AdventAI

PREACHING DOCTRINE.

By William Brickey

From Review and Herald, Vol. 64, No. 30., July 26, 1887

BY WILLIAM BRICKEY.

I have often been invited to preach, with the gentle caution, “Don’t preach any doctrine.” One minister was particularly solicitous one Sunday to have me fill his appointment, but said he, “Don’t preach any doctrine.” Another gentleman once wrote me to come and deliver a course of lectures, in a place about twenty miles distant, but did not forget the advice, “Don’t come to propagate any particular doctrine.”

To hear some people talk, one would think that doctrine was as dangerous as the diphtheria, and twice as contagious. Christ taught doctrine, and I have never known any one to be injured by what he taught. A few quotations from the Bible on this point will serve to enlighten those whose minds are thus beclouded. In Mark 4:2 we read that Christ “said unto them in his doctrine;” “the people were astonished at his doctrine” (Matt. 7:28); “they were astonished at his doctrine” (Luke 4:32); and in Rom. 6:17; Titus 1:9; 2:1, we find that the apostles taught doctrine.

“All Scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable,” for what?—“For doctrine.” Then we see that the very first thing for which the Scripture is good, is doctrine. But there seems to be a particular portion that is especially good for doctrine.

We know that the law is good. It was made for the lawless, the disobedient, for murderers, liars, and every other person who is walking contrary to sound doctrine. 1 Tim. 1:8–10. Ah! this is what troubles them. Were it not for the fact that the law is sound doctrine, and condemns everything that is contrary to it, there would be no trouble. But if all Scripture is profitable for doctrine (2 Tim. 3:16), how can we preach the Scripture without preaching doctrine?—We cannot; therefore Paul says, “Preach the word” (of God). Why?—“For the time will come when they will not endure sound doctrine.” 2 Tim. 4:2, 3. Surely we have reached that time. It is more agreeable to have the ear tickled, than it is to have the hard heart broken.

Dassel, Minn.p. 469

THE PERFECTION OF THE DECALOGUE.

We read in the nineteenth psalm, “The law of Jehovah is perfect,” and this is exactly and literally true. It is therefore an exception to what generally obtains in this world. All men acquiesce in the couplet of Pope,—

“Whoever thinks a faultless piece to see, Thinks what ne’er was, nor is, nor e’er shall be,”

which simply reiterates what was said two thousand years before in Holy Writ, “I have seen an end of all perfection.” But the same writer proceeds immediately to say, “Thy commandment is exceeding broad.” Incompleteness belongs to all the works of man, but the work of God is like himself, perfect, and that not in the sense conveyed in the well-known verse of the poet-laureate,—

“Faultily faultless, icily regular, splendidly null!”

but in the higher sense of being in substance, form, expression, and tone, exactly adapted to its purpose. This has been denied, not only by avowed enemies of our holy religion, but even by some who minister acceptably at its altar. The subject, therefore, is worthy of consideration. The purpose of the ten commandments was to reveal a rule of duty for men, and this we insist was accomplished in a way that leaves nothing to desire. The truth may be shown,—

1. By the nature of the law itself. Its contents are just what they ought to be. They enjoin only what is right; they forbid only what is wrong. They err neither in excess nor in defect. No error or incongruity can be detected from beginning to end. The ground that is covered takes in all the relations and interests of man, the recognition, the worship, the reverence, and the proportion of time he owes to God, all relative duties arising from the family, the household, and the State, the regard due to the life, the domestic circle, the property, and the good name of one’s neighbor; and then the whole winds up with a precept that shows that thought, as well as speech and act, is included in the obligation. No modern theory of practical ethics discloses any duty which is not contained in the Sinaitic summary. That summary is suited to all lands, all races, all times, all states of society. It contains nothing that is sectional, or national, or fortuitous, or temporary. The fifth commandment may seem an exception, because the promise attached to it mentions “the land which the Lord thy God giveth thee,” whence some have rashly inferred that the whole decalogue was simply a Jewish statute, and destitute of universal significance and applicability. But the impropriety of this inference is shown by the language of the apostle Paul in the opening of the sixth chapter of his Epistle to the Ephesians. Writing to a Gentile church nearly all of whose members were of heathen origin (chap. 2:11–13; 4:17–19), he enforces the duty of children to their parents by citing this precept, altering the last clause so that it reads, “and thou mayest live long upon the earth,” thus clearly teaching that the reference to the Holy Land in the original statute was a provisional feature which in no degree limited or impaired the world-wide and perpetual scope of the obligation. It is clear, therefore, that the code is addressed to man as man everywhere and always. It lays hold of Jew and Greek, Barbarian and Scythian, male and female, bond and free, high and low, all nations, all classes without exception; for whatever other differences obtain, all stand upon the same footing as rational, responsible beings, and alike need some authoritative directory of conduct.

But, while the code is thus comprehensive and far-reaching, it is also succinct and brief, as a manual always should be. It resolves human duty into its constituent elements, and then sums up these elements into a decade of precepts whose form is not to be mistaken. Obedience to parents, the very earliest of earthly obligations, stands for the whole series of relative duties. And rightly, for the good child will naturally be the good husband, and master, and citizen. Nor is it conceivable that one relation should be defined and cared for, while others, equally natural and permanent and general, should be neglected. In like manner when the code takes up the rights of man in society, the leading overt act of gross transgression is selected and specified, because the prohibition of it means the prohibition of all lesser forms of the same sin. And the last precept lays particular stress upon the heart, out of which are the issues of life. Thus there is provided a vade mecum of the most satisfactory kind. A little summary having no more parts than can be counted on the fingers of both hands contains the whole substance of the moral law. It realizes the proverbial saying, “The Iliad in a nutshell.” A child can easily learn it by heart. A man can recall its precepts anywhere. It is a portable manual always available. As a summation of ethics it has never been surpassed save once, and then it was by its divine Author—when our Lord, in answer to the question of a lawyer (Matt. 22:37–40), compressed the ten commandments into two. Apart from this most felicitous condensation, the decalogue remains the briefest, clearest, and most complete statement of human duty the world has ever seen.

But the order in which its precepts are arranged is as remarkable as their nature. The two tables treat first of what belongs to God, then of what is due to man, with the clear implication not only that the former is superior to the latter, but also that it is the basis upon which it rests. Ethics, so far from being a substitute for religion, is its offspring and dependent. The first table begins with the ultimate fact of the divine existence, then prescribes the way in which God is to be worshiped, next the reverence with which every manifestation of his nature is to be regarded, after which comes the period of time to be consecrated to his service, and the duty which is due to those who are God’s representatives on earth, whether parents or other superiors. The second table begins with life, because the dead have no more to do with earth, and then, after this most necessary provision, guards personal purity and the integrity of the domestic circle, after which comes the right of property, a right so nearly connected in all lands and ages with the preservation of social order. This is followed by a guaranty for the maintenance of truth and charity of speech, and the whole concludes with a precept that shows that in all cases it is not so much external obedience as the state of the heart that is required. Now this arrangement of the divine commands is the best conceivable. It could hardly be altered in the least without injury. It puts first what is first in reality. The claims of God transcend those of all his creatures, and attention to these is a condition precedent to the discharge of all other duties. If experience teaches anything, it is that a divine sanction is indispensable to a proper and permanent restraint upon human conduct. To love God is the first and great commandment. In like manner the second table proceeds, taking up in turn the chief social obligations of mankind, and riveting them all by a final precept which lays its firm grasp upon the inner man of the heart.

Once more, the perfection of the decalogue may be argued from its manifest reasonableness. If there be no God, then religion does not exist, and it is folly to talk of sacred precepts; but if there be a God, the maker of heaven and earth, and sole ruler of the children of men, the one in whom we live and move and have our being, then the duties prescribed in the first table are due unto him. Nothing less can meet his exalted claims. Every feeling of propriety and gratitude summons us to render to him love, honor, reverence, worship, and obedience. And so with the other part of the “ten words.” If men be a race, if they have sprung from a common ancestor, if they are of one blood, if they are linked together, not casually or temporarily, but by a bond of nature, then beyond question they owe to each other all that the second table enjoins. They are members one of another, and as such must be governed invariably by the law of love. There is nothing arbitrary or capricious in any precept. All spring from a common source, and are self-commended by their bearing upon human welfare. And as far as the decalogue is obeyed in its spirit, just so far is earth made to resemble heaven.

But the decalogue is no exception to the rule that in this world nothing human or divine escapes criticism, and accordingly fault has been found with it, and sometimes even by those who are within the Christian pale. People have tried to identify it with the moral character of the people to whom it was first given, just as if it were a natural development of the human faculties instead of being a descent from above just as really as the “great sheet let down from heaven by four corners,” which Peter saw at Joppa. Its constant claim is that it came to man, not from him. It expresses, therefore, not the moral ideas which he has attained, but those which are held by his Maker and by him put into the form of a statute.

(1.) Of the older class of objections the most common is that no provision has anywhere been made for friendship or the love of country. But the former is not properly a subject of legislation, nor could its terms or degrees be intelligently prescribed. In itself it is a felicity rather than a duty, and it is more properly to be placed among the rewards of moral excellence than among its obligations. Indeed, the moment it is made a duty, the fine aroma of the relation exhales, and its chief charm disappears. Its whole value lies in its spontaneous character. As for the duty of patriotism, that may be safely left to the action of natural causes. Experience shows that the great danger here is, not that men will fail in love of their country, but that they will become so absorbed in it as to forget the rights of individuals and the immutable claims of humanity and justice. And when patriotism is pampered to excess, it ceases to be a virtue, and is rather “the bond and cement of a guilty confederation.” Nor if the relative duties (of rulers and ruled), fairly implied in the fifth commandment, are faithfully discharged by each party, is there any reason to fear that men will fall short of the attachment to their country which is universally recognized as appropriate and becoming. The law, therefore, without enjoining the duty, lays the basis for its rational and consistent exercise.

(2.) The Rev. R. W. Dale, in his excellent little work on the ten commandments, says that they “were not intended to constitute a complete code of morals. There are many sins which they do not condemn, and there are many virtues which they do not enforce. The symmetrical completeness of human systems of ethics is not to be found either in the Old Testament or the New; and certainly we have no right to expect that these laws, given to a race which must have suffered the gravest moral injury from protracted slavery to a heathen nation, should cover the whole ground of moral duty.” If this be so, it is very singular that, while almost everything else in Judaism has become obsolete, this code has kept, and still keeps, its place in the theology, the catechisms, and the ritual, of the Christian world. The whole church cannot have been mistaken for eighteen centuries. The omissions which some detect are seeming rather than real. It is true that the second table contains only a series of naked prohibitions, but the principle underlying these negations sweeps the whole field of human duty. The inward and spiritual character of the morality here enjoined is made abundantly plain by the closing precept, which casts its piercing light upon all that precedes. It does not annex any additional province of obligation, but affirms that the law covers every movement of the mind, as well as the actions of the body, and brings the whole man, inner and outer, under the sway of duty. It was this tenth commandment that wrought a spiritual revolution in the soul of the great apostle (Rom. 7:7), and led him to the true experimental knowledge of his natural condition and character. Nor was this due to any strained application of the words, but rather to the strict and natural interpretation of their meaning. Moreover, when the rich young ruler came to our Lord with the weighty question, “What good thing shall I do, that I may have eternal life?” the plain categorical answer was, “If thou wilt enter into life, keep the commandments.” Now, it is impossible to explain or justify this answer save on the principle that the commandments comprehend all human duty. It is true that the subsequent words of the Saviour show that he intended to convince the amiable ruler of his self-ignorance, and bring him to a proper sense of sin; but this fact in no way lessens the intrinsic force of his declaration as to the weight and significance of the decalogue.

(Continued next week.)