ELD. CANRIGHT'S CHANGE OF FAITH.
By George I. Butler
It will surprise many of the readers of the REVIEW to learn that Eld. D. M. Canright, who has been long and extensively known among us, has given up nearly all the views of Seventh-day Adventists which distinguish us from other denominations, and expects to unite with one of the popular churches. This has come to us all like a sudden shock. It is only within four or five weeks that we had any intimation of such a change. Up to that time Eld. Canright seemed to be earnest and devoted in the work in which we are engaged. We then received a letter from him in which he stated some of the difficulties in his mind. He made a visit to us at Battle Creek, when these things were talked over with the writer and several of our prominent brethren. It was evident that his mind was fully made up to close his connection with our people. He made an appointment with the writer to be with him at Otsego, his home church, when he wished to make a statement before the church of his change of belief, and give some of the reasons for this change. Thursday afternoon, Feb. 17, we met with the church at Otsego, when he spent the better part of an hour in presenting his views and feelings relative to leaving our denomination, stating that he could no longer believe in the leading doctrines held by us, and urging strongly that he might be dropped from the church because he could no longer agree with us. His wife took substantially the same position, and it was thought best to grant their pressing request; and thus he closed his connection with us as a people. He desired that a brief statement from himself might be published in the REVIEW, concerning his feelings and wishes. We herewith present his statement verbatim as sent for publication, which all will be very anxious to read:— “DEAR BRETHREN AND SISTERS: Through the kindness of the editors, I am permitted to address to you these few parting words. I have so far changed my views on some of the vital points of our faith and practice that it is no longer possible for me to labor with our people. This has caused me as deep sorrow as it has my brethren and sisters. I have been personally acquainted with so many of our people whom I love dearly, have labored pleasantly with so many of our ministers, and have interwoven so much of the labor and hopes of my life with the work that it has been a terrible trial to me to leave them all at last. “It grieves me to know that our people, holding the views that they do, can no longer regard me as a Christian, or have any hope of my salvation. But my convictions of truth and duty were so strong that I was compelled to follow them, or live in constant condemnation. Personally, I have not one word of fault to find either with the church where I live, or with those with whom I have labored. I have been treated justly, liberally, and tenderly. There is not one hard feeling between us, as far as I know. It will always give me pleasure to regard our people and speak of them as an honest and devout people. But believing that they are mistaken in their views, of course I cannot preach with them. Though I should be glad to do so, yet it would be unfair to ask the privilege of giving my reasons for doing as I have done. They are perfectly satisfactory to me, and no one else is responsible for them. “The brethren all know that for years I have been troubled with doubts on some points, so much so that I quit preaching more than once; but my attachment for our people was so strong that each time I was led to believe that I must be in the dark, and that it would be the safest way to follow the judgment of my brethren. This I tried to do, and for a time succeeded in persuading myself that I was satisfied. But it was always only a compromise. My judgment was not satisfied. This winter a question came up which affected our position upon the law, and of course that ended the matter. “Allow me to say that I have not lost any of my faith in the Bible, nor in the Christian religion; nor have I any idea of going off on some side issue, holding on to one part of the message and opposing another part; for it must all stand or fall together. I expect to labor as a minister of Christ as long as I live. I have not the slightest inclination to infidelity, Spiritualism, or any lax system of religion which draws away from the pure and simple gospel of Christ. I design immediately to unite with some evangelical church where I can find the most piety and practical religion, and there work the best I can for the glory of God and the salvation of men. My wife heartily joins with me in this. With many prayers and the best of wishes for your spiritual prosperity, and asking the same for ourselves, I remain sincerely your brother in hope of the mercy of God. D. M. C.” In our interview at Otsego, there was no unpleasant language used, no unkind expressions; and though, of course, there was great sadness of heart to think that one so long associated with us should depart from the faith we hold so dear, yet everything passed off pleasantly. It may be well to briefly state some of the positions taken in our interview at Otsego, as many of the readers of the REVIEW will be anxious to learn concerning the matter. He stated that when he first accepted the Seventh-day Adventist doctrines, for a time he believed implicitly in them all without a doubt; but many years ago, after trials came between him and some occupying a leading position in the work, he was thrown into doubt and perplexity, and remained in this condition more or less for some fifteen years. While fully believing some of the doctrines held, others looked doubtful to him; but as every point in the system of faith held by Seventh-day Adventists was mutually dependent on other points, all being mutually connected in one system, so that not one point could be removed without destroying the whole, he had not been able to settle the matter in his own mind, and so had been in uncertainty for a long time. Several times he had stopped preaching, feeling that he could go no further; then when the matter was brought before him in a forcible manner by his friends, he thought perhaps he was in the dark, and would then try to believe it all and commence to labor again. But now he had come to a point where he no longer believed that the ten commandments were binding upon Christians, and had given up the law, the Sabbath, the messages, the sanctuary, our position upon the United States in prophecy, the “Testimonies,” health reform, the ordinance of humility, etc., etc. He also said that he did not believe that the papacy had changed the Sabbath; and though he did not directly state it, yet his language intimated that he would probably keep Sunday. When asked concerning the papacy, which was to change the time and law of the Most High, spoken of in Dan. 7:25, he did not think that referred to the ten commandments, but to some gospel ordinance or civil law. On some of these questions he evidently has not yet become settled. He expects to unite with the Methodists, Baptists, or some other evangelical denomination, and labor still in the ministry as long as he lives. He thought that the Seventh-day Adventists were too narrow in their ideas, and that in quoting as much as they did from the Old Testament they were going back into the moonlight rather than experiencing the sunshine of the gospel. He thought that we were exalting the law above Christ. He said that he thought there was a larger percentage of good Christians among our people in proportion to their numbers than among any other denomination he knew of. He expressed a high appreciation of and confidence in some of our leading men, believing them to be honest, devoted servants of Christ. He said he was perfectly satisfied with the treatment he had received among Seventh-day Adventists. He had no fault to find with them on that score, and felt that they had used him in all respects as well as Christians should. He still claimed to believe that the coming of Christ was near, making the same application of Daniel 2 and 7 and Matthew 24 that he always had, but did not believe there was to be any special message preceding Christ's second coming, in the sense in which Seventh-day Adventists teach. It will seem most surprising to the large number who have read Eld. Canright's writings, and heard him tell how strongly he has believed this doctrine, to read these statements. And it is astonishing to us all how he could change so quickly and radically. There are facts, however, which to some of us who are well acquainted with him, make it less surprising than it will be to most of the readers of this article. This is really the fifth time that Eld. Canright has virtually given up many of the leading doctrines held by our people. Indeed, for the last fifteen years there have been times when he ceased to preach altogether, and seemed to be in great darkness and discouragement, and under powerful temptation, so that his best friends felt most anxious for him. Then, when he would see his mistakes and make confessions, he would be greatly blessed in so doing, and for quite a space of time afterward would seem to be as strong in the faith as any man could be. After coming out of these dark, discouraging periods, he would seem to enjoy labor very much, and quite a measure of God's blessing; but when discouragement came upon him, all this seemed to fade away from his mind, and he would go back to his former doubts and discouragements as before. Large numbers of our people will not forget the Jackson camp-meeting two years ago last fall, when Eld. Canright took his stand again after having ceased to labor for one or two years, and how affecting was the confession he made in public there, and repeated through the REVIEW. The reader will find this confession in another column of this paper. Here he claimed that the truth never before looked so plain to him. It was, indeed, a very affecting confession, and the Spirit of God seemed to come very near. He claimed here to have a new conversion, and said that he knew the Spirit of God greatly rested down upon him and the meeting. It is a great mystery to us how he can disown these experiences where the Spirit of God greatly blessed him. Yet he has taken his position at last against the whole truth. But we forbear to further comment upon these things. We have felt exceedingly sad to part in our religious connection with one whom we have long esteemed as a dear brother. We feel that he has made a great and sad mistake. But we have no fears in regard to the effect of this apostasy upon our people and work in general. Eld. Canright's fluctuations and changes are too well known by many to influence very deeply the minds of those who believe the truth from the mighty evidences presented in God's word, which sustain it. The belief of our people is not tied to one man or any set of men. They believe as they do because God's word thus teaches. Eld. Canright will never be able to answer the arguments he has a thousand times presented in favor of the truth. The most astonishing thing about it is that the very position he has triumphantly refuted in many debates, he now accepts. The argument is as strong now as ever, but the weakness of Bro. Canright is plainly manifest. We personally entertain the kindest of feelings for him. And our great regret is, that as the message is beginning to go with mighty power, reaching its broad arms around the world, manifesting its superiority to opposing influences, he should go back to popular theology, and unite with those that hate the truth of God. Many others have apostatized in the past, such as Hall, Snook, Brinkerhoff, and others, but this did not affect the progress of the work. We expect that doubtless there will be many other cases in the future. We have always looked for this, as the light which God has given us plainly intimates the fact that there will be such apostates. “Nevertheless the foundation of God standeth sure, having this seal, The Lord knoweth them that are his.” 2 Tim. 2:19. “But he that shall endure unto the end, the same shall be saved.” Matt. 24:13. G. I. B.