A NEW ARGUMENT AGAINST CAPITAL PUNISHMENT

25%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 22, 1887

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 12.

Read the full edition

A NEW ARGUMENT AGAINST CAPITAL PUNISHMENT.

THOSE who disclaim against the practice of allowing condemned murderers to take their exit from this present life via the gallows, will find themselves indebted to the Spiritualistic literature of the Banner of Light for an argument against capital punishment which probably never forced itself upon their minds; at least we have never seen it mentioned anywhere before. This is a little strange, too, because it is a very powerful argument, one which might well cause most of our administrators of justice to think twice before sanctioning this extreme measure in their dealings with convicted criminals, if it did not cause the cold chills to creep over some at the recollection of what their thoughtlessness has possibly occasioned in the past. With those who are so simple as to still hold to the ancient belief that “a living dog is better than a dead lion,” this argument will have no weight; but the great majority who are of the opposite belief ought to comprehend it in its full magnitude. They may have argued a great deal about the evils of subjecting the body to the barbarities of this mode of punishment, but did they ever stop to think about the soul which was compelled to take its flight from the body in this ignominious manner, and of the course which that soul, thus liberated to the sphere of so much greater power and knowledge, would very likely pursue in the matter afterward? The illumination cast on this subject by the Banner of Light, enables us to see what takes place when such carelessness as the laws of some States sanction is exercised on these unpleasant occasions:—
“Mrs. Druse, the Herkimer uxoricide, was executed on Monday last. Thus another human being has been suddenly ushered into the spirit world filled with hate upon those instrumental in sending her there, where she does not belong, and should not have gone until nature had fulfilled its mission in this respect. She committed a great crime, to be sure. She never would have done so had she not possessed a fiendish disposition to begin with. She is now free—free to return to earth, and, through psychological laws, be instrumental in having other murders committed, simply out of revenge for being taken off in the manner she was. It would have been far better had she been placed in close confinement during her natural life.”
As spiritualistic ideas are now getting to be so prevalent, it would be strange if the numerous class who are opposed to capital punishment should allow such a powerful argument as this to remain longer in the background. L. A. S.