen, as it is admitted, that we must go to later than apostolic times for the establishment of Sunday observance.’
“These are not the words of a prejudiced person, but of a paper which is working with all its might to secure a strict observance of Sunday by law.
“We now come to the consideration of the bill in question. It has six sections, which are designed to take the place of sections 299, 300, 301, of the Penal Code. The first three sections provide for the strict observance of Sunday. The first is to the effect that any one who shall expose for sale any goods or wares, or shall keep open any work-shop, or liquor saloon, where spirituous, malt, or vinous liquors are sold, shall be deemed guilty of misdemeanor, and shall be fined not less than five nor more than fifty dollars. The second prohibits all rioting, fighting, horse-racing, gaming, and shows, under the same penalty. The third is to the effect that every person who labors himself, or who compels his servant or apprentice to labor on the first day of the week, shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor, and shall be fined not less than five nor more than fifty dollars. If this law were passed and enforced, it is certain that Sunday would be observed as strictly as any one could ask for, for it provides for perfect rest from labor. Section 4 is as follows:—
“Sec. 4. This act shall not extend to any person who conscientiously believes that the seventh day of the week ought to be observed as a Sabbath, and who actually observes such Sabbath, provided that in the pursuit of his labor or business he disturbs no other person.”
“This section was most vigorously objected to by those who addressed the meeting, and we were particularly impressed with the fact that their denunciation of this provision met with the most hearty applause, both from the reverend gentlemen on the stand, and from the pews. Mr. Fox, in particular, was very strenuous in his assertion that ‘we cannot except anybody.’ And in this he was heartily supported. We will not now notice the ‘strong argument’ which he adduced to show why no exception could be made, but will call attention to the consummate selfishness and the utter disregard of human rights, which characterized these advocates of the Sunday law. They have a law framed which prohibits all labor and all amusements on the first day of the week. The framer of the law, however, has put in a clause exempting from penalty those who conscientiously believe in, and actually keep, the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath, provided they disturb nobody else by their labor. Although this is not justice, but is simply toleration, the observers of the seventh day would make no complaint, if the wording were changed slightly, so as to make it read in harmony with the probable meaning. The law provides for perfect quiet on Sunday, for the Sunday worshipers themselves are the judges as to whether or not they are disturbed by the labor of those who worship upon the seventh day. There are some people so extremely sensitive that they would be ‘disturbed’ if they imagined that somebody else was working at the most quiet work in his own house, with the doors closed; but we suppose that it is not the intent of the section to open the way for accusation to be made and sustained unless disturbance has actually been made. Still, the law, even with the needed modification, would be all on the side of the men who plead for Sunday. But they are not contented with that. The law gives them all the opportunity they could desire to get at the people, for those whom it permits to labor would not attend their services anyway; but still no exemption can be made. And yet the advocates of a Sunday law have the effrontery to tell us that it is just, and that there is nothing in it savoring of persecution.
“But Mr. Fox says that this fourth section nullifies the preceding three, and that if it is retained they will have no Sunday observance at all. Said he, ‘If the law is not universal in its requirement, a man may be a Jew on Sunday and a Christian on Saturday, and so evade the law entirely.’ Although there are many Christians who observe Saturday, we gather from this statement that he means that a man could work on Sunday, by professing to believe in the seventh-day Sabbath, and then could also work on Saturday, by professing to be a Sunday-keeper. And yet Mr. Fox had just read the entire bill, which provides for the most perfect rest on the first day of the week, and exempts only those who actually rest on the seventh day. In his entire speech he utterly ignored the plain provisions of the bill, and aimed to convey the idea that if passed it would allow every man to do as he might please. The Tribune says that Mr. Fox ‘delivered one of his characteristic speeches.’ If this is so, we must suppose that the habit of technical quibbling has, in his long practice as a criminal lawyer, become so fixed that it is impossible for him to state a case on its merits. When men object to a law which guards the Sunday as strictly as would the one under consideration, which allows no one to perform any labor, except those who conscientiously keep the seventh day, and them only on condition that they work in such a way that no hyper-sensitive Sunday-observer may consider himself disturbed, it is very evident that they want a law that shall have not a vestige of tolerance.
“The ‘strong argument’ which Mr. Fox brought to bear in support of his assertion that the law would not amount to anything unless it were made universal, was that ‘it is a law of nature that men should rest one day in seven; that everything that lives must have a weekly rest day, or must suffer, and that all civilized nations should provide for the observance of this law of nature.’ Here again we see the quibbling sophistry of the criminal lawyer. The bill, as worded, provides for a weekly rest day for every individual in the State, and Mr. Fox knows this as well as anybody. Would he have the assurance to say that this law of nature can be satisfied only by rest on Sunday? Is it not possible that a man can recuperate his wasted energies if his weekly rest falls upon Saturday? Is there anything in the law of nature which says that a man must rest on Sunday alone or suffer, physically?—No; there is no such law of nature, except in the nature of selfish and designing men who, in order to foist upon the people a Sabbath of their own making, are willing to trample upon the rights of any one who conscientiously differs with them. If those men were honest in their claim that all they want is a law to protect the laboring man, so that soulless capital may not grind him down seven days in the week, and that the sole basis of their proposed law is that it is a civil necessity, they would not object to the bill as it now stands. According to the provisions of that bill, no man may labor on Sunday unless he has taken his rest the day before. Neither can he compel his employe to labor. Every man must rest one day in the week; and yet these disinterested philanthropists, whose sole object is to provide for the physical well-being of the poor laboring men, are not contented. Is it possible that there is any one so blind as to see no sinister motive in their plea for the Sunday law?
“‘But,’ said Dr. Briggs, indorsing the sophistry of Mr. Fox, ‘if laboring men are to have a rest day, it must be the same day for all. Suppose the county recorder keeps Saturday, and the police judge keeps Sunday, and another public officer should keep Friday; there would be hopeless confusion, and no business could be transacted.’ We can ease the Doctor’s mind in this regard. Those who keep the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath, and who request the Legislature to respect their religious convictions by granting them permission to quietly labor on Sunday, are not office-seekers. They do not ask to be made county recorders, nor justices of the peace, nor to fill any other public office; they simply ask toleration in the discharge of their conscientious convictions; and certainly since, as the Doctor said, they are less than one per cent of the population, there is not very much cause to fear that the business of the courts will be impeded very soon by Sabbath-keeping officers. No; the Sabbath-keepers say to their Sunday friends: You may monopolize all the civil offices. You are so greatly in the majority that we could not hinder you from doing so, even if we were inclined to. We do not ask you to violate your conscience by doing business with us on Sunday; we simply ask that we be not molested in doing our own business in a way that shall interfere with nobody. But they are met with the reply that this cannot be granted. These ministers of the gospel whose fundamental principle is, ‘Whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them,’ say to this handful of conscientious Sabbath-keepers: ‘We cannot allow you this privilege; there are more of us than there are of you, and you must submit to us, even though the following out of your convictions would not disturb us; since we have a law which gives us all the protection we could ask for, we will not allow you any toleration.’ It is evident that with the Sunday law champions, might alone makes right.”
“Let us notice a little further this law of nature which they prate so much about, and which prompts them, as they say, to ask a Sunday law. Man’s physical nature demands weekly periods of rest. If the laboring man does not get this, he will suffer, and there are so many amusements going on that he will not get it unless he is compelled to take it by law. We grant the necessity of weekly rest; but while they are so carefully looking after their physical wants, why do they not go further? It is a fact that man’s physical nature requires daily rest, and the physical demand for this daily rest is far more imperative than it is for the weekly rest. A man could work for months every day in the week and suffer no irreparable injury physically; but if he should labor six consecutive days without taking any sleep, he would find himself a total wreck. Now if the State has a right to compel men to take weekly rest because their physical nature demands it, then it must be the duty of the State to compel laboring men to take adequate daily rest, which his physical nature far more imperiously demands. If their plea for a Sunday law from a physical stand-point amounts to anything, they should, in order to be consistent, request a law compelling laboring men to remain in bed from ten o’clock at night till five o’clock in the morning. Will they ever do this?—Not by any means. Why not?—Because they are not actuated in the least by a solicitude for the welfare of the laboring man, but by a selfish desire to force all to accept a religious institution of their own devising.
“‘But,’ says Dr. Briggs, ‘the law does not forbid that a man shall keep any other day that he pleases. If he wishes to keep any other day he may, but there must be only one day recognized by law, and that must be Sunday, because the majority regard that day; and the man who wishes to observe another day must submit to the inconvenience of keeping both.’ Very magnanimous this, indeed. Perhaps one who has not given much thought to the matter may think that it is all right, but we shall show by plain reasoning that it is religious intolerance. Both religion and nature require that a man should rest one day in seven. The commandment of God from Sinai says, ‘Six days shalt thou labor, and do all thy work, but the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work.’ We may not construe these words as a commandment to labor upon six days in the week; but that to labor on six days is every man’s God-given privilege, no man can deny. No divine precept requires more than one rest day in the week, and Dr. Briggs himself stated that one day in the week more than suffices to recuperate man’s wasted energies. Consequently the ‘law of nature’ cannot demand more than one day in the week. Therefore we say that it is a self-evident proposition that if it is man’s religious duty to rest one day in seven, it is equally his religious privilege to labor on the other six days. Now here are people who conscientiously follow the plain requirement of the decalogue, and rest on the seventh day of the week. Their conscience demands this as a religious duty. Necessity compels them to labor six days in the week to support their families, and religion grants them this privilege. Now, if after they have complied with the divine requirement to rest upon the seventh day, the law steps in and compels them to rest also upon another day, their religious privileges are interfered with. If a man’s religious convictions compel him to rest upon a certain day as the Sabbath, those same religious convictions, combined with physical necessity, compel him to labor on the other six days. And any law which punishes him for such labor is simply persecution for conscience’ sake. The punishment administered to him is just as much for his rest upon the seventh day as it is for his labor upon the first. They may talk all they please about the law’s not hindering a man from observing the seventh day, but they know very well that its tendency is in the direction of forcing a man to labor upon that day. And inasmuch as the first three sections of the bill under consideration provide that every one whose conscience does not require him to keep the seventh day shall rest upon the first day, and the fourth section simply grants conscientious observers of the seventh day immunity from penalty, provided that they do not disturb anybody, we can come to no other conclusion than that those who object to this saving clause are actuated in their desire for a Sunday law, not so much by love for the Sunday, as by hatred for the Sabbath.”
—Contentment springs from humility.